Uncovering and Categorizing Social Biases in Text-to-SQL

Yan Liu, Yan Gao, Zhe Su, Xiaokang Chen, Elliott Ash, Jian-Guang Lou

TL;DR

This paper tackles the critical issue of social biases in Text-to-SQL models, which are increasingly used in sensitive administrative applications. The authors introduce a novel benchmark, BiaSpider, to uncover and categorize these biases, revealing that even models with similar accuracy can exhibit vastly different levels of bias.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Text-to-SQL models translate natural language questions into SQL queries, bridging the gap between users and complex databases. These models are widely adopted in administrative sectors like banking and government, where biased decisions can have significant real-world consequences. While existing Text-to-SQL datasets are often "clean" and neutral, the authors argue that social biases, inherent in large pre-trained language models (PLMs), can still manifest in downstream applications. These biases can lead to unfair or discriminatory outcomes, amplifying societal stereotypes. The paper aims to systematically uncover, categorize, and measure these biases in Text-to-SQL models.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology involves a novel paradigm for constructing social bias benchmarks for structured data. This paradigm focuses on altering both queries and tables to elicit stereotypical correlations. Specifically, they leverage GPT-3 to:

  1. Identify Human-Relevant Tables: Filter out tables not pertaining to human contexts, as social bias is only meaningful in such scenarios.
  2. Identify Human-Relevant Queries: Further refine queries to ensure they are relevant to human contexts.
  3. Paraphrase Database Queries: Introduce judgmental modifiers (negative, positive, comparative) into neutral queries to create biased versions.

This process results in the BiaSpider benchmark, which is then used to evaluate Text-to-SQL models. They also analyze different types of judgmental modifiers and their impact.

Datasets

  • Spider: Used as the base for constructing the BiaSpider benchmark.
  • BiaSpider: A newly introduced benchmark specifically designed to measure social biases in Text-to-SQL models. It consists of three versions (v1, v2, v3) with an increasing number of demographic dimensions.
  • BooksCorpus and English Wikipedia: Used as pre-training datasets for BERT, BART, and T5 models, and for neutrality comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hidden Biases in "Neutral" Data: Even when Text-to-SQL models are fine-tuned on seemingly neutral datasets, social biases from their pre-trained language models are inherited and can emerge in real-world applications.
  • Two Main Bias Categories: The paper identifies two primary categories of social biases in Text-to-SQL:
  • Stereotypical Correlation: Models build unjustified links between judgmental expressions and specific demographics (e.g., associating "dangerous" with "Muslim").
  • Discriminative Comparison: Models unfairly judge individuals or groups as better or worse based on characteristics like ethnicity or religion.
  • Bias vs. Accuracy Trade-off: Models with similar task accuracy can exhibit vastly different levels of social bias, highlighting the need for users to consider this trade-off.
  • Impact of Pre-trained Models: The choice of the underlying pre-trained language model significantly influences the level of social bias in Text-to-SQL models.

Key Results

  • The study found that Text-to-SQL models, even when fine-tuned on neutral data, demonstrate significant social biases.
  • The RATSQL model (fine-tuned on BERT) exhibited the most severe social bias, as indicated by the highest Bias Score.
  • Models fine-tuned on BART and T5 showed fewer social biases compared to BERT-based models.
  • The BiaSpider benchmark effectively elicits social biases without generating illogical SQL queries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncovering vs. Solving: The current work focuses on uncovering and analyzing social biases but does not provide a direct solution to mitigate them.
  • Scalability Verification: While the proposed paradigm for benchmark construction is scalable, its efficacy with other Text-to-SQL datasets needs further verification.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future work should focus on developing methods to solve the social bias problem in Text-to-SQL. They also propose that the BiaSpider benchmark can be extended to other Text-to-SQL datasets. The paper also raises questions about when models should respond to subjective judgments in queries and how to handle cases where databases lack relevant information for such judgments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Large pre-trained language models are acknowledged to carry social bias towards different demographics, which can further amplify existing stereotypes in our society and cause even more harm. Text-to-SQL is an important task, models of which are mainly adopted by administrative industries, where unfair decisions may lead to catastrophic consequences. However, existing Text-to-SQL models are trained on clean, neutral datasets, such as Spider and WikiSQL. This, to some extent, cover up social bias in models under ideal conditions, which nevertheless may emerge in real application scenarios. In this work, we aim to uncover and mitigate social bias in Text-to-SQL models. We summarize the categories of social bias that may occur in structural data for Text-to-SQL models. We build test benchmarks and reveal that models with similar task accuracy can contain social bias at very different rates. We show how to take advantage of our methodology to assess and mitigate social bias in the downstream Text-to-SQL task.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2023uncovering,
  author = {Yan Liu and Yan Gao and Zhe Su and Xiaokang Chen and Elliott Ash and Jian-Guang Lou},
  title = {{Uncovering and Categorizing Social Biases in Text-to-SQL}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.18653/v1/2023.acl-long.759},
}
Figure