Unconventional gapping behavior in a kagome superconductor

Md Shafayat Hossain, Qi Zhang, Eun Sang Choi, Danilo Ratkovski, Bernhard Lüscher, Yongkai Li, Yu-Xiao Jiang, Maksim Litskevich, Zi‐Jia Cheng, Jia‐Xin Yin, Tyler A. Cochran, Brian Casas, Byung‐Hoon Kim, Xiàn Yáng, Jinjin Liu, Yugui Yao, A. F. Bangura, Zhiwei Wang, Mark H. Fischer, Titus Neupert, Luis Balicas, M. Zahid Hasan

TL;DR

Researchers have uncovered a "band-selective" pairing mechanism in the kagome superconductor $\text{CsV}_3\text{Sb}_5$, where two superconducting gaps emerge almost independently on different electron bands. This discovery challenges the standard multiband model—where one dominant gap induces superconductivity in others—and provides a potential unifying framework for previously contradictory observations in this class of materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In materials with multiple Fermi surfaces (multiband systems), understanding how superconductivity emerges is notoriously difficult. The conventional "multiband scenario" assumes a primary band becomes superconducting and then "drags" other bands along via inter-band interactions, causing gaps to open simultaneously.

The kagome-lattice material $\text{CsV}_3\text{Sb}_5$ has become a major focus in condensed matter physics because it hosts a unique mix of topology, charge density waves (CDW), and superconductivity. However, experimental results have been conflicting: some studies suggested a conventional, fully gapped state, while others found evidence of "nodes" (points where the gap vanishes) and time-reversal symmetry breaking. This paper seeks to resolve these contradictions by investigating the gapping behavior across different temperature and magnetic field regimes.

Methods

The authors employed a multi-pronged experimental approach to probe the bulk properties of $\text{CsV}_3\text{Sb}_5$ single crystals and exfoliated flakes (~90 nm thick):

  • Electrical Transport: Measuring resistivity to determine the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) and the upper critical magnetic field ($H_{c2}$).
  • Thermal Transport: Using a one-heater, three-thermometer method to measure longitudinal thermal conductivity ($\kappa_{xx}/T$). Unlike electrical current, heat is carried by delocalized quasiparticles even in the superconducting state, making it a sensitive probe for gap nodes.
  • Thermodynamics: Utilizing high-resolution specific heat ($C/T$) measurements via a SiN membrane-based nanocalorimeter to quantify the electronic density of states.
  • Angular Mapping: Rotating the magnetic field both out-of-plane and in-plane to observe how the superconducting state responds to different crystallographic directions.

Datasets

As an experimental condensed matter physics paper, it does not use "training" datasets in the machine learning sense. Instead, it generates primary experimental data from:

  • Sample S1 and S2: High-quality $\text{CsV}_3\text{Sb}_5$ flakes encapsulated in hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN).
  • Theoretical Benchmarks: Data is compared against the Tinkham formula (for 2D superconductivity), the Ginzburg-Landau model, and the Pauli paramagnetic limit ($\mu_0 H_p \approx 1.84 \times T_c$).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two-Regime Superconductivity: The team identified two distinct regimes (I and II) separated at approximately 0.8–1 K. Crucially, they found no evidence of a formal phase transition between them, suggesting a gradual "hand-off" between bands.
  • Decoupled Gaps: In Regime I (high temperature), a primary gap opens, but a large fraction of electronic states remains "normal" (non-superconducting). In Regime II (low temperature), a second gap forms on a different band, removing this residual weight. This implies the bands are remarkably decoupled.
  • The Anisotropy Switch: One of the most striking "aha" moments was observing that the thermal conductivity anisotropy rotates by 90° when cooling from Regime I to Regime II. This suggests that the second gap has a different symmetry or nodal structure than the first.
  • Pauli Limit Violation: The in-plane upper critical field ($H_{c2,||}$) reached ~10 T, exceeding the theoretical Pauli limit (~6.44 T) by over 50%. This points toward unconventional pairing or strong spin-orbit coupling effects.

Key Results

  • Transition Temperature: Confirmed a bulk $T_c$ of 3.5 K.
  • Specific Heat Jump: The normalized jump at $T_c$ ($\Delta C/\gamma_e \approx 0.6$) is significantly lower than the standard BCS value of 1.42, confirming that only a portion of the Fermi surface participates in the initial transition.
  • Upper Critical Field Enhancement: Observed a pronounced "upturn" in $H_{c2}$ at low temperatures, characteristic of the opening of a second, nearly independent gap.
  • Nodal Evidence: The rapid increase of thermal conductivity at very low magnetic fields suggests that the second gap likely has nodes, allowing quasiparticles to be easily excited.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Direct Nodal Confirmation: While transport data strongly implies a nodal structure in the second gap, more direct spectroscopic evidence (like ultra-low temperature STM) would be beneficial.
  • Impurity Sensitivity: The authors note that disorder usually averages out gap differences. While their samples were "clean," further study is needed to see how robust this band-selective pairing is against chemical doping or defects.
  • CDW Interaction: The paper focuses on the superconducting state, but the exact mechanism by which the underlying charge density wave "prepares" the bands for this selective pairing remains an open theoretical challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

Determining the types of superconducting order in quantum materials is a challenge, especially when multiple degrees of freedom, such as bands or orbitals, contribute to the fermiology and when superconductivity competes, intertwines, or coexists with other symmetry-breaking orders. Here, we study the Kagome-lattice superconductor CsV3Sb5, in which multiband superconductivity coexists with a charge order that substantially reduces the compound's space group symmetries. Through a combination of thermodynamic as well as electrical and thermal transport measurements, we uncover two superconducting regimes with distinct transport and thermodynamic characteristics, while finding no evidence for a phase transition separating them. Thermodynamic measurements reveal substantial quasiparticle weight in a high-temperature regime. At lower temperatures, this weight is removed via the formation of a second gap. The two regimes are sharply distinguished by a pronounced enhancement of the upper critical field at low temperatures and by a switch in the anisotropy of the longitudinal thermal conductivity as a function of in-plane magnetic field orientation. We argue that the band with a gap opening at lower temperatures continues to host low-energy quasiparticles, possibly due to a nodal structure of the gap. Taken together, our results present evidence for band-selective superconductivity with remarkable decoupling of the (two) superconducting gaps. The commonly employed multiband scenario, whereby superconductivity emerges in a primary band and is then induced in other bands appears to fail in this unconventional kagome superconductor. Instead, band-selective superconducting pairing is a paradigm that seems to unify seemingly contradicting results in this intensely studied family of materials and beyond.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hossain2025unconventional,
  author = {Md Shafayat Hossain and Qi Zhang and Eun Sang Choi and Danilo Ratkovski and Bernhard Lüscher and Yongkai Li and Yu-Xiao Jiang and Maksim Litskevich and Zi‐Jia Cheng and Jia‐Xin Yin and Tyler A. Cochran and Brian Casas and Byung‐Hoon Kim and Xiàn Yáng and Jinjin Liu and Yugui Yao and A. F. Bangura and Zhiwei Wang and Mark H. Fischer and Titus Neupert and Luis Balicas and M. Zahid Hasan},
  title = {{Unconventional gapping behavior in a kagome superconductor}},
  booktitle = {Nature Physics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41567-024-02770-z},
}
Figure