Uncertainty Intervals for Robust Bottleneck Assignment

Michael Elad, Tony A. Wood, Chris Manzie, Iman ShamesarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We examine the robustness of bottleneck assignment problems to perturbations in the assignment weights. We derive two algorithms that provide uncertainty bounds for robust assignment. We prove that the bottleneck assignment is guaranteed to be invariant to perturbations which lie within the provided bounds. We apply the method to an example of task assignment for a multi-agent system.

Introduction

In multi-agent systems, such as a fleet of autonomous drones or robotic factory workers, the Bottleneck Assignment Problem (BAP) is a fundamental optimization tool. It aims to minimize the "worst-case" cost—for instance, ensuring the slowest task in a parallel operation is completed as quickly as possible. However, the edge weights (representing time, distance, or cost) used in these calculations are often subject to real-world uncertainties like sensor noise or communication delays.

This research addresses a critical gap: determining individualized robustness bounds for every edge weight. Unlike previous methods that assume uniform error bounds across all edges, this paper provides a framework where each weight can vary independently and simultaneously without invalidating the optimal assignment.

Methodology

The authors introduce two primary algorithms to calculate these "uncertainty intervals" $[L_j, U_j]$ for each edge $e_j$:

  1. Algorithm 2 (Relaxed $\Delta$ Algorithm): This sophisticated approach identifies three critical bottleneck edges—the original bottleneck ($e^*$), the bottleneck if $e^*$ is removed ($e^+$), and the bottleneck if $e^*$ and its incident nodes are removed ($e^-$). By analyzing the gaps between these values, it generates asymmetric intervals. Remarkably, it maintains the same computational complexity as solving the BAP itself.
  2. Algorithm 3 (Naive Algorithm): A faster, linear-time $O(|E|)$ alternative. It calculates bounds based on the simple distance between an edge's weight and the weight of the bottleneck edge.
Example of asymmetric uncertainty intervals for agent-task assignments.

As shown in the example intervals above, robustness is often asymmetric. Many edges can increase or decrease in weight infinitely ($-\infty$ or $+\infty$) without affecting the optimal solution, leading to a "half-space" view of the allowable perturbation set.

Key Results and Scaling

The algorithms were rigorously tested using synthetic benchmarks consisting of 1,000 random bipartite graphs for various problem sizes. The primary metric was the "Minimum Robustness," representing the smallest interval calculated across the graph.

Minimum robustness comparison between Algorithm 2 and Algorithm 3.

The results demonstrate that Algorithm 2 is significantly superior for scaling. While both algorithms see a decrease in robustness as graph density increases (due to more edges having weights close to the bottleneck), Algorithm 2 consistently provides larger, more useful safety margins than the Naive Algorithm.

Conclusion

This work provides a robust mathematical foundation (Theorem 1) for ensuring that bottleneck assignments remain invariant under weight perturbations. By providing individualized, asymmetric intervals with minimal computational overhead, these algorithms offer a practical diagnostic tool for real-time multi-agent systems. Future research will focus on extending these individualized intervals to the Linear Assignment Problem and exploring the geometric implications of these robustness sets.

Summary updated

Abstract

We examine the robustness of bottleneck assignment problems to perturbations in the assignment weights. We derive two algorithms that provide uncertainty bounds for robust assignment. We prove that the bottleneck assignment is guaranteed to be invariant to perturbations which lie within the provided bounds. We apply the method to an example of task assignment for a multi-agent system.
BibTeX
@misc{elad2019uncertainty,
  author = {Michael Elad and Tony A. Wood and Chris Manzie and Iman Shames},
  title = {{Uncertainty Intervals for Robust Bottleneck Assignment}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {2005.11795},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.11795},
}
Figure