Global Sensitivity Analysis for the Linear Assignment Problem

Michael Elad, Tony A. Wood, Chris Manzie, Iman ShamesarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this paper, the following question is addressed: given a linear assignment problem, how much can the all of the individual assignment weights be perturbed without changing the optimal assignment? The extension of results involving perturbations in just one edge or one row/column are presented. Algorithms for the derivation of these bounds are provided. We also show how these bounds may be used to prevent assignment churning in a multi-vehicle guidance scenario.

Introduction: The Challenge of Assignment Churning

In multi-agent robotics, the Linear Assignment Problem (LAP) is frequently employed to optimally pair agents with tasks, minimizing total costs such as fuel consumption or time. However, in practical applications, these costs are rarely static. They are often estimates derived from noisy sensor data or fluctuating communication links.

A significant issue arises when sensor noise causes the "optimal" solution to flicker rapidly between different assignments. This phenomenon, known as assignment churning, leads to inefficient behavior where a vehicle might repeatedly switch its target, resulting in zig-zagging trajectories that waste energy and time. This paper introduces a global sensitivity analysis framework to provide a mathematical "deadband" against such noise.

Methodology: Global Sensitivity and Recursive Refinement

Standard sensitivity analysis typically examines how much a single edge weight can change before the optimal solution shifts. This research extends this to a global context, asking how much all edge weights can vary simultaneously.

The approach is built on three core components:

  1. Element-wise Sensitivity ($s_{ab}$): This is defined as the cost difference between the optimal assignment and the next best assignment that either includes or excludes a specific edge.
  2. The $1/2N$ Bound: The authors prove that if every edge weight is perturbed by no more than its individual sensitivity divided by $2N$ (where $N$ is the number of assignments), the overall optimal solution is guaranteed to remain unchanged.
  3. Recursive Algorithm: To reduce the conservatism of the $1/2N$ bound, a recursive algorithm iteratively updates weights and re-calculates sensitivities until it identifies a critical perturbation—the exact boundary where the solution would change.
Calculated allowable intervals for assignment weights. These bounds define the 'safe zone' within which the optimal assignment remains invariant despite simultaneous perturbations.

Key Insights: Linearity as a Shield

The authors leverage the inherent linearity of the LAP cost function. By understanding how perturbations in "good" edges (those in the optimal set) and "bad" edges (those outside it) interact, they can maintain stability. Crucially, this method allows every weight to vary independently, unlike previous models that required coupled perturbations (e.g., affecting an entire row).

Results and Simulation

The proposed framework was validated through numerical examples and a multi-vehicle guidance simulation. In the simulation, vehicles were tasked with reaching specific targets under noisy conditions.

Vehicle trajectories in a multi-target assignment scenario. The solid blue lines represent the paths taken, demonstrating how the robust strategy maintains stable assignments despite noise, preventing the zig-zagging characteristic of churning.

The "robust" strategy uses the calculated sensitivity bounds as a threshold. If a new, noisy measurement falls within the previously established "safe" intervals, the system retains the current assignment. This approach successfully eliminated churning, leading to shorter, straight-line paths and significantly improved operational efficiency.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The paper provides a rigorous mathematical proof of stability and demonstrates that the recursive algorithm reliably converges to critical perturbations. While highly effective, the current framework assumes a unique initial optimal assignment. Future work will address degenerate cases where multiple optimal solutions exist, explore "Type 1" sensitivity for sub-optimal assignments, and seek closed-form solutions to further reduce computational overhead for large-scale real-time systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the following question is addressed: given a linear assignment problem, how much can the all of the individual assignment weights be perturbed without changing the optimal assignment? The extension of results involving perturbations in just one edge or one row/column are presented. Algorithms for the derivation of these bounds are provided. We also show how these bounds may be used to prevent assignment churning in a multi-vehicle guidance scenario.
BibTeX
@misc{elad2020global,
  author = {Michael Elad and Tony A. Wood and Chris Manzie and Iman Shames},
  title = {{Global Sensitivity Analysis for the Linear Assignment Problem}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2005.11792},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.11792},
}
Figure