Abstract
Highly accurate activation calculations are the basis of radiation protection optimization design, and the accuracy of activation calculations depends on nuclear data. Based on the ENDF/B-VIII.0 and JEFF3.3 decay evaluation libraries, the influence of different nuclear data on the reactor structural material activation calculation is analyzed, and the nuclear data-related sensitivity and uncertainty quantification of radioactivity, decay heat and photon sources are carried out by the global sensitivity analysis method and the Latin Hypercube Sampling method. Based on uncertainty data in ENDF/B-VIII.0 and JEFF3.3, quantifying the uncertainty of radioactivity, decay heat and photon source in the shutdown dose calculation of reactor structural materials, the maximum uncertainty of radioactivity and decay heat reach 4.54 and 1.45%, respectively. The half-life and decay energy of $^{55}\text{Fe}$ are the main sources of uncertainty.
Introduction
Accurate activation calculations are critical for designing radiation shielding, planning reactor decommissioning, and managing radioactive waste. These calculations rely on nuclear data libraries containing the physical properties of isotopes, such as half-lives and decay energies. However, these data points are derived from experiments and inherently carry uncertainties. This study addresses how these small input uncertainties propagate through engineering simulations to affect output results for radioactivity, decay heat, and photon sources in reactor structural materials.
Methodology
The researchers developed a robust workflow to bridge the gap between fundamental nuclear physics and engineering applications. The first step involved updating the activation library for the ORIGEN2 code—a standard tool for isotope depletion and decay—using the latest international data libraries, ENDF/B-VIII.0 and JEFF3.3.
To quantify the propagation of uncertainty, the team coupled ORIGEN2 with the SIMLAB software. They employed the Latin Hypercube Sampling (LHS) method, which allows for statistically significant uncertainty analysis with fewer samples than traditional Monte Carlo methods. Sensitivity analysis was performed using Spearman correlation coefficients to rank which input parameters (e.g., the half-life of a specific isotope) most strongly influenced the final results.
The analysis was tested on a pressurized water reactor (PWR) model based on the NUREG/CR-6115 standard, simulating 50 years of operation followed by 48 years of shutdown.
Results and Discussion
The study found that uncertainty levels are time-dependent, peaking as different isotopes dominate the radiation profile during the cooling period.
- Radioactivity and Decay Heat: The maximum uncertainty in radioactivity reached 4.54% at the 10-year mark post-shutdown. For decay heat, the uncertainty peaked at 1.45% after 5 years.
- The Dominance of $^{55}\text{Fe}$: Iron-55 ($^{55}\text{Fe}$) emerged as the primary source of uncertainty. As iron is the main component of reactor steel and $^{55}\text{Fe}$ has a relatively long half-life (~2.7 years), its decay data uncertainties dominate the error bars for radioactivity and decay heat years after shutdown.
- Photon Source: Gamma radiation uncertainty was lower, peaking at 0.19% in the third year, primarily driven by $^{54}\text{Mn}$.
The researchers also noted that many standard libraries lack explicit uncertainty data for half-lives. Consequently, they derived conservative uncertainty ranges by comparing discrepancies between the ENDF and JEFF libraries.
Conclusion
This analysis demonstrates that uncertainties in fundamental nuclear data can lead to non-negligible variations in engineering predictions for reactor activation. Specifically, the half-life and decay energy of $^{55}\text{Fe}$ are the most critical parameters to refine to improve the accuracy of radiation protection and decommissioning designs. Future work should focus on high-precision experimental measurements of these key isotopes to reduce the uncertainty in reactor safety assessments.
Summary updated