Sensitivity Analyses of Initial Compositions and Cross Sections for Activation Products of In-Core Structure Materials

Kento Yamamoto, Keisuke Okumura, Kensuke Kojima, Tsutomu OkamotoOpenalex Unknown 2014 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Sensitivity analyses of initial compositions and cross sections were conducted to quantitatively clarify the source elements and the nuclear reactions dominating the generation of activation products. In these analyses, the ORIGEN2.2 code was used with ORLIBJ40, a set of the cross-section libraries based on JENDL-4.0. Analyses were conducted for the activations of cladding tubes, end plugs, and spacers of fuel assemblies and channel boxes in BWR that are composed of zirconium alloy, stainless steel, and nickel-chromium-based alloy. From about 50 representative radioactive nuclides, several nuclides were selected as the targets of sensitivity analyses for the aspect of their large concentrations in the target materials. The results of sensitivity coefficients clarified the source elements and the nuclear reactions dominating the generation of activation products even for the nuclides generated through complicated pathways. These results could be utilized to select the objectives of the impurity elements for measurements and of nuclear data for the improvement of accuracy. These results will contribute to improvements in the accuracy of numerical evaluations of activation product concentrations.

Introduction

The operation of nuclear reactors results in the activation of structural materials due to intense neutron flux. Components such as cladding tubes, spacers, and channel boxes, typically made of zirconium alloys, stainless steel, or nickel-chromium alloys, become radioactive over time. Accurately predicting the concentration of these activation products is vital for the "back-end" of the nuclear cycle, specifically for decommissioning plants and disposing of radioactive waste. However, these predictions are often hampered by uncertainties in the initial chemical composition of materials—especially trace impurities—and the nuclear cross-sections. This study employs sensitivity analysis to identify the specific variables that drive final radioactivity levels.

Methodology

The researchers utilized the ORIGEN2.2 code for isotope depletion and generation calculations, supported by the ORLIBJ40 cross-section library based on JENDL-4.0. The analysis focused on four primary materials: Zircaloy-2, Zircaloy-4, SUS304 stainless steel, and INCONEL alloy 718.

The irradiation scenario simulated a typical Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) environment. As shown in Figure 1, the model assumed four irradiation cycles, each lasting approximately 377 days, followed by a 10-year cooling period.

Figure 1: Irradiation history used in the sensitivity analysis, simulating four cycles of reactor operation.

The components analyzed include cladding tubes, end plugs, and spacers, which vary in material composition between BWR and PWR designs (see Figure 2).

Figure 2: Materials and components of fuel assemblies in BWR and PWR reactors considered in the study.

Sensitivity Analysis Framework

Sensitivity coefficients ($S$) were calculated to determine the relative importance of initial concentrations ($X$) and cross-sections ($\sigma$) on the final product concentration ($W$). A coefficient of $S \approx 1.0$ indicates that a 1% error in that specific parameter leads to a 1% error in the final radioactivity prediction. This quantitative approach allows for the identification of "dominant pathways" even in complex multi-step nuclear reaction chains.

Results and Discussion

The analysis of 54 representative radioactive nuclides revealed significant insights into the origins of radioactivity within reactor structures.

Impact of Impurities

A key finding was the role of trace impurities. In SUS304 stainless steel, standard industrial specifications often omit cobalt. However, sensitivity analysis showed that when measured cobalt impurities are included, the production of Cobalt-60 shifts from being dominated by Nickel-60 reactions to being almost entirely driven by the Cobalt-59 impurity. Similarly, Carbon-14 and Chlorine-36 concentrations were found to be critically dependent on initial Nitrogen and Sulfur levels, respectively.

Complex Reaction Chains

The study successfully untangled multi-step pathways. For example, Beryllium-10 in Zircaloy-2 was traced back to two primary sources: the $(n, \alpha)$ reaction of Carbon-13 and the $(n, p)$ reaction of Boron-10.

Material-Specific Findings

  • Zircaloy-2: Identified 17 target nuclides. Iron-55 production was primarily linked to iron impurities, with secondary contributions from nickel.
  • INCONEL 718: For this chemically complex alloy, 16 target nuclides were analyzed. Nickel-59 and Nickel-63 concentrations were found to depend almost exclusively on initial nickel content and specific $(n, \gamma)$ reactions.

Conclusion

This sensitivity analysis provides a robust framework for prioritizing data refinement in nuclear engineering. By identifying which impurities and cross-sections most significantly affect activation product concentrations, researchers can focus measurement efforts on critical trace elements and improve the accuracy of nuclear data libraries. These findings are vital for enhancing the reliability of numerical evaluations used in decommissioning and waste management strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sensitivity analyses of initial compositions and cross sections were conducted to quantitatively clarify the source elements and the nuclear reactions dominating the generation of activation products. In these analyses, the ORIGEN2.2 code was used with ORLIBJ40, a set of the cross-section libraries based on JENDL-4.0. Analyses were conducted for the activations of cladding tubes, end plugs, and spacers of fuel assemblies and channel boxes in BWR that are composed of zirconium alloy, stainless steel, and nickel-chromium-based alloy. From about 50 representative radioactive nuclides, several nuclides were selected as the targets of sensitivity analyses for the aspect of their large concentrations in the target materials. The results of sensitivity coefficients clarified the source elements and the nuclear reactions dominating the generation of activation products even for the nuclides generated through complicated pathways. These results could be utilized to select the objectives of the impurity elements for measurements and of nuclear data for the improvement of accuracy. These results will contribute to improvements in the accuracy of numerical evaluations of activation product concentrations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yamamoto2014sensitivity,
  author = {Kento Yamamoto and Keisuke Okumura and Kensuke Kojima and Tsutomu Okamoto},
  title = {{Sensitivity Analyses of Initial Compositions and Cross Sections for Activation Products of In-Core Structure Materials}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1007/978-4-431-55111-9\_20},
}
Figure