Una mirada a los criterios de diseño acústico de la infraestructura educacional en Chile

Juan A. Rodríguez-AguilarRevista 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Since oral communication is the main means we use to learn, acoustics becomes one of the most important attributes of the architectural design of classrooms. Adverse acoustic conditions in the classroom negatively affect the learning, performance and cognitive development of students. In year 2015 the Ministry of Education introduced acoustic design criteria for learning spaces. This article presents a review of these criteria based on a comparison with international regulations and considering the database of the Santiago's urban noise map. The results show that the current acoustic criteria for educational settings in Chile present several shortcomings with respect to international standards. It is also observed that more than 70% of educational establishments in Santiago are exposed to environmental noise levels that lie outside the range of application of the criterion.

Introduction

In the architectural design of educational spaces, factors such as lighting and thermal comfort often take center stage. However, acoustics remains a critical, yet frequently overlooked, component of a functional learning environment. For children, whose auditory systems and neurological processing capabilities do not fully mature until their late teens, poor acoustics represent a significant barrier to cognitive development and academic achievement.

In 2015, the Chilean Ministry of Education (MINEDUC) introduced specific acoustic design criteria for learning spaces. While this was a positive step toward recognizing the importance of the acoustic environment, current research suggests these standards fall short of international benchmarks and fail to account for the acoustic reality of Chile's urban centers. This paper evaluates the adequacy of these regulations by comparing them with international standards and analyzing their applicability within the context of Santiago’s urban noise levels.

Methodology

The evaluation of Chile’s acoustic criteria was conducted through a two-pronged comparative approach:

  1. Regulatory Benchmarking: The MINEDUC criteria were compared against the standards of 13 OECD countries, including the United Kingdom’s Building Bulletin 93 (BB93) and the United States’ ANSI S12.60, as well as World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines. The analysis focused on four key descriptors: internal background noise level ($L_{eqAS}$), reverberation time (RT), Speech Transmission Index (STI), and façade sound insulation ($D_{2m, nT, w}$).
  2. Geospatial Noise Analysis: To test the real-world applicability of these standards, the study utilized the 2016 Noise Map of Santiago provided by the Ministry of Environment. This database contains ambient noise measurements for the façades of 2,155 educational institutions, ranging from preschools to special education centers.

Comparative Analysis: Chile vs. International Standards

The comparison revealed several critical gaps in the Chilean regulatory framework.

The Absence of Background Noise Limits

The most significant omission in the Chilean standard is the lack of a limit on maximum internal background noise ($L_{eqAS}$). Most OECD countries cap this at 35 dB(A) to ensure that mechanical systems or external traffic do not drown out instruction. Without this requirement, Chilean classrooms remain vulnerable to high ambient noise levels that compromise the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR).

Developmental Considerations

Research indicates that children require a much higher SNR—ideally +15 dB—to achieve the same level of speech intelligibility as an adult. Younger students (under 13) are particularly at risk because they lack the linguistic experience to "fill in the blanks" when a teacher's voice is masked by noise. The current Chilean criteria do not differentiate requirements based on student age or the specific needs of inclusive or special education classrooms.

Results: The Urban Noise Reality in Santiago

The geospatial analysis of Santiago’s schools highlights a fundamental flaw in the applicability of the 2015 criteria. Chilean law currently requires 30 dB of façade insulation only if external noise levels are $\le 65$ dB(A). However, it offers no guidance or requirements for environments exceeding this threshold.

The data shows that:

  • 70.63% of all educational facilities in Santiago (approximately 1,572 schools) are exposed to urban noise levels above 65 dB(A).
  • 80.41% of public secondary schools are exposed to noise $\ge 65$ dB(A).
  • Nearly 44% of public secondary schools face external noise levels exceeding 70 dB(A).

Consequently, the current façade insulation requirement is technically inapplicable for the majority of schools in the capital, leaving thousands of students in a "regulatory no-man's land" where their learning environment is unprotected from excessive external noise.

Discussion and Conclusion

The 2015 MINEDUC criteria represent an initial effort to address classroom acoustics, but they are currently insufficient to protect the learning process in noisy urban environments. The flat 30 dB insulation requirement is at the lower end of the international range (28–48 dB) and fails precisely where it is needed most.

Furthermore, the economic implications of poor school acoustics are profound. Improving student achievement through better learning environments correlates directly with long-term GDP growth. Therefore, acoustic design should be viewed not as a luxury, but as a vital public policy tool for national development.

Recommendations for Future Policy

To align with international best practices and protect student welfare, the following updates to Chilean regulations are recommended:

  • Establish Internal Noise Limits: Incorporate a strict maximum internal background noise level ($L_{eqAS} \le 35$ dB).
  • Dynamic Insulation Standards: Replace the single 65 dB threshold with a scaling requirement for façade insulation based on actual external noise exposure.
  • Age-Based and Inclusive Criteria: Develop specific, stricter acoustic controls for preschools and "Special Audition Classrooms" to support students with hearing or language impairments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since oral communication is the main means we use to learn, acoustics becomes one of the most important attributes of the architectural design of classrooms. Adverse acoustic conditions in the classroom negatively affect the learning, performance and cognitive development of students. In year 2015 the Ministry of Education introduced acoustic design criteria for learning spaces. This article presents a review of these criteria based on a comparison with international regulations and considering the database of the Santiago's urban noise map. The results show that the current acoustic criteria for educational settings in Chile present several shortcomings with respect to international standards. It is also observed that more than 70% of educational establishments in Santiago are exposed to environmental noise levels that lie outside the range of application of the criterion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rodriguezaguilar2019una,
  author = {Juan A. Rodríguez-Aguilar},
  title = {{Una mirada a los criterios de diseño acústico de la infraestructura educacional en Chile}},
  booktitle = {Revista},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.4067/s0718-50732019000200115},
}
Figure