Ultrastructural comparison of dendritic spine morphology preserved with cryo and chemical fixation

Hiromi Tamada, Jérôme Blanc, Natalya Korogod, Carl C.h. Petersen, Graham Knott

Abstract

Previously we showed that cryo fixation of brain tissue gave a truer representation of brain ultrastructure in comparison with a standard chemical fixation method (Korogod et al 2005). Extracellular space matched physiological measurements, there were larger numbers of docked vesicles and less glial coverage of synapses and blood capillaries. Here, using the same preservation approaches we compared the morphology of dendritic spines. We show that the length of the spine and the volume of its head is unchanged, however, the spine neck width is thinner by more than 30% after cryo fixation. In addition, the weak correlation between spine neck width and head volume seen after chemical fixation was not present in cryo-fixed spines. Our data suggest that spine neck geometry is independent of the spine head volume, with cryo fixation showing enhanced spine head compartmentalization and a higher predicted electrical resistance between spine head and parent dendrite.

Introduction

Dendritic spines are tiny protrusions on neurons that receive the majority of excitatory signals. Understanding their precise geometry is essential for modeling synaptic strength and electrical compartmentalization. For decades, chemical fixation (using aldehydes) has been the standard for electron microscopy (EM). However, this process is slow and can induce significant artifacts, such as tissue shrinkage or the collapse of extracellular space. This study investigates whether standard chemical fixation accurately preserves spine morphology by comparing it against high-pressure cryo-fixation, which vitrifies tissue in its native state.

Methods and Datasets

The researchers compared two preservation techniques in the adult mouse cerebral cortex:

  1. Chemical Fixation: Standard transcardial perfusion with glutaraldehyde and paraformaldehyde.
  2. Cryo-fixation: High-pressure freezing to vitrify tissue in less than 90 seconds, preserving the "native" state.

Following preservation, the team used Serial Section Electron Microscopy (both TEM and FIBSEM) to capture ultrastructural data. 3D reconstructions were performed on 116 cryo-fixed spines and 150 chemically-fixed spines using software tools like TrakEM2 and NeuroMorph.

3D reconstruction of dendritic spines from serial section electron microscopy.

Key Results

The study revealed that while spine head volume and neck length remained consistent between both methods, the neck diameter was drastically different.

Morphological Distortions

  • Neck Diameter: Cryo-fixed necks averaged 128 nm, while chemically fixed necks were significantly wider at 182 nm (a ~42% increase in diameter).
  • Cross-sectional Area: The area was nearly doubled in chemically fixed samples (0.0284 µm² vs. 0.0159 µm²).
  • Independence of Geometry: In chemically fixed tissue, there is a weak correlation between spine head size and neck width. In cryo-fixed tissue, this correlation disappears, suggesting that spine neck width is regulated independently of synapse size.
Schematic and 3D mesh analysis of dendritic spine morphology, illustrating measurements for head volume, neck length, and cross-sectional area.

Electrical Isolation

The spine neck acts as a resistor; a thinner neck translates to higher electrical resistance. Using Ohm's law, the researchers calculated that the median resistance of a cryo-fixed spine neck is 80 MΩ, compared to only 34 MΩ in chemically fixed tissue. At the upper end of the range, some cryo-fixed spines reached resistances of ~1 GΩ, implying much stronger electrical compartmentalization than current EM-based models assume.

Discussion and Future Work

The widening observed in chemical fixation is likely due to the sensitivity of actin—the spine's primary structural protein—to aldehydes. When the actin cytoskeleton is dismantled by chemicals, the neck likely loses tension and expands.

While cryo-fixation provides a more accurate structural framework, it currently suffers from lower membrane contrast, making it difficult to identify internal organelles like the endoplasmic reticulum within the thinnest necks. Future studies using electron tomography will be necessary to visualize these internal components with higher resolution. Nonetheless, these findings suggest that synapses are more isolated from their parent neurons than previously thought, necessitating updates to computational models of neuronal activity.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Previously we showed that cryo fixation of brain tissue gave a truer representation of brain ultrastructure in comparison with a standard chemical fixation method (Korogod et al 2005). Extracellular space matched physiological measurements, there were larger numbers of docked vesicles and less glial coverage of synapses and blood capillaries. Here, using the same preservation approaches we compared the morphology of dendritic spines. We show that the length of the spine and the volume of its head is unchanged, however, the spine neck width is thinner by more than 30 % after cryo fixation. In addition, the weak correlation between spine neck width and head volume seen after chemical fixation was not present in cryo-fixed spines. Our data suggest that spine neck geometry is independent of the spine head volume, with cryo fixation showing enhanced spine head compartmentalization and a higher predicted electrical resistance between spine head and parent dendrite.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tamada2020ultrastructural,
  author = {Hiromi Tamada and Jérôme Blanc and Natalya Korogod and Carl C.H. Petersen and Graham Knott},
  title = {{Ultrastructural comparison of dendritic spine morphology preserved with cryo and chemical fixation}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.56384},
}
Figure