Ultra Reliable UAV Communication Using Altitude and Cooperation Diversity

Mohammad Mahdi Azari, Fernando Rosas, Kwang-Cheng Chen, Sofie Pollin

TL;DR

This paper introduces a comprehensive framework for analyzing and optimizing air-to-ground (A2G) communication links for Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) acting as aerial base stations. It accounts for height-dependent path loss and fading, and proposes methods to determine optimal UAV altitudes for maximizing reliability and coverage, both for direct communication and when using ground relays.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing deployment of UAVs as aerial base stations for providing broadband connectivity, especially in remote areas, necessitates a deep understanding of their communication link characteristics. Existing research often simplifies A2G channels by ignoring crucial factors like height-dependent path loss and small-scale fading, or by using basic propagation models. This paper addresses the need for a more accurate and generic framework to analyze A2G systems, considering these real-world complexities. Specifically, it aims to:

  • Develop a unified framework for analyzing both A2G and ground-to-ground (G2G) links.
  • Incorporate height-dependent path loss exponents and fading.
  • Derive analytical expressions for optimal UAV altitude to minimize outage probability.
  • Investigate the impact of ground relays on A2G communication reliability and coverage.
  • Determine optimal UAV placement strategies for maximizing coverage area.

Methods

The authors propose a generic framework that extends existing ground-to-ground (G2G) channel models to A2G scenarios. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Height-Dependent Channel Modeling: The framework incorporates altitude-dependent path loss exponents ($\alpha(\theta_x)$) and Rician factors ($K(\theta_x)$), where $\theta_x$ is the elevation angle. This is a significant improvement over models that assume constant parameters.
  • Analytical Outage Probability Derivation: They derive closed-form expressions for the outage probability of direct A2G links and for A2G cooperative communication networks using ground relays.
  • Optimization Framework: The paper formulates optimization problems to find the optimal UAV altitude ($h$) that minimizes outage probability for a given ground distance ($r_D$) and the maximum coverage radius ($r_Y^Y$) for a given altitude.
  • Cooperative Communication Analysis: They analyze Decode-and-Forward (DF) opportunistic relaying, deriving both exact outage probabilities and analytical lower bounds.
  • Power Allocation Strategy: For scenarios with a fixed total transmit power budget, they introduce a power allocation factor ($\rho$) to optimize the distribution of power between the UAV and ground relays to maximize coverage.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on analytical modeling and simulation-based validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Optimal Altitude is Crucial: The outage probability of A2G links is a convex function of UAV altitude, meaning there's an optimal height that minimizes reliability issues. This optimal altitude is influenced by factors like distance, transmit power, and channel conditions.
  • Ground Relays Enhance Reliability and Coverage: Incorporating ground relays significantly improves A2G communication reliability and can extend coverage, even with a constrained total transmit power budget.
  • Relay Placement Matters: While the optimal UAV altitude for direct communication is primarily determined by the direct link, relaying communication performance is more stable across a range of altitudes. The effectiveness of relays is also influenced by their proximity to the destination.
  • Power Allocation is Key for Cooperative Networks: When operating under a total power budget, an optimal power allocation strategy between the UAV and relays is essential for maximizing coverage. Generally, allocating more power to the UAV is beneficial due to lower path loss, but relays become more critical at lower altitudes or with higher relay densities.
  • Cooperation Extends Coverage: Cooperative communication strategies consistently result in larger coverage areas compared to direct communication, regardless of relay density.

Key Results

  • The paper provides analytical expressions for the optimal UAV altitude that minimizes outage probability for direct A2G links.
  • It derives a lower bound for the outage probability of A2G cooperative communication with ground relays, which is shown to be tight.
  • Simulations demonstrate that the analytical results for outage probability and optimal elevation angles closely match numerical simulations.
  • For a specific scenario with 1000m communication range and low transmit power, the optimal UAV altitude for direct communication was found to be 1300m, while relaying communication achieved optimal performance over a wider altitude range (700m-2000m).
  • Constraining the total transmit power, a 35% reduction in UAV transmit power was possible for a 200m altitude UAV to achieve the same coverage range by including ground relays. Alternatively, unconstrained UAV height with relays could increase coverage by up to 25% with 15% less UAV transmit power.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: While the model is more comprehensive than previous ones, it still relies on certain assumptions, such as the Rician distribution for fading and specific functional forms for altitude-dependent path loss and Rician factor. The paper notes that the general shape of $\alpha(\theta)$ and $K(\theta)$ can vary significantly with different environments and system parameters, suggesting the need for empirical validation.
  • Computational Complexity: The paper mentions that due to the complicated expressions for outage probabilities in relaying and cooperative communication, the optimization problems are not always mathematically tractable and may require numerical optimization for specific scenarios.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the impact of UAV transmit power limitations and the interference caused by UAVs due to their higher Line-of-Sight (LoS) probability. They also indicate that the proposed framework can be extended to analyze more complex scenarios, such as those involving multiple UAVs or different relaying strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) that serve as aerial base stations is expected to become predominant in the next decade. However, in order for this technology to unfold its full potential it is necessary to develop a fundamental understanding of the distinctive features of air-to-ground (A2G) links. As a contribution in this direction, this paper proposes a generic framework for the analysis and optimization of the A2G systems. In contrast to the existing literature, this framework incorporates both height-dependent path loss exponent and small-scale fading, and unifies a widely used ground-to-ground channel model with that of A2G for analysis of large-scale wireless networks. We derive analytical expressions for the optimal UAV height that minimizes the outage probability of a given A2G link. Moreover, our framework allows us to derive a height-dependent closed-form expression and a tight lower bound for the outage probability of an \textit{A2G cooperative communication} network. Our results suggest that the optimal location of the UAVs with respect to the ground nodes does not change by the inclusion of ground relays. This enables interesting insights in the deployment of future A2G networks, as the system reliability could be adjusted dynamically by adding relaying nodes without requiring changes in the position of the corresponding UAVs.
BibTeX
@article{azari2018ultra,
  author = {Mohammad Mahdi Azari and Fernando Rosas and Kwang-Cheng Chen and Sofie Pollin},
  title = {{Ultra Reliable UAV Communication Using Altitude and Cooperation Diversity}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1109/tcomm.2017.2746105},
}
Figure