Two-User SIMO Interference Channel With Treating Interference as Noise: Improper Signaling Versus Time-Sharing

Christoph Hellings, Ferhad Askerbeyli, Wolfgang Utschick

Introduction

In the design of wireless communication systems, managing interference between users is a fundamental challenge. A common and practical approach is Treating Interference as Noise (TIN), where receivers do not attempt to decode the structure of interfering signals but instead treat them as additive noise. Traditionally, this approach has relied on "proper" Gaussian signaling—signals where the real and imaginary components are independent and possess equal variance, resulting in circular symmetry in the complex plane.

Recent research in Single-Input Single-Output (SISO) systems suggested that "improper" signaling—intentionally unbalancing the real and imaginary components—could provide significant rate gains. This paper investigates whether these advantages extend to the more complex Single-Input Multiple-Output (SIMO) interference channel and how improper signaling compares to the traditional technique of coded time-sharing.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The authors explore the trade-offs between signaling strategies using a combination of theoretical proofs and numerical optimization. The core of their investigation centers on two distinct scenarios: one where users can alternate transmission strategies over time (time-sharing) and one where they are restricted to a single, continuous strategy.

1. The Enhanced Channel Concept

To evaluate the optimality of proper signaling, the authors developed a novel "enhanced" version of the SIMO channel. By transforming the complex channel into a composite real representation, they were able to prove that any rate gain achievable through improper signaling could be matched or exceeded by averaging proper signals over time. This theoretical breakthrough establishes that for the two-user SIMO TIN channel, proper signaling is sufficient to reach the Pareto boundary of the achievable rate region, provided coded time-sharing is permitted.

2. Optimization Algorithms

Because finding the optimal signaling parameters is a non-convex problem, the authors implemented two distinct algorithmic approaches:

  • Composite Real Gradient-Projection: For improper signaling, the authors proposed a heuristic that treats complex signals as 2D real vectors. This algorithm uses gradient-based steps to maximize the weighted sum rate of the users.
  • Global Optimization for Proper Signals: To ensure a fair baseline, the authors used a combination of Lagrange duality and a branch-and-bound algorithm (specifically a mixed monotonic programming approach). This guaranteed that the "proper" signaling comparison point was the absolute mathematical optimum.

Key Insights

The Power of Coded Time-Sharing

The study's most significant finding is that coded time-sharing (averaging both data rates and transmit powers over time) acts as a "great equalizer." In the two-user SIMO case, the added complexity of implementing improper signaling is unnecessary if the system can support time-sharing. Mathematically, balancing power across the real and imaginary dimensions (improper signaling) is equivalent to balancing power across time intervals (time-sharing) in this specific channel model.

Improper Signaling as a Restricted-Environment Tool

While proper signaling is optimal with time-sharing, the paper highlights that improper signaling remains a vital tool when time-sharing is unavailable. In scenarios with strict latency constraints or hardware limitations that prevent rapid strategy switching, improper signaling can significantly push the boundaries of achievable data rates beyond what "pure" proper signaling can provide.

Results and Limitations

Theorem 1: Optimality

The authors formally proved that proper signaling achieves the entire achievable rate region for the two-user SIMO TIN channel if coded time-sharing is allowed. Numerical simulations using synthetic channel realizations confirmed this, showing that while improper signaling outperforms pure proper strategies, it never exceeds the outer boundary defined by proper signaling with time-sharing.

Future Directions

While this research settles the debate for the two-user SIMO case, several open questions remain:

  • Multi-User Systems: In systems with three or more users, the complex phase interactions between signals may allow improper signaling to outperform time-sharing.
  • MIMO Extensions: Extending these proofs to Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) systems is mathematically challenging, as it requires moving from scalar variances to complex covariance matrices.
  • Algorithm Refinement: The gradient-projection method for improper signaling is a heuristic; developing a global optimizer for improper signaling in multi-user scenarios remains a goal for future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the two-user Gaussian interference channel with Gaussian inputs and treating interference as noise (TIN), improper complex signals can be beneficial if time-sharing is not allowed or if only the data rates are averaged over several transmit strategies (convex hull formulation). On the other hand, proper (circularly symmetric) signals have recently been shown to be optimal if coded time-sharing is considered, i.e., if both the data rates and the transmit powers are averaged. In this paper, we show that both conclusions remain the same if single-input multiple-output (SIMO) systems with multiple antennas at the receivers are considered. The proof for the case with coded time-sharing is via a novel enhanced channel concept for the two-user SIMO interference channel, which turns out to deliver a tight outer bound to the TIN rate region with coded time-sharing. The result for the case without coded time-sharing is demonstrated by studying specific examples in which a newly proposed composite real gradient-projection method for improper signaling can outperform the globally optimal proper signaling strategy. In addition, we discuss how the achievable TIN rate region with coded time-sharing can be computed numerically.
BibTeX
@article{hellings2020two,
  author = {Christoph Hellings and Ferhad Askerbeyli and Wolfgang Utschick},
  title = {{Two-User SIMO Interference Channel With Treating Interference as Noise: Improper Signaling Versus Time-Sharing}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Signal Process.},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/tsp.2020.3027903},
}
Figure