Two ultra-stable novel allotropes of Tellurium few-layers

Cong Wang, Linlu Wu, Xieyu Zhou, Linwei Zhou, Peng‐Jie Guo, Kai Liu, Zhong-Yi Lu, Zhihai Cheng, Yang Chai, Wei JiarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

At least four two- or quasi-one-dimensional allotropes and their mixtures have been theoretically predicted or experimentally observed for low-dimensional Tellurium (Te), specifically the $\alpha, \beta, \gamma, \delta$ and chiral-$\alpha+\delta$ phases. Among these, the $\gamma$ and $\alpha$ phases were previously identified as the most stable for monolayer and thicker layers, respectively. In this work, we report two novel low-dimensional phases, designated as $\epsilon$ and $\zeta$. The $\zeta$ phase is over 29 meV/Te more stable than the previously leading monolayer $\gamma$ phase, while the $\epsilon$ phase shows comparable stability. The energetic advantage of the $\zeta$ phase over the $\alpha$ phase diminishes with increasing layer thickness, reaching a crossover point at four layers (12 sublayers). Notably, this stability window can be expanded via charge doping. Both $\epsilon$ and $\zeta$ phases exhibit metallic behavior, with the $\zeta$ phase showing quantum well states due to strong interlayer coupling. These findings provide significant insights into the polytypism of Te few-layers and open new avenues for high-conductivity 2D electrode design.

Introduction

While 2D materials like graphene and phosphorene have been extensively studied, group VI elements—the chalcogens—remain a frontier for 2D allotrope discovery. Tellurium (Te) is particularly interesting due to its complex phase diagram. Previous research identified several low-dimensional phases ($\alpha, \beta, \gamma, \delta$), but achieving ultra-stable structures that resist spontaneous transformation remains a challenge. This study addresses the stability and electronic properties of Te few-layers, identifying two entirely new phases that redefine the stability limits of 2D Tellurium.

Methodology

The researchers utilized Density Functional Theory (DFT) simulations via the Vienna ab-initio simulation package (VASP) and Quantum Espresso. To ensure high accuracy for the heavy Tellurium atoms, the PBE functional and hybrid functionals (HSE06) were employed, crucially incorporating Spin-Orbit Coupling (SOC). Van der Waals interactions were modeled using the optB88-vdW method to accurately capture interlayer forces. Additionally, an ionic potential method was used to simulate charge doping effects, representing the influence of substrates or gating.

Results: Structural and Energetic Stability

The discovery of the $\epsilon$ and $\zeta$ phases marks a significant shift in our understanding of 2D Te. The $\zeta$ phase features a high-symmetry square lattice (P4/MMM) with a Te-Te bond length of 3.15 Å. Structurally, the $\epsilon$ phase is related to the $\beta$ phase; under heavy electron doping, the rhomboid chains of the $\beta$ phase tilt to 90 degrees, forming a new diamond-chain structure.

Structural models and energetic stability of 2D Te allotropes. (a-d) Top and side views of the $\alpha, \beta, \epsilon,$ and $\zeta$ phases. (e) Total energy per Te atom vs. layer number, highlighting the stability crossover between the $\zeta$ and $\alpha$ phases at 4 layers. (f) Surface energy as a function of layer thickness.

Energetically, the $\zeta$ phase is the most stable 2D Tellurium structure discovered to date. In monolayer form, it is 29 meV/Te more stable than the $\gamma$ phase. As shown in Figure 1e, the $\zeta$ phase remains the most stable configuration for up to four layers (12 sublayers). Beyond this thickness, the material's bulk properties dominate, and it transitions to the standard $\alpha$ phase. Surface energy calculations (Figure 1f) suggest that while the $\alpha$ phase is the easiest to exfoliate, the $\zeta$ and $\epsilon$ phases possess reasonable surface energies, indicating they are viable candidates for experimental synthesis.

Electronic Properties

Unlike many semiconducting 2D materials, both the $\epsilon$ and $\zeta$ phases are metallic. The $\zeta$ phase is characterized by very strong interlayer coupling, which leads to the emergence of quantum well states in its layer-dependent band structures. This strong band dispersion and high conductivity make the $\zeta$ phase an ideal candidate for next-generation 2D electrodes.

Discussion and Synthesis Outlook

While these findings are currently theoretical, the high stability of the $\zeta$ phase suggests several experimental pathways for synthesis. One approach is Molecular Beam Epitaxy (MBE) or Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) using square-lattice substrates to template the $\zeta$ geometry. Alternatively, since a similar structure exists in bulk Te under high pressure (8 GPa), a "fast-release" technique from high pressure might trap the material in the metastable $\zeta$ phase at ambient conditions. Furthermore, charge doping can be used as a stabilizer to maintain the $\zeta$ phase at thicknesses beyond the four-layer limit.

Conclusion

The prediction of the $\epsilon$ and $\zeta$ phases expands the known polytypism of Tellurium few-layers. The $\zeta$ phase, in particular, stands out for its superior stability in the few-layer regime and its unique metallic properties. These results provide a theoretical foundation for developing high-performance 2D metallic electrodes and further exploring the topological potential of group VI materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

At least four two- or quasi-one- dimensional allotropes and a mixture of them were theoretically predicted or experimentally observed for low-dimensional Te, namely the α, \b{eta}, γ, δ and chiral-α+δ phases. Among them the γ and α phases were found the most stable phases for monolayer and thicker layers, respectively. Here, we found two novel low-dimensional phases, namely the ε and ζ phases. The ζ phase is over 29 meV/Te more stable than and the ε phase shows comparable stability with the most stable monolayer γ phase. The energetic difference between the ζ and α phases reduces with respect to the increased layer thickness and vanishes at the four-layer (12-sublayer) thickness, while this thickness increases under change doping. Both ε and ζ phases are metallic chains and layers, respectively. The ζ phase, with very strong interlayer coupling, shows quantum well states in its layer-dependent bandstructures. These results provide significantly insight into the understanding of polytypism in Te few-layers and may boost tremendous studies on properties of various few-layer phases.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2018two,
  author = {Cong Wang and Linlu Wu and Xieyu Zhou and Linwei Zhou and Peng‐Jie Guo and Kai Liu and Zhong-Yi Lu and Zhihai Cheng and Yang Chai and Wei Ji},
  title = {{Two ultra-stable novel allotropes of Tellurium few-layers}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1809.00561},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1809.00561},
}
Figure