van der Waals Stacking-Induced Topological Phase Transition in Layered Ternary Transition Metal Chalcogenides

Junwei Liu, Hua Wang, Chen Fang, Liang Fu, Xiaofeng QianNano 2016 · DOI · arXiv · OpenAlex

Abstract

Novel materials with nontrivial electronic and photonic band topology are crucial for realizing novel devices with low power consumption and heat dissipation and quantum computing free of decoherence. Here, we theoretically predict a novel class of ternary transition metal chalcogenides that exhibit dual topological characteristics, quantum spin Hall insulators (QSHIs) in their two-dimensional (2D) monolayers and topological Weyl semimetals in their 3D noncentrosymmetric crystals upon van der Waals (vdW) stacking. Remarkably, we find that one can create and annihilate Weyl fermions and realize the transition between Type-I and Type-II Weyl fermions by tuning vdW interlayer spacing, providing the missing physical picture of the evolution from 2D QSHIs to 3D Weyl semimetals. Our results also show that these materials possess excellent thermodynamic stability and weak interlayer binding; some of them were synthesized two decades ago, implying their great potentials for experimental synthesis, characterization, and vdW heterostacking. Moreover, their ternary nature will offer more tunability for electronic structure by controlling different stoichiometry and valence charges. Our findings provide an ideal materials platform for realizing QSH effect and exploring fundamental topological phase transition and will open up a variety of new opportunities for two-dimensional materials and topological materials research.

Introduction

Topological materials represent a frontier in condensed matter physics, offering the potential for dissipationless electronic transport and robust quantum computing. The search for materials that are both topologically non-trivial and experimentally stable has led researchers to explore transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDCs). However, many binary TMDCs are metastable or difficult to synthesize in the specific phases required for topological behavior.

This research introduces a new class of ternary transition metal chalcogenides ($MM’Te_4$) that address these limitations. These materials function as 2D quantum spin Hall insulators (QSHIs) in monolayer form and transform into 3D Weyl semimetals when stacked. This system provides a unique "missing link" in understanding the topological phase transition—the evolution from a 2D insulator to a 3D semimetal driven by van der Waals (vdW) interactions.

Computational Methodology

The study employed a rigorous first-principles approach to characterize the electronic and structural properties of the $MM’Te_4$ family ($TaIrTe_4$, $TaRhTe_4$, $NbIrTe_4$, $NbRhTe_4$):

  • Density Functional Theory (DFT): Calculations were performed using the VASP package with the PBE exchange-correlation functional to determine ground-state atomic structures.
  • vdW Corrections: To accurately model the weak interlayer forces, the authors applied the optB88-vdW functional.
  • Tight-Binding Models: DFT eigenstates were transformed into localized quasiatomic orbitals to construct effective Hamiltonians, enabling the calculation of topological invariants such as the $Z_2$ index and Chern numbers.
  • Surface State Visualization: The Green’s function method was used to calculate the Density of States (DOS) for semi-infinite surfaces, allowing for the visualization of Fermi arcs and helical edge states.
  • Phase Transition Simulation: Linear interpolation between a decoupled layer limit and the equilibrium bulk structure was used to simulate the transition from 2D to 3D states.

The Stacking-Induced Phase Transition

The core discovery of this work is that interlayer vdW interaction acts as a "topological switch." In the monolayer limit, these materials are 2D QSHIs with fundamental band gaps ranging from 23 to 65 meV—large enough to potentially support the Quantum Spin Hall effect at experimentally accessible temperatures.

As these layers are stacked into a 3D crystal, the vdW interaction breaks inversion symmetry and modifies the band structure. This stacking-induced change forces a phase transition, where the 2D band gap closes and reopens to form Weyl points. This process provides a clear physical picture of how 2D topological insulators evolve into 3D Weyl semimetals.

Engineering Weyl Fermions

The ternary nature of these materials ($MM’X_4$) offers significant advantages over binary counterparts. With two distinct metal sites, researchers can fine-tune the electronic structure by adjusting stoichiometry or swapping elements.

Furthermore, the study demonstrates that Weyl fermions can be engineered by tuning the interlayer spacing (simulating elastic strain). The authors found they could move Weyl points through the Brillouin zone, causing them to meet and annihilate or transition between Type-I and Type-II Weyl fermions. Type-I Weyl fermions exhibit a standard cone shape, while Type-II fermions feature tilted cones with electron and hole pockets that break Lorentz invariance. This transition is significant for exploring unique transport properties and giant magnetoresistance.

Stability and Experimental Outlook

Thermodynamic and dynamic stability analyses confirm that all four predicted compounds are viable for synthesis. In fact, $NbIrTe_4$ and $TaIrTe_4$ (belonging to the $Pmn2_1$ space group) were synthesized as early as the 1990s, though their topological properties remained unexplored until now.

Crucially, the interlayer binding energies (25–27 $meV/Å^2$) are lower than that of graphite (~30 $meV/Å^2$). This suggests that these materials can be easily exfoliated into monolayers using standard mechanical techniques like the "Scotch tape" method. In the bulk form, $NbRhTe_4$ exhibits eight Weyl points in the $k_z=0$ plane, which are well-separated in momentum space, making them ideal candidates for detection via Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES).

Conclusion

The $MM’Te_4$ family represents a versatile platform for studying topological physics. By bridging the gap between 2D and 3D topological phases through vdW stacking, these materials offer a roadmap for developing next-generation electronic devices. Future work will likely focus on experimental validation of the predicted Fermi arcs and exploring the effects of different substrates on the topological transition points.

Summary updated

Abstract

Novel materials with nontrivial electronic and photonic band topology are crucial for realizing novel devices with low power consumption and heat dissipation and quantum computing free of decoherence. Here, we theoretically predict a novel class of ternary transition metal chalcogenides that exhibit dual topological characteristics, quantum spin Hall insulators (QSHIs) in their two-dimensional (2D) monolayers and topological Weyl semimetals in their 3D noncentrosymmetric crystals upon van der Waals (vdW) stacking. Remarkably, we find that one can create and annihilate Weyl fermions and realize the transition between Type-I and Type-II Weyl fermions by tuning vdW interlayer spacing, providing the missing physical picture of the evolution from 2D QSHIs to 3D Weyl semimetals. Our results also show that these materials possess excellent thermodynamic stability and weak interlayer binding; some of them were synthesized two decades ago, implying their great potentials for experimental synthesis, characterization, and vdW heterostacking. Moreover, their ternary nature will offer more tunability for electronic structure by controlling different stoichiometry and valence charges. Our findings provide an ideal materials platform for realizing QSH effect and exploring fundamental topological phase transition and will open up a variety of new opportunities for two-dimensional materials and topological materials research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2016van,
  author = {Junwei Liu and Hua Wang and Chen Fang and Liang Fu and Xiaofeng Qian},
  title = {{van der Waals Stacking-Induced Topological Phase Transition in Layered Ternary Transition Metal Chalcogenides}},
  booktitle = {Nano},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.nanolett.6b04487},
}
Figure