Two-Restricted One Context Unification is in Polynomial Time

Adrià Gascón, Manfred Schmidt-Schauß, Ashish Tiwari

TL;DR

This paper tackles a specific, yet crucial, variant of "context unification" called 1CU2r, where a single context variable appears at most twice. The authors present a polynomial-time algorithm to solve this problem and represent all its solutions, a significant step towards efficiently solving more general context unification problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the problem of "One Context Unification" (1CU), which extends standard first-order unification by allowing a special "context variable" that can represent arbitrary subterms. While standard first-order unification is efficient, context unification is considerably more complex, with the general problem being in PSPACE and its exact complexity still an open question. This paper focuses on a restricted version, 1CU2r, where the context variable appears at most twice in the input equations. Solving 1CU2r is important because it serves as a subroutine in polynomial-time algorithms for more general 1CU problems, making it a bottleneck for broader applications.

Methods

The authors develop a polynomial-time algorithm for 1CU2r based on an inference rule system that operates on "states." Each state consists of a pair of terms and a set of equations. The algorithm iteratively applies rules like "Decompose" (similar to first-order unification), "Easy" (for simple cases), "Shrink" rules (to reduce the problem size), and a novel "Merge" rule. The Merge rule is key to handling the symmetric nature of some unification problems and is crucial for achieving polynomial time complexity. The algorithm also includes a mechanism to represent all possible solutions, not just determine if a solution exists.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Merge" Rule is Crucial: The introduction of a "Merge" rule is a novel contribution that allows the algorithm to handle symmetric aspects of unification efficiently, preventing exponential blow-up.
  • 1CU2r as a Building Block: The paper highlights that solving 1CU2r is a fundamental step towards solving more complex context unification problems, making this result highly impactful for the field.
  • Polynomial Representation of Solutions: Beyond just deciding solvability, the paper provides a way to represent all solutions in polynomial space, which is essential for practical applications.
  • DAG Representation Matters: The assumption of terms being represented as Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) is critical for achieving polynomial time complexity, as it allows for efficient sharing of subterms.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates that the 2-restricted One Context Unification (1CU2r) problem is solvable in polynomial time. Furthermore, it shows that a polynomial-size representation of all solutions can be computed within the same time complexity. This result holds even when terms are represented using Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs).

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that the general One Context Unification (1CU) problem remains open. The authors suggest future work to extend their techniques to the unrestricted 1CU problem. Additionally, they propose investigating fault-tolerant unification with different bounds on "faults" and exploring whether their algorithms can be adapted for term representations beyond DAGs, such as Singleton Tree Grammars (STGs).

Summary updated

Abstract

One Context Unification (1CU) extends first-order unification by introducing a single context variable. This problem was recently shown to be in NP, but it is not known to be solvable in polynomial time. We show that the case of 1CU where the context variable occurs at most twice in the input (1CU2r) is solvable in polynomial time. Moreover, a polynomial representation of all solutions can also be computed in polynomial time. The 1CU2r problem is important as it is used as a subroutine in polynomial time algorithms for several more-general classes of 1CU problem. Our algorithm can be seen as an extension of the usual rules of first-order unification and can be used to solve related problems in polynomial time, such as first-order unification of two terms that tolerates one clash. All our results assume that the input terms are represented as Directed Acyclic Graphs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gascon2015two,
  author = {Adrià Gascón and Manfred Schmidt-Schauß and Ashish Tiwari},
  title = {{Two-Restricted One Context Unification is in Polynomial Time}},
  booktitle = {CSL},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.4230/lipics.csl.2015.405},
}

Loading related content...

Figure