Twisted DNA Origami-Based Chiral Monolayers for Spin Filtering

Haozhi Wang, Fangfei Yin, Lingyun Li, Mingqiang Li, Zheng Fang, Chenyun Sun, Bochen Li, Jiye Shi, Jiang Li, Lihua Wang, Shiping Song, Xiaolei Zuo, Xiaoguo Liu, Chunhai Fan

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a way to use "twisted" DNA origami to create highly ordered, stable monolayers that act as ultra-efficient electron spin filters. By leveraging the structural rigidity of DNA origami, they achieved a ten-fold increase in spin-filtering efficiency per unit area compared to traditional DNA strands, proving that a molecule's large-scale "tertiary" shape is just as important as its atomic-scale helix for controlling electron spin.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the emerging field of spintronics, researchers aim to use the "spin" of an electron (up or down) rather than just its charge to process information. A key phenomenon here is Chirality-Induced Spin Selectivity (CISS): when electrons pass through a chiral (handed) molecule, the molecule acts as a filter, letting one spin direction pass more easily than the other.

DNA is a natural candidate for this because of its inherent right-handed double helix. However, building practical spin filters with DNA is difficult. Traditional methods use single-stranded (ssDNA) or double-stranded (dsDNA) "forests" on gold surfaces. These are often messy and disordered because individual DNA strands are floppy—their "persistence length" (a measure of stiffness) is only about 50 nm. This lack of structural control makes it hard to design efficient devices or even accurately measure how well they are working.

Methods

The authors turned to Structural DNA Nanotechnology, specifically Twisted DNA Origami (TDO), to solve the stability and design issues.

  1. The Architecture: They designed a "bundle" of 60 dsDNA strands arranged in a honeycomb lattice. Unlike a single strand, this bundle is incredibly rigid.
  2. Inducing Twist: By strategically inserting or deleting base pairs (e.g., adding 6 extra base pairs every 21 pairs), they forced the entire bundle to twist. They created four versions:
  3. V-TDO: Vertically straight (achiral tertiary structure).
  4. R-TDO: Right-handed global twist.
  5. L-TDO: Left-handed global twist.
  6. P-TDO: A control designed to lie parallel to the surface.
  7. Surface Assembly: These TDOs were anchored to a gold/nickel electrode using thiolated DNA linkers, ensuring they stood upright.
  8. Characterization: The team used Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM)—enhanced by a novel in-situ silicification method (coating the DNA in silica to make it visible under the electron beam)—to confirm the TDOs were standing up and correctly oriented.
  9. Spin Measurement: They used an electrochemical setup with a magnetized nickel electrode and Methylene Blue (MB) as a redox probe. By switching the magnet's polarity, they could measure how much more "spin-up" vs. "spin-down" current was allowed through the TDO layer.

Datasets

This is an experimental physical chemistry paper rather than a data-science-heavy one. The "data" consists of:

  • OxDNA Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: Used to model the mechanical stability and internal helicity of the TDO structures.
  • Electrochemical Cyclic Voltammetry (CV): The primary source of spin-filtering efficiency metrics.
  • Microscopy Images: SEM and AFM data used to calculate "Normalized Spin Polarization" (NSP) by quantifying the exact density of DNA on the electrode surface.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tertiary Chirality is a Force Multiplier: The most significant finding is that the global "tertiary" twist of the origami structure modulates the CISS effect. While the individual DNA helices do the heavy lifting, the overall twist of the bundle can either enhance (R-TDO) or dampen (L-TDO) the filtering efficiency.
  • Overcoming the Persistence Length Limit: By bundling 60 strands, the researchers created a structure far more stable than individual dsDNA. This allowed for a "highly organized dsDNA cluster" that maintains its orientation, which is crucial for aligning the electron's path with the magnetic field.
  • Internal Compaction: MD simulations revealed that the global twist actually changes the "tightness" of the internal B-DNA helices. The right-handed global twist (R-TDO) compacts the internal helices, which the authors believe is why it shows the highest efficiency.
  • Precision Normalization: The authors proposed a "Normalized Spin Polarization" (NSP) formula. This allows researchers to compare spin filtering across different molecular geometries by accounting for the percentage of area covered and the orientation of the molecules.

Key Results

  • 10x Efficiency Boost: TDO-based monolayers showed a nearly one-order-of-magnitude increase in spin-filtering efficiency per unit area compared to conventional 15-base-pair dsDNA.
  • R-TDO Wins: The right-handed twisted origami (R-TDO) achieved a 573% increase in efficiency over standard dsDNA.
  • Structural Fidelity: AFM data showed an average modification density of ~93,000 TDOs per cm², with the majority of structures standing perfectly perpendicular to the electrode.
  • Stability: The TDO monolayers remained stable over more than 50 cyclic voltammetry measurements, a significant improvement over more fragile ssDNA/dsDNA layers.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Electron Scattering: The authors noted that the growth rate of CISS efficiency per base pair was slightly lower than theoretical predictions. They attribute this to increased electron scattering within the dense DNA bundles, which reduces overall conductivity.
  • Scaling: While 60-strand bundles are effective, there is likely an upper limit where the bulkiness of the origami might hinder charge transport.
  • Future Directions: This work opens the door for "rationally designed" chiral membranes. Future research could explore using these TDO layers in solid-state spintronic components or as highly sensitive chiral biosensors for medical diagnostics.

Reference: Wang, H., Yin, F., et al. Twisted DNA origami-based chiral monolayers for spin filtering. (2024).

Summary updated

Abstract

DNA monolayers with inherent chirality play a pivotal role across various domains including biosensors, DNA chips, and bioelectronics. Nonetheless, conventional DNA chiral monolayers, typically constructed from single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) or double-stranded DNA (dsDNA), often lack structural orderliness and design flexibility at the interface. Structural DNA nanotechnology has emerged as a promising solution to tackle these challenges. In this study, we present a strategy for crafting highly adaptable twisted DNA origami-based chiral monolayers. These structures exhibit distinct interfacial assembly characteristics and effectively mitigate the structural disorder of dsDNA monolayers, which is constrained by a limited persistence length of ∼50 nm of dsDNA. We highlight the spin-filtering capabilities of seven representative DNA origami-based chiral monolayers, demonstrating a maximal one-order-of-magnitude increase in spin-filtering efficiency per unit area compared with conventional dsDNA chiral monolayers. Intriguingly, our findings reveal that the higher-order tertiary chiral structure of twisted DNA origami further enhances the spin-filtering efficiency. This work paves the way for the rational design of DNA chiral monolayers.
BibTeX
@article{wang2024twisted,
  author = {Haozhi Wang and Fangfei Yin and Lingyun Li and Mingqiang Li and Zheng Fang and Chenyun Sun and Bochen Li and Jiye Shi and Jiang Li and Lihua Wang and Shiping Song and Xiaolei Zuo and Xiaoguo Liu and Chunhai Fan},
  title = {{Twisted DNA Origami-Based Chiral Monolayers for Spin Filtering}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.3c11566},
}

Loading related content...

Figure