Turnover shapes evolution of birth and death rates

Teemu Kuosmanen, Simo Särkkä, Ville MustonenbioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that standard population genetics models have overlooked the crucial role of "turnover" (the combined rate of birth and death) in shaping evolutionary dynamics. By reformulating population genetics from first principles of birth and death, the authors show that turnover significantly influences mutant fixation, establishment, and the evolution of life-history strategies, calling for a more unified eco-evolutionary theory.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard theory of population genetics, while powerful, often treats birth and death rates as separate entities and can overlook their combined effect, termed "turnover." This oversight is problematic because turnover dictates the timescale of evolutionary events and influences demographic stochasticity. Existing models, particularly those based on the Wright-Fisher diffusion, implicitly assume a turnover rate of one, which may not be realistic for natural populations. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more comprehensive theoretical framework that explicitly incorporates turnover and its impact on key evolutionary processes like mutant fixation and establishment, and ultimately, the evolution of life-history strategies.

Methods

The authors propose a reformulation of population genetics starting from discrete-time birth-death processes. They derive a general stochastic differential equation (SDE) for the frequency dynamics of competing birth-death processes. This SDE is then used to derive "turnover corrections" to classical results concerning mutant fixation, establishment, and substitution. They introduce the concept of "turnover flux," a deterministic selection term that favors lower turnover mutants in small populations. Furthermore, they derive an SDE for the evolution of the mean turnover rate, allowing them to analyze how life-history strategies evolve. To illustrate their theory, they employ a "patch model" which incorporates multiplicative density-dependent feedback on births and additive density- and frequency-dependent feedback on deaths, allowing for analytical tractability and comparison with simulations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical derivations and simulations based on a defined "patch model" rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Turnover is More Than Just Fitness: The combined rate of birth and death (turnover) is not just a byproduct of fitness but a fundamental parameter that shapes evolutionary trajectories.
  • Wright-Fisher is a Special Case: The widely used Wright-Fisher model implicitly assumes a turnover rate of one, which can mask the significant impact of differential turnover in real populations.
  • Turnover Flux: In small populations, a deterministic "turnover flux" emerges, favoring mutants with lower turnover, acting as a form of selection independent of classical fitness.
  • Life-History Evolution is Driven by Variance: The evolution of life-history strategies (e.g., fast vs. slow life histories) is fundamentally driven by the variance in intrinsic birth and death rates, with multiplicative ecological feedback playing a crucial role.
  • Demographic Transitions Explained: The framework helps explain demographic transitions, where a permanent decrease in effective turnover is achieved, linking evolutionary innovations to ecological feedback.

Key Results

  • The paper derives SDEs for population frequency dynamics that explicitly include turnover.
  • Turnover corrections are provided for fixation probabilities, showing that mutants with lower turnover have higher fixation probabilities, even for classically neutral mutants.
  • A "turnover bias" is observed, where populations are more likely to be found in lower turnover states.
  • The establishment threshold for mutants is shown to be modulated by turnover, with lower turnover mutants establishing more easily.
  • The evolution of mean turnover is analyzed, demonstrating how variance in birth and death rates, modulated by ecological feedback, drives life-history evolution.
  • Simulations using the patch model support the analytical predictions, illustrating the interplay of turnover, selection, and ecological feedback.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Analytical Tractability: While the framework is general, fully analytical results may not always be achievable for complex ecological feedback mechanisms.
  • Age- and Size-Dependent Strategies: The current model primarily focuses on constant life-history strategies, and extending it to age- and size-dependent strategies would be a valuable future direction.
  • Experimental Validation: The authors emphasize the need for more experimental work to measure birth and death rates directly, which would allow for rigorous testing of the theory's predictions.
  • Human Demography and Cultural Evolution: The framework could be applied to model human demography and cultural evolution, particularly in understanding demographic transitions.
  • Cancer Evolution: The insights into turnover and its impact on evolution are directly relevant to understanding cancer progression and developing optimal treatment strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Population turnover, a key trait shaped by the organism’s life history strategy, plays an important role in eco-evolutionary dynamics by fixing the timescale for individual birth and death events as well as in determining the level of demographic stochasticity related to growth. Yet, the standard theory of population genetics, and the models heavily used in the related data analysis, have largely ignored the role of turnover. Here we propose a reformulation of population genetics starting from the first principles of birth and death and show that the role of turnover is evolutionarily important. We derive a general stochastic differential equation for the frequency dynamics of competing birth-death processes and determine the appropriate turnover corrections for the essential results regarding fixation, establishment, and substitution of mutants. Our results reveal how both the absolute and relative turnover rates influence evolution. We further describe a deterministic turnover selection, the turnover flux, which operates in small populations. Finally, we analyse the evolution of mean turnover and show how it explains the key eco-evolutionary mechanisms underlying demographic transitions. In conclusion, our results explicitly show how competing life-history strategies, demographic stochasticity, ecological feedback, and evolution are inseparably intertwined, thus calling for a unified theory development starting from the underlying mechanisms of birth and death.
BibTeX
@misc{kuosmanen2022turnover,
  author = {Teemu Kuosmanen and Simo Särkkä and Ville Mustonen},
  title = {{Turnover shapes evolution of birth and death rates}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.07.11.499527},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure