Tuning the dials of Synthetic Biology

James A. J. Arpino, Edward J. Hancock, James Anderson, Mauricio Barahona, Guy‐Bart Stan, Antonis Papachristodoulou, Karen M. PolizziMicrobiology 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

Synthetic biology aims to engineer biological systems like an engineer designs machines, but the process is still challenging. This review provides a comprehensive guide to the "dials" – tunable parameters – available to synthetic biologists for modifying gene expression at various levels, from global cellular properties to specific protein modifications. Understanding and systematically tuning these dials is crucial for building predictable and robust synthetic biological systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The core problem this paper addresses is the lack of a fully realized, systematic engineering design cycle for synthetic biology. While the field aspires to be the "Engineering of Biology," creating predictable and reliable biological systems remains a significant challenge. This is partly due to the complexity of biological systems and the difficulty in precisely controlling gene expression. The authors highlight the need for a clear understanding of how various biological components can be modified and tuned to achieve specific design objectives, moving towards truly "plug-and-play" biological parts.

Methods

This paper is a comprehensive review, not an experimental study. Therefore, it doesn't introduce novel methods in the traditional sense. Instead, it synthesizes and categorizes existing knowledge about the "dials" or tunable parameters used in synthetic biology. The authors systematically review how these dials operate at different levels:

  • Global parameters: This includes the choice of the cellular chassis (e.g., E. coli strain) and controlling gene copy number (e.g., via plasmid origin of replication).
  • Transcriptional level: This involves selecting different promoter types, modifying their strength, and controlling their activation/repression through inducers.
  • Translational level: This focuses on tuning ribosome-binding site (RBS) strength, codon optimization, and mRNA decay rates.
  • Post-translational level: This encompasses protein degradation tags and protein activity manipulation.

The paper also discusses how these dials can be modeled mathematically using deterministic and stochastic approaches, and how experimental implementation guides the design cycle.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Dials" Metaphor: The paper effectively uses the "dials" metaphor to conceptualize the tunable parameters in synthetic biology, making complex concepts more accessible.
  • Hierarchical Control: Synthetic biology offers control over gene expression at multiple hierarchical levels (global, transcriptional, translational, post-translational), each with its own set of "dials."
  • Interdependence of Dials: Tuning one dial can have unintended consequences on others, highlighting the need for a holistic design approach and careful consideration of trade-offs. For example, increasing gene copy number can sometimes increase promoter leakiness.
  • Modeling is Crucial: Mathematical modeling is presented as an indispensable tool for guiding design, predicting behavior, and understanding the impact of tuning different dials.
  • Trade-offs are Inherent: Achieving specific design objectives often involves trade-offs. For instance, fast system dynamics might require post-translational control, which can incur higher metabolic burden.
  • Standardization is Key: The development of standardized biological parts and methodologies is crucial for enabling predictable and reproducible synthetic biology.

Key Results

As a review paper, it doesn't present quantitative experimental results. However, it synthesizes findings from numerous studies to illustrate:

  • Range of Control: The paper demonstrates that dials like RBS strength can offer control over translation initiation rates spanning several orders of magnitude (e.g., 10000-fold).
  • Impact of Parameters: Figure 6 provides deterministic simulations showing how changing various dials (inducer concentration, gene copy number, promoter strength, RBS strength, degradation rate, basal expression) affects reporter protein concentration over time. These simulations visually highlight the dynamic and steady-state effects of tuning.
  • Complexity of Tuning: The paper emphasizes that while some dials are easier to tune (e.g., gene copy number via plasmid origin of replication), others are more complex and involve trade-offs (e.g., promoter strength vs. dynamic range and leakiness).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Predictability Challenges: The authors acknowledge that while many dials exist, their behavior can be context-dependent and difficult to predict precisely, especially when combining multiple components or using different chassis.
  • Experimental Effort: Tuning many dials, particularly those involving promoter design, can be time-consuming and require extensive screening.
  • Chassis Specificity: The effects of certain dials can vary significantly between different cellular chassis, requiring careful characterization in the target organism.
  • Future Directions: The paper implicitly suggests future work in developing more robust predictive models, standardizing biological parts, and creating better tools for designing and optimizing synthetic gene circuits. The integration of computational tools with experimental validation is highlighted as a path forward. The authors also point to the need for better understanding of how different dials interact and how to manage trade-offs effectively.

Summary updated

Abstract

Synthetic Biology is the 'Engineering of Biology' - it aims to use a forward-engineering design cycle based on specifications, modelling, analysis, experimental implementation, testing and validation to modify natural or design new, synthetic biology systems so that they behave in a predictable fashion. Motivated by the need for truly plug-and-play synthetic biological components, we present a comprehensive review of ways in which the various parts of a biological system can be modified systematically. In particular, we review the list of 'dials' that are available to the designer and discuss how they can be modelled, tuned and implemented. The dials are categorized according to whether they operate at the global, transcriptional, translational or post-translational level and the resolution that they operate at. We end this review with a discussion on the relative advantages and disadvantages of some dials over others.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arpino2013tuning,
  author = {James A. J. Arpino and Edward J. Hancock and James Anderson and Mauricio Barahona and Guy‐Bart Stan and Antonis Papachristodoulou and Karen M. Polizzi},
  title = {{Tuning the dials of Synthetic Biology}},
  booktitle = {Microbiology},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1099/mic.0.067975-0},
}
Figure