In October 2017, the Sentinel-5 Precursor (S5P) mission was launched, carrying the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI). TROPOMI provides daily global coverage at an unprecedented spatial resolution of 7 km × 3.5 km, extending the European atmospheric composition record initiated in 1995. This study presents a comprehensive validation of TROPOMI’s near real-time (NRTI) and offline (OFFL) total ozone column (TOC) products. Comparisons against global ground-based networks (Brewer, Dobson, and SAOZ) and established satellite missions (OMPS, GOME-2) demonstrate that TROPOMI TOC data meets mission requirements, with a mean bias within 0–1.5% and a mean standard deviation between 2.5% and 4.5%. These results confirm the high quality of TROPOMI TOC products for continued global ozone monitoring.
Introduction
Monitoring the ozone layer's recovery and the evolution of tropospheric pollution requires continuous, high-quality global observations. Since the 1970s, satellite missions have been vital for this task. The launch of TROPOMI aboard the S5P satellite represents a significant advancement, offering much higher spatial resolution than its predecessors. However, ensuring the reliability of this new data for long-term climate records requires rigorous validation against independent "ground truth" measurements and inter-comparison with existing satellite sensors to ensure consistency across the historical record.
Methodology and Data Products
The validation effort focused on two primary TROPOMI TOC products derived from different retrieval algorithms:
Near Real-Time (NRTI): Uses a fast Differential Optical Absorption Spectroscopy (DOAS) algorithm to provide data within three hours of sensing.
Offline (OFFL): Utilizes the GODFIT v4 direct-fitting algorithm, which is the standard for European climate data records, offering higher accuracy for scientific research.
Co-location Strategy
Given TROPOMI's high resolution, traditional broad co-location criteria (e.g., 100 km) are no longer optimal. The authors investigated the impact of spatial and temporal windows on comparison statistics. They found that a strict 10 km spatial and 40-minute temporal window significantly reduces noise in the comparisons by ensuring both instruments observe nearly the same air parcel.
Figure 3: Impact of spatial co-location distance on the mean difference (a) and standard deviation (b) between TROPOMI and ground-based TOC measurements across various stations.
The global statistical analysis reveals that TROPOMI TOC products are highly accurate. The mean bias relative to ground-based sensors is between 0% and 1.5%, well within the mission's 3.5%–5% requirement. The precision, represented by the mean standard deviation of differences, ranges from 2.5% to 4.5%.
Satellite Inter-comparison
TROPOMI data was also compared with heritage sensors, including OMPS (on Suomi-NPP) and GOME-2 (on Metop-A and Metop-B). The agreement is excellent, with absolute differences in mean bias below 0.7% and standard deviations under 1%, ensuring a seamless transition between missions for climate studies.
Key Insights and Discussion
Albedo Sensitivity: A notable finding was a seasonal bias (up to 5%) in the NRTI product at high northern latitudes during spring 2018. This was attributed to the use of a static albedo climatology in the NRTI algorithm, which failed to account for year-specific snow/ice variations. The OFFL product, which retrieves albedo dynamically, did not exhibit this issue.
Resolution and Variability: The high precision of TROPOMI means that observed "errors" in comparisons are often due to small-scale atmospheric variability or the inherent limitations of ground-based instruments rather than satellite sensor noise.
Conclusion
The first-year validation of TROPOMI/S5P total ozone column data confirms its exceptional quality and consistency with both ground-based networks and previous satellite missions. While minor improvements to the NRTI albedo handling are recommended for polar regions, the mission is successfully fulfilling its role in providing high-resolution, reliable data for global ozone monitoring. Continuous validation will remain essential to monitor the instrument's long-term stability as it ages in space.
Summary updated
Abstract
In October 2017, the Sentinel-5 Precursor (S5P) mission was launched, carrying the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI), which provides a daily global coverage at a spatial resolution as high as 7 km × 3.5 km and is expected to extend the European atmospheric composition record initiated with GOME/ERS-2 in 1995, enhancing our scientific knowledge of atmospheric processes with its unprecedented spatial resolution. Due to the ongoing need to understand and monitor the recovery of the ozone layer, as well as the evolution of tropospheric pollution, total ozone remains one of the leading species of interest during this mission. In this work, the TROPOMI near real time (NRTI) and offline (OFFL) total ozone column (TOC) products are presented and compared to daily ground-based quality-assured Brewer and Dobson TOC measurements deposited in the World Ozone and Ultraviolet Radiation Data Centre (WOUDC). Additional comparisons to individual Brewer measurements from the Canadian Brewer Network and the European Brewer Network (Eubrewnet) are performed. Furthermore, twilight zenith-sky measurements obtained with ZSL-DOAS (Zenith Scattered Light Differential Optical Absorption Spectroscopy) instruments, which form part of the SAOZ network (Système d'Analyse par Observation Zénitale), are used for the validation. The quality of the TROPOMI TOC data is evaluated in terms of the influence of location, solar zenith angle, viewing angle, season, effective temperature, surface albedo and clouds. For this purpose, globally distributed ground-based measurements have been utilized as the background truth. The overall statistical analysis of the global comparison shows that the mean bias and the mean standard deviation of the percentage difference between TROPOMI and ground-based TOC is within 0 –1.5 % and 2.5 %–4.5 %, respectively. The mean bias that results from the comparisons is well within the S5P product requirements, while the mean standard deviation is very close to those limits, especially considering that the statistics shown here originate both from the satellite and the ground-based measurements. Additionally, the TROPOMI OFFL and NRTI products are evaluated against already known spaceborne sensors, namely, the Ozone Mapping Profiler Suite, on board the Suomi National Polar-orbiting Partnership (OMPS/Suomi-NPP), NASA v2 TOCs, and the Global Ozone Monitoring Experiment 2 (GOME-2), on board the Metop-A (GOME-2/Metop-A) and Metop-B (GOME-2/Metop-B) satellites. This analysis shows a very good agreement for both TROPOMI products with well-established instruments, with the absolute differences in mean bias and mean standard deviation being below +0.7 % and 1 %, respectively. These results assure the scientific community of the good quality of the TROPOMI TOC products during its first year of operation and enhance the already prevalent expectation that TROPOMI/S5P will play a very significant role in the continuity of ozone monitoring from space.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{garane2019tropomi,
author = {Katerina Garane and Maria-Elissavet Koukouli and Tijl Verhoelst and Christophe Lerot and Klaus-Peter Heue and Vitali Fioletov and Dimitris Balis and Alkiviadis Bais and Ariane Bazureau and Angelika Dehn and F. Goutail and J. Granville and Debora Griffin and Daan Hubert and Arno Keppens and Jean‐Christopher Lambert and Diego Loyola and C. A. McLinden and Andréa Pazmiño and Jean‐Pierre Pommereau and Alberto Redondas and Fabian Romahn and Pieter Valks and Michel Van Roozendaël and Jian Xu and Claus Zehner and Christos Zerefos and Walter Zimmer},
title = {{TROPOMI/S5P total ozone column data: global ground-based validation and consistency with other satellite missions}},
booktitle = {Atmospheric},
year = {2019},
doi = {10.5194/amt-12-5263-2019},
}