Tropical Pacific climate variability under solar geoengineering: impacts on ENSO extremes

Abdul Malik, Peer Nowack, Joanna D. Haigh, Long Cao, Luqman Atique, Yves Plancherel

Abstract

Many modelling studies suggest that the El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) will change with rising atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations. Solar geoengineering has been proposed to counteract anthropogenic climate change, but its effectiveness remains uncertain, particularly for ENSO due to the short duration of typical simulations. This study presents results from a 1000-year-long solar-geoengineering simulation (G1) using the HadCM3L model. While G1 offsets global mean surface warming, it leads to a 0.3°C overcooling and a 5% reduction in mean rainfall in the tropical Pacific relative to preindustrial conditions. Although the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) position is restored, other aspects like zonal wind stress and SST gradients are reduced by ~10%, weakening the Pacific Walker Circulation. Consequently, the frequency of extreme El Niño and La Niña events increases by approximately 60% and 30%, respectively, despite extreme El Niños becoming weaker relative to the preindustrial state.

Introduction: The ENSO Challenge

The El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is a dominant driver of global climate variability, influencing weather patterns, agriculture, and ecosystems worldwide. As greenhouse gas concentrations rise, understanding how ENSO will evolve is critical. However, detecting statistically significant changes in the highly variable tropical Pacific background climate is difficult with standard ~50-year geoengineering simulations. This research addresses the "signal-to-noise" challenge by utilizing a millennium-long simulation to evaluate whether solar radiation management (SRM) can restore the tropical Pacific’s preindustrial state or if it induces a novel climate regime characterized by altered extremes.

Methodology: A Millennium of Simulation

The study employed the HadCM3L coupled atmosphere-ocean general circulation model, following the G1 experiment protocol of the Geoengineering Model Intercomparison Project (GeoMIP). Three 1,000-year scenarios were analyzed:

  1. piControl: A preindustrial baseline.
  2. Abrupt 4 × CO2: A scenario where CO2 is quadrupled.
  3. G1: A geoengineering scenario where the 4 × CO2 warming is offset by a 4% reduction in the solar constant.

The 1,000-year duration allowed for robust statistical analysis using Wilcoxon rank-sum and bootstrap methods to identify significant shifts in ENSO frequency and amplitude.

Results and Discussion

The "Overcooling" Effect and SST Gradients

Solar geoengineering does not perfectly cancel CO2-induced warming due to the different spatial distributions of shortwave (solar) and longwave (CO2) forcing. In the G1 simulation, the tropical Pacific experiences an average overcooling of 0.3°C compared to preindustrial levels.

Sea Surface Temperature (SST) distributions and anomalies across the piControl, 4xCO2, and G1 scenarios. Panel (e) highlights the tropical overcooling in G1 relative to piControl.

While the global mean temperature is stabilized, the zonal and meridional SST gradients are reduced by approximately 10%. This weakening of the background thermal structure contributes to a less stable climate system in the Pacific.

Rainfall Dynamics and ITCZ Restoration

One of the successes of the G1 scenario is the restoration of the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ). Under 4 × CO2, the ITCZ shifts 7.5° southward; solar geoengineering effectively returns it to its preindustrial position. However, this comes at the cost of a 5% (0.23 mm/day) reduction in mean rainfall over the tropical Pacific.

Rainfall patterns and anomalies. G1 (c) shows the restoration of the ITCZ position compared to the southward shift in 4xCO2 (b), though with an overall reduction in intensity (e).

ENSO Extremes: The Frequency Paradox

The weakened Pacific Walker Circulation (PWC) and reduced wind stress in G1 create conditions conducive to more frequent El Niño events. The study found that the frequency of extreme El Niño events increases by ~60%, while extreme La Niña events increase by ~30%.

Interestingly, a "frequency paradox" emerges: while extreme El Niños become more common, they are less intense (weaker SST anomalies) than those in the preindustrial era. Conversely, extreme La Niñas become both more frequent and stronger, consistent with the general overcooling of the region. The overall ENSO amplitude strengthens by 9%–10%, and the characteristic asymmetry between warm and cold events is reduced by 65%.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While solar geoengineering can mitigate global mean warming, it fails to "reset" the complex dynamics of the tropical Pacific. The resulting climate is one of increased variability and more frequent extremes. Future research should focus on multi-model ensembles to verify these trends across different climate models and investigate the specific biological and socio-economic impacts of a more volatile tropical Pacific.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many modelling studies suggest that the El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO), in interaction with the tropical Pacific background climate, will change with rising atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations. Solar geoengineering (reducing the solar flux from outer space) has been proposed as a means to counteract anthropogenic climate change. However, the effectiveness of solar geoengineering concerning a variety of aspects of Earth's climate is uncertain. Robust results are particularly challenging to obtain for ENSO because existing geoengineering simulations are too short (typically ∼ 50 years) to detect statistically significant changes in the highly variable tropical Pacific background climate. We here present results from a 1000-year-long solar-geoengineering simulation, G1, carried out with the coupled atmosphere–ocean general circulation model HadCM3L. In agreement with previous studies, reducing the solar irradiance (4 %) to offset global mean surface warming in the model more than compensates the warming in the tropical Pacific that develops in the 4 × CO2 scenario. We see an overcooling of 0.3 ∘C and a 0.23 mm d−1 (5 %) reduction in mean rainfall over the tropical Pacific relative to preindustrial conditions in the G1 simulation, owing to the different latitudinal distributions of the shortwave (solar) and longwave (CO2) forcings. The location of the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) in the tropical Pacific, which moved 7.5∘ southwards under 4 × CO2, is restored to its preindustrial position. However, other aspects of the tropical Pacific mean climate are not reset as effectively. Relative to preindustrial conditions, in G1 the time-averaged zonal wind stress, zonal sea surface temperature (SST) gradient, and meridional SST gradient are each statistically significantly reduced by around 10 %, and the Pacific Walker Circulation (PWC) is consistently weakened, resulting in conditions conducive to increased frequency of El Niño events. The overall amplitude of ENSO strengthens by 9 %–10 % in G1, but there is a 65 % reduction in the asymmetry between cold and warm events: cold events intensify more than warm events. Notably, the frequency of extreme El Niño and La Niña events increases by ca. 60 % and 30 %, respectively, while the total number of El Niño events increases by around 10 %. All of these changes are statistically significant at either 95 or 99 % confidence level. Somewhat paradoxically, while the number of total and extreme events increases, the extreme El Niño events become weaker relative to the preindustrial state, while the extreme La Niña events become even stronger. That is, such extreme El Niño events in G1 become less intense than under preindustrial conditions but also more frequent. In contrast, extreme La Niña events become stronger in G1, which is in agreement with the general overcooling of the tropical Pacific in G1 relative to preindustrial conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{malik2020tropical,
  author = {Abdul Malik and Peer Nowack and Joanna D. Haigh and Long Cao and Luqman Atique and Yves Plancherel},
  title = {{Tropical Pacific climate variability under solar geoengineering: impacts on ENSO extremes}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-20-15461-2020},
}
Figure