TL;DR
This review paper explores the evolving landscape of computer-aided manufacturing (CAM) in prosthodontics, focusing on two primary streams: subtractive (milling) and additive (layer-by-layer building). It highlights how CAM is revolutionizing the creation of oral and facial prostheses, offering alternatives to traditional methods with varying strengths for different applications.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
For decades, traditional methods have been the gold standard for fabricating oral and facial prostheses. However, these methods often involve significant human intervention, multiple error-prone steps (like impression taking and waxing), and can be time-consuming and costly. This can lead to inaccuracies, inconsistencies, and limitations, especially for complex restorations like facial prostheses that require precise aesthetic matching and durability. The paper addresses the need to understand and evaluate the emerging CAM technologies that offer potential solutions to these challenges.
Methods
This paper is a narrative review, meaning it synthesizes and analyzes existing literature on CAM in prosthodontics. The authors categorize CAM into two main streams:
- Subtractive Manufacturing: This involves removing material from a larger block to create the desired prosthesis. The primary technique discussed is Computer Numeric Control (CNC) milling, which uses computer-controlled tools to shape the material. This can involve 3-axis, 4-axis, or 5-axis milling machines, each offering different levels of complexity and precision.
- Additive Manufacturing: This builds objects layer by layer from 3D model data. The paper discusses several additive techniques relevant to prosthodontics:
- Selective Laser Melting (SLM) / Sintering (SLS): Uses a laser to fuse or sinter powder material.
- Stereolithography (SLA): Uses a UV light to cure liquid resin layer by layer.
- 3D Printing: Extrudes material through a nozzle, which solidifies upon deposition.
The review evaluates these methods based on their processing protocols, materials used, and resulting accuracy, particularly in the context of oral and facial prostheses.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. This is a review article, not an empirical study with datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Two Main Streams, Different Strengths: The core insight is the division of CAM in prosthodontics into subtractive (milling) and additive (layer-by-layer) approaches, each with distinct advantages.
- Subtractive for Intraoral, Additive for Facial: Subtractive methods tend to produce more homogeneous objects with good accuracy, making them ideal for intraoral prostheses that withstand high occlusal forces. Additive methods, while potentially having more surface variation, excel at creating complex shapes and large workpieces, making them better suited for facial prostheses.
- Material Matters: The choice of material (ceramics, metals, resins, waxes) significantly impacts the capabilities and limitations of both subtractive and additive processes. High-strength ceramics and zirconia, for instance, are well-suited for CAM but require specific processing.
- Accuracy is Nuanced: While CAM generally aims for higher precision than traditional methods, the accuracy of milled restorations can be influenced by factors like bur diameter, material hardness, and the need for manual "adaptation steps." Implant components, however, show superior accuracy with milling. Additive manufacturing's accuracy is affected by layer thickness and curing beam width, but it offers advantages in producing intricate details without the need for compensation features.
- Beyond Fit: Durability and Aesthetics: The review touches upon how CAM can improve the durability of prostheses (e.g., by enabling the use of stronger materials or precise monolithic designs) and enhance aesthetic outcomes, particularly for facial prostheses.
Key Results
- Subtractive Milling: Offers acceptable accuracy for intraoral prostheses. However, challenges exist with achieving perfect marginal fit for tooth-supported restorations compared to conventional methods, with milled titanium crowns showing larger vertical gaps than cast ones. Implant components, conversely, demonstrate superior fit with milling.
- Additive Manufacturing: Excels at producing complex geometries, undercuts, and fine details, making it ideal for facial prostheses. Accuracy is generally good, with dimensional accuracy for metal workpieces in the range of 3-82 µm. However, surface texture can exhibit stepping due to the layered build-up.
- Material Advancements: CAM has enabled the widespread use of high-strength ceramics like zirconia for restorations previously not feasible with conventional methods.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- Subtractive Accuracy: For tooth-supported restorations, milled prostheses sometimes show less ideal marginal fit compared to conventional methods, requiring manual adjustments.
- Additive Surface Texture: Layered production in additive manufacturing can lead to stepped surfaces, which may require post-processing.
- Material Defects: Both techniques can introduce material defects, though subtractive methods currently produce more homogeneous objects.
- Limited Data: For some additive techniques like 3D printing, there is still limited data on their accuracy and clinical performance.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that continuous improvements in software, hardware, and materials will likely lead to wider acceptance and increased use of CAM in dentistry. Further research is needed to fully understand the long-term clinical validity and advantages of additive manufacturing for various prosthodontic applications. The authors emphasize the importance of clinicians and technicians becoming familiar with these evolving technologies.
Summary updated