TL;DR
This paper tackles the "black box" problem of how Large Language Models (LLMs) use their internal knowledge when generating answers, aiming to make this process more transparent and trustworthy. They introduce a new task, "Context-Prior Augmented Citation Generation," and a method called INTRALIGN, which enables LLMs to cite both external retrieved information and their own internal knowledge, leading to more reliable and verifiable responses.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
LLMs are prone to "hallucinations," meaning they can generate incorrect or fabricated information. While techniques like Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) and citation generation help by grounding answers in external sources, it's still unclear how LLMs utilize their internal knowledge (the knowledge encoded in their parameters). This opacity makes it hard to trust their outputs, especially when external information is insufficient or of poor quality. The paper addresses the challenge of making LLMs' internal knowledge utilization transparent and ensuring the trustworthiness of their generated citations, particularly when combining internal and external knowledge.
Methods
The core of the paper's contribution lies in its novel task and method:
- Context-Prior Augmented Citation Generation Task: This task requires LLMs to generate citations that consider both external retrieved documents and their internal parameter knowledge. Crucially, it also demands that the model provide a confidence score for its internal citations, making the utilization of this knowledge more interpretable.
- RAEL (Rational Attribution and Elaboration) Paradigm: This is a framework designed to guide LLMs in using both external and internal knowledge. It encourages models to review context, scrutinize their internal knowledge, and then generate citations and answers.
- INTRALIGN (Interpretability-Trustworthiness Alignment): This is an integrated method that combines multi-scenario trustworthy data generation with an interpretability-focused alignment algorithm. It involves generating high-quality training data by sampling from LLMs and then fine-tuning them to improve their ability to cite internal knowledge with trustworthiness. The alignment process uses a weighted loss function to prioritize citations and confidence scores.
Datasets
The paper utilizes a combination of existing datasets and a novel approach to data generation:
- Existing Datasets: CRAG (factual question-answering), FRAMES (multi-document reasoning), and SituatedFaithfulnessEval (benchmarking LLM's situated faithfulness). These were selected for their diverse QA types and factual nature.
- Data Generation: The authors also create synthetic datasets, including "Reddit-style" data from Wikipedia, to simulate scenarios with less convincing external sources. They also categorize questions based on difficulty and the LLM's knowledge grasp to study the "tug-of-war" between internal and external knowledge.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Internal Knowledge is Crucial but Opaque: The paper highlights that while LLMs possess vast internal knowledge, how they access and utilize it for citation generation remains a significant challenge.
- The "Tug-of-War" Between Knowledge Sources: LLMs don't always seamlessly integrate internal and external knowledge. The paper shows that question difficulty and the LLM's existing knowledge level influence whether it favors internal or external citations. For instance, when external documents are less convincing or questions are harder, LLMs tend to rely more on their internal knowledge.
- Dishonest Internal References: A concerning finding is that when external documents are weak, LLMs might "rewrite" them as internal knowledge, a form of plagiarism. The proposed method aims to mitigate this.
- Confidence Scores for Transparency: The paper emphasizes the importance of confidence scores for internal citations as a way to signal the LLM's certainty about its own knowledge, thereby increasing transparency.
Key Results
- Improved Performance: INTRALIGN significantly outperforms baselines across various metrics, including accuracy, citation recall (both external and internal), convincingness, and conciseness.
- Better Trustworthiness: The method leads to more trustworthy references, as indicated by higher scores in convincingness and conciseness, and lower Expected Calibration Error (ECE).
- Adaptive Knowledge Utilization: INTRALIGN enables LLMs to adaptively leverage both external and internal knowledge, maintaining high accuracy across different scenarios.
- Reduced Plagiarism: The proposed alignment process demonstrates a lower plagiarism rate and severity compared to other methods.
- Human Evaluation Alignment: Automatic metrics for Convincingness and Conciseness show a good correlation with human judgments.
Limitations and Future Work
- Open-Source Model Enrichment: The authors suggest that using more open-source models could further enrich experiments, as parameter knowledge varies significantly.
- Dataset Bias: Possible biases might be introduced during data sampling and reranking.
- Authenticity of Synthetic Data: The "Reddit-style" data, while useful, might not perfectly represent authentic low-quality knowledge sources.
- Minor Correct Answers: A small percentage of minor correct answers were still observed, suggesting room for improvement in annotation processes.
- Internal Mechanism Exploration: Future work could focus on further exploring the internal mechanisms of parameter knowledge utilization and developing more targeted control over citing external or internal knowledge.
- Copyright Concerns: The use of large models that memorize parameter knowledge raises potential copyright issues, though the paper notes that the memorized content is limited.
Summary updated