Transcranial ultrasound stimulation effect in the redundant and synergistic networks consistent across macaques

Marilyn Gatica, Cyril Atkinson-Clément, Pedro A. M. Mediano, Mohammad Alkhawashki, James Ross, Jérôme Sallet, Marcus Kaiser

TL;DR

Researchers have demonstrated that low-intensity transcranial ultrasound stimulation (TUS) does more than just "nudge" brain activity—it fundamentally reorganizes how information flows through complex neural networks. By applying TUS to macaques, the team showed that this non-invasive tool can shift the balance between redundant and synergistic information processing, consistently across individuals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While we have various ways to stimulate the brain non-invasively (like magnetic or electrical stimulation), most struggle to reach deep structures with high precision. Low-intensity transcranial ultrasound stimulation (TUS) is a promising alternative because it can target deep-seated brain regions with millimeter accuracy.

However, we still don't fully understand how TUS reorganizes the brain's "high-order" communication. Most studies look at simple pairwise correlations—how region A talks to region B. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how TUS affects the complex interplay of multiple regions, specifically looking at redundancy (information shared across many parts) and synergy (new information that only emerges when parts work together).

Methods

The researchers used a sophisticated information-theoretic framework to analyze resting-state fMRI data from three macaques.

  1. Stimulation: They targeted two distinct areas: the Supplementary Motor Area (SMA) and the Frontal Polar Cortex (FPC) using 40-second bursts of low-intensity TUS.
  2. Information Decomposition: Instead of standard connectivity, they used Integrated Information Decomposition ($\Phi ID$). This allowed them to calculate a "synergy minus redundancy rank gradient." Think of this as a map showing which brain regions act as "redundant hubs" (reliable, shared info) versus "synergistic integrators" (complex, emergent info).
  3. Graph Theory: They applied network metrics like modularity (to see how segregated redundant info is) and global efficiency (to see how well synergistic info is integrated).
  4. Structure-Function Coupling: They compared these informational changes against the physical "wiring" of the brain (Structural Connectivity via Diffusion MRI).

Datasets

The study utilized an existing "offline TUS fMRI" dataset of three macaques.

  • Conditions: Control (non-TUS), SMA-TUS, and FPC-TUS.
  • Imaging: High-resolution structural MRI and resting-state fMRI (recorded 30–150 minutes post-stimulation).
  • Atlases: The researchers mapped the data to the CHARM and SARM macaque brain atlases, dividing the brain into 140 distinct regions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Target-Specific Ripples: TUS didn't just affect the target; it caused specific "downstream" shifts. Stimulating the FPC (a high-level cognitive area) primarily altered the limbic network, while stimulating the SMA (a motor area) altered the motor network.
  • The Structure-Function Divorce: One of the most striking findings was that TUS decreased the coupling between the brain's physical wiring and its functional information flow. This suggests that TUS temporarily "frees" the functional network from its structural constraints, allowing for a reorganization of neural communication.
  • Information Topology: Redundancy is typically modular (segregated into neat pockets), while synergy is integrated across the whole brain. TUS disrupted this: SMA-TUS decreased the modularity of redundancy, while FPC-TUS increased the global integration of synergy.
  • Consistency is Key: Despite the complexity of these high-order metrics, the results were remarkably consistent across all three macaques, suggesting these informational shifts are a fundamental biological response to ultrasound.

Key Results

  • SMA-TUS Effects: Shifted motor areas (like the pallidum and posterior thalamus) toward more redundant interactions, while shifting frontal areas (like the ventrolateral prefrontal cortex) toward synergy.
  • FPC-TUS Effects: Shifted the limbic network (striatum, hippocampus, and anterior cingulate) toward redundancy.
  • Quantitative Decoupling: The correlation between structural connectivity and redundancy dropped significantly (e.g., from $\rho = 0.24$ in controls to $\sim 0.19$ after stimulation).
  • Network Changes: SMA-TUS specifically reduced the modular organization of redundant information, effectively "blurring" the boundaries of shared information in the motor system.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: The study only involved three macaques. While the results were consistent, larger samples are needed for broader generalization.
  • Anesthesia: The macaques were under isoflurane anesthesia, which is known to alter brain connectivity. It remains to be seen how these informational shifts manifest in an awake, behaving state.
  • Relative Metrics: The "rank gradient" used is a relative measure; future work could explore absolute changes in bits of information.
  • Human Translation: The ultimate goal is to move this toward human clinical applications, potentially using TUS to "re-tune" information flow in psychiatric or neurological disorders where synergy/redundancy balance is disrupted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Low-intensity transcranial ultrasound stimulation (TUS) is a noninvasive technique that safely alters neural activity, reaching deep brain areas with good spatial accuracy. We investigated the effects of TUS in macaques using a recent metric, the synergy minus redundancy rank gradient, which quantifies different kinds of neural information processing. We analyzed this high-order quantity on the fMRI data after TUS in two targets: the supplementary motor area (SMA-TUS) and the frontal polar cortex (FPC-TUS). The TUS produced specific changes at the limbic network at FPC-TUS and the motor network at SMA-TUS and altered the sensorimotor, temporal, and frontal networks in both targets, mostly consistent across macaques. Moreover, there was a reduction in the structural and functional coupling after both stimulations. Finally, the TUS changed the intrinsic high-order network topology, decreasing the modular organization of the redundancy at SMA-TUS and increasing the synergistic integration at FPC-TUS.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gatica2024transcranial,
  author = {Marilyn Gatica and Cyril Atkinson-Clément and Pedro A. M. Mediano and Mohammad Alkhawashki and James Ross and Jérôme Sallet and Marcus Kaiser},
  title = {{Transcranial ultrasound stimulation effect in the redundant and synergistic networks consistent across macaques}},
  booktitle = {Network},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1162/netn\_a\_00388},
}
Figure