TransAID Deliverable 6.2/2 - Assessment of Traffic Management Procedures in Transition Areas

Leonhard Lücken, Matthias Schwamborn, Evangelos Mintsis, Dimitris Koutras, Vasilios Karagounis, Alejandro Correa, Miguel Sepulcre, Baldomero Coll Perales, Gokulnath Thandavarayan, Robbin Blokpoel, Xiaoyun Zhang, Giovanni Huisken, Steven Boerma, Sven Maerivoet, Kristof Carlier, P. I. Pápics, Bart Ons, Stef Tourwé, Olaf Angelo Banse Bueno, Julian SchindlerElib 2021 · DOI

TransAID Project Logo

Abstract

This Deliverable 6.2 of the TransAID project presents and evaluates the simulation results obtained for the scenarios considered during the project's first and second iterations. To this end, driver- and AV-models, traffic management procedures, and V2X communication protocols were implemented within the iTETRIS simulation framework. Previous results from Deliverable 4.2, where baseline and traffic management measures without V2X communication were compared, have been confirmed. While not all TransAID scenarios' traffic KPIs were affected, the realistic simulation of V2X communication has shown a discernible impact on some of them, making it an indispensable modeling aspect for a realistic performance evaluation. Flaws of the first iteration's traffic management algorithms concerning wireless V2X communication and packet loss were identified and addressed during the second iteration. We conclude that realistic V2X simulation is essential for safety, though it induces a significant computational overhead.

Introduction: The Challenge of Transition Areas

As the automotive landscape shifts toward a mix of manual, connected, and fully automated vehicles (AVs), the industry faces a significant hurdle: Transition Areas (TAs). These are specific road segments—such as complex intersections, construction zones, or areas with degraded sensor visibility—where an AV may suddenly realize it can no longer operate autonomously. This realization triggers a "Transition of Control" (ToC) to the human driver or, if the driver is unresponsive, a "Minimum Risk Manoeuvre" (MRM) like pulling over to the shoulder.

Historically, traffic management research often assumed "ideal" communication, where every message between a vehicle and infrastructure arrives instantly and perfectly. However, real-world wireless signals are subject to interference, physical obstacles, and network congestion. This paper addresses the critical gap between idealized simulations and the "messy reality" of wireless Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) communication.

Methodology: The iTETRIS Framework

To evaluate these complex interactions, the study utilized the iTETRIS simulation framework, a "system of systems" that couples three core components:

  1. SUMO (Simulation of Urban MObility): A microscopic traffic simulator handling vehicle physics and driver behavior.
  2. ns-3: A discrete-event network simulator that models the actual physics of radio waves (ITS-G5/802.11p), including signal attenuation and packet collisions.
  3. iCS (iTETRIS Control System): Middleware that synchronizes the traffic and network simulators.

Iterative Development and Use Cases

The project was structured into two distinct iterations, allowing for the refinement of algorithms based on initial findings. The researchers tested five specific Use Cases (UCs), including navigating roadworks via bus lanes and scheduling ToCs before "No-Automated-Driving" zones.

The iterative development process as documented in the project's version history.

As shown in the project's documentation (Figure 5), the development process involved detailed scenario descriptions for each Use Case (e.g., UC5, UC1, UC3,4) and the integration of specific traffic management (TM) sections. This iterative approach was vital for identifying and fixing flaws in the first iteration's algorithms, particularly regarding their sensitivity to packet loss.

Key Insights: Communication as a Traffic KPI

The study revealed that communication performance—measured by latency and packet delivery ratio—is not just an IT metric; it is a fundamental traffic metric.

The Robustness Requirement

A critical finding was that algorithms designed for perfect information are inherently fragile. In early tests, the loss of a single "Take-over Request" message could lead to a safety failure. By the second iteration, the team implemented acknowledgment (ACK) mechanisms and message retransmissions, which significantly boosted system safety and reliability.

The Computational Tax

Realistic modeling comes at a high cost. Simulating one hour of traffic with realistic V2X can take days or weeks of CPU time, especially at high traffic densities (Level of Service C or D). The authors argue that while realism is necessary for safety validation, researchers must strategically trade off between simulation depth and computation time.

Results and Performance Evaluation

  • Packet Failure Rates: In realistic scenarios, packet failure ratios typically ranged between 2% and 8%. While seemingly low, these failures were enough to cause "shockwaves" in motorway traffic if they affected critical maneuver advice.
  • Channel Busy Ratio (CBR): In urban scenarios, the communication channel was busy less than 20% of the time. However, in dense motorway merging, this spiked to over 30%, nearing the threshold for congestion control protocols.
  • Latency: Average V2X latency remained low, around 1–2.5 ms, suggesting that when packets do arrive, they are timely enough for high-speed safety applications.
  • Safety Improvements: Refined traffic management measures (like intelligent ramp metering) reduced the average ToC rate to between 0.2% and 2%, proving that infrastructure-assisted driving is effective even with imperfect networks.

Conclusion and Recommendations

The TransAID project demonstrates that realistic V2X communication modeling is indispensable for evaluating traffic management in Transition Areas. The study concludes with three primary recommendations:

  1. Account for Packet Loss: Traffic management algorithms must be designed to handle sporadic packet loss.
  2. Balance Realism and Speed: A trade-off between computation time and the degree of realism is necessary for large-scale studies.
  3. Infrastructure Assistance: Infrastructure-based traffic management can significantly reduce the frequency of risky control transitions.

These findings provide a roadmap for the real-world prototypes to be developed in the next phase of the TransAID project (WP7).

Summary updated

Abstract

This Deliverable 6.2 of the TransAID project presents and evaluates the simulation results obtained for the scenarios considered during the project's first and second iterations. To this end, driver- and AV-models designed in WP3, traffic management procedures developed in WP4, and V2X communication protocols and models from WP5 were implemented within the iTETRIS simulation framework. Previous main results from Deliverable 4.2, where baseline and traffic management measures without V2X communication were compared, have been confirmed. While not all TransAID scenarios' traffic KPIs were affected, the realistic simulation of V2X communication has shown a discernible impact on some of them, which makes it an indispensable modelling aspect for a realistic performance evaluation of V2X traffic scenarios. Flaws of the first iteration's traffic management algorithms concerning wireless V2X communication and the accompanying possibility of packet loss were identified and have been addressed during the project's second iteration. Finally, lessons learned while working on these simulation results and assessments have additionally been described in the form of recommendations for the real-world prototype to be developed in WP7. We conclude that all results obtained for all scenarios when employing ideal communication confirmed the statistical trends of the results from the original TM scenarios as reported in Deliverable 4.2 where no V2X communication was considered. Furthermore, the performance evaluation of the considered scenarios and parameter combinations has shown the following, which held true in both the first and second iterations: (1) The realistic simulation of V2X communication has an impact on traffic scenarios, which makes them indispensable for a realistic performance evaluation of V2X traffic scenarios. (2) Traffic management algorithms need to account for sporadic packet loss of various message types in some way. (3) Although important, the realistic modelling and simulation of V2X communication also induces a significant computational overhead. Thus, from a general perspective, a trade-off between computation time and degree of realism should be considered.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lucken2021transaid,
  author = {Leonhard Lücken and Matthias Schwamborn and Evangelos Mintsis and Dimitris Koutras and Vasilios Karagounis and Alejandro Correa and Miguel Sepulcre and Baldomero Coll Perales and Gokulnath Thandavarayan and Robbin Blokpoel and Xiaoyun Zhang and Giovanni Huisken and Steven Boerma and Sven Maerivoet and Kristof Carlier and P. I. Pápics and Bart Ons and Stef Tourwé and Olaf Angelo Banse Bueno and Julian Schindler},
  title = {{TransAID Deliverable 6.2/2 - Assessment of Traffic Management Procedures in Transition Areas}},
  booktitle = {Elib},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.13140/rg.2.2.29764.14724},
}
Figure