DSRC & C-V2X Comparison for Connected and Automated Vehicles in Different Traffic Scenarios

Yuanzhe Jin, Xiangguo Liu, Qi ZhuarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

The safe operation of Connected and Automated Vehicles (CAVs) relies heavily on robust Vehicle-to-Everything (V2X) communication. Currently, two primary standards compete for dominance: Dedicated Short Range Communications (DSRC), based on IEEE 802.11p, and Cellular Vehicle-to-Everything (C-V2X), based on 3GPP LTE/5G standards. While DSRC is a mature, decentralized technology, C-V2X offers the promise of extended range and lower latency through cellular infrastructure. This study provides a comparative analysis of these protocols across three critical traffic scenarios: ramp merging, intersection management, and platoon braking.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a high-fidelity simulation environment to evaluate the protocols. The stack included Veins for network-traffic coupling, SUMO for microscopic traffic modeling, and Plexe for specialized platooning simulations.

The evaluation focused on three distinct scenarios:

  1. Ramp Merging: Vehicles merging from a ramp onto a main road at varying angles and traffic densities.
  2. Intersections: A delay-tolerant management system controlling two connected intersections.
  3. Platoon Braking: An emergency braking event within a vehicle platoon to measure safety margins.

Performance was measured using metrics such as road time, brake time, and Minimum Inter-vehicle Distance (MIVD).

Results and Discussion

Ramp Merging Performance

In the ramp merging scenario, the performance of both protocols was comparable at low vehicle densities. However, as traffic density increased, C-V2X demonstrated a clear advantage. At a density of 2000 vehicles per hour, C-V2X achieved a merge time of 38.11 seconds, outperforming DSRC's 40.51 seconds. This suggests that C-V2X's higher communication frequency allows for more efficient coordination in congested merging environments.

Road Time in Ramp Merging

Intersection Coordination

Contrary to the merging results, DSRC showed superior performance in high-density intersection scenarios. At a density of 700 vehicles, DSRC-equipped vehicles cleared the intersections in 59.77 seconds, while C-V2X-equipped vehicles took 68.35 seconds. This edge is attributed to the specific intersection control model used, which favors the stable, "one-time" communication characteristics of DSRC over the high-frequency updates of C-V2X.

Platoon Braking Safety

The most significant safety differences were observed during emergency platoon braking. C-V2X provided a substantial safety buffer, maintaining a Minimum Inter-vehicle Distance (MIVD) of 8.74 meters even at high densities. In contrast, DSRC's MIVD dropped to 5.09 meters, indicating a much higher risk of collisions. Furthermore, C-V2X enabled the platoon to come to a complete stop faster (4.13s vs. 4.81s for DSRC).

Platoon Braking Performance Metrics

Conclusion

The choice between DSRC and C-V2X is not binary; rather, it depends on the specific traffic context. C-V2X excels in high-density safety-critical maneuvers like merging and platooning due to its superior range and update frequency. DSRC, however, remains highly effective and potentially more efficient for infrastructure-heavy coordination like intersection management. Future research should explore hybrid models or machine-learning-based protocol switching to leverage the strengths of both standards dynamically.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{jin2022dsrc,
  author = {Yuanzhe Jin and Xiangguo Liu and Qi Zhu},
  title = {{DSRC \& C-V2X Comparison for Connected and Automated Vehicles in Different Traffic Scenarios}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2203.12553},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.12553},
}
Figure