Traffic Management for Emergency Vehicle Priority Based on Visual Sensing

Nellore Kapileswar, Gerhard P. Hancke

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel system for prioritizing emergency vehicles at intersections using visual sensing to detect their distance and a modified MAC protocol (PE-MAC) to ensure rapid communication of this information. The system aims to reduce emergency response times by dynamically adjusting traffic signals, ultimately saving lives and property.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traffic congestion is a global issue that significantly impacts emergency vehicle response times. Traditional traffic light systems operate on fixed schedules, failing to account for the urgent needs of emergency vehicles like ambulances, fire engines, and police cars. When these vehicles are caught in traffic jams, their arrival at critical incidents is delayed, leading to potentially fatal consequences and property loss. Existing solutions often rely on GPS or other infrastructure-heavy methods, prompting the need for a more efficient, cost-effective, and integrated approach.

Methods

The proposed solution combines several key components:

  • Visual Sensing for Distance Measurement: Instead of relying solely on GPS, the system uses cameras at intersections to capture real-time video. This visual data is processed to determine the distance between an approaching emergency vehicle and the intersection. The paper evaluates three distance calculation techniques: Euclidean, Manhattan, and Canberra distances, concluding that Euclidean distance offers the best performance for this application.
  • Vehicle Counting: Alongside distance, the system also counts vehicles to better understand traffic flow and potential congestion. This is achieved through standard image processing techniques like grayscale conversion, foreground extraction, thresholding, and morphological operations.
  • Priority for Emergency Traffic Based MAC (PE-MAC) Protocol: To ensure that critical emergency vehicle information reaches the Traffic Management Center (TMC) quickly, the authors propose a modified Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol. PE-MAC is built upon the IEEE 802.11p standard and introduces a new back-off selection and contention window adjustment scheme. This modification prioritizes emergency vehicle data over normal vehicle data, significantly reducing transmission delays.
  • VANET Model and Simulation: A Vehicle Ad-Hoc Network (VANET) model for an Urban Traffic Management System (UTMS) was developed and simulated using the NS-2 network simulator. This allowed for the evaluation of the proposed PE-MAC protocol against the standard IEEE 802.11p and other protocols like IEEE 802.15.4.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The authors mention collecting "five input videos of road traffic, around four to eight minutes were recorded" for their vehicle counting and distance measurement simulations, but these do not appear to be publicly released datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Visual Sensing as a Cost-Effective Alternative: Using existing camera infrastructure for distance measurement offers a more practical and potentially less expensive solution compared to GPS-dependent systems.
  • Euclidean Distance Superiority: For real-time visual sensing applications in traffic management, the Euclidean distance calculation proved to be the most accurate and suitable method.
  • PE-MAC Significantly Reduces Delay: The custom PE-MAC protocol demonstrates a substantial improvement in reducing the delay for transmitting emergency vehicle data, which is crucial for timely traffic signal adjustments.
  • Integrated System Approach: The paper highlights the importance of integrating sensing (visual), communication (PE-MAC), and control (TMC) for an effective emergency vehicle priority system.

Key Results

  • Distance Measurement Accuracy: The Euclidean distance measurement achieved an accuracy of 98.60%, significantly outperforming Manhattan distance (77.61%) and Canberra distance (28.78%).
  • PE-MAC Performance:
    • End-to-End Delay: PE-MAC showed a significant reduction in average end-to-end delay compared to IEEE 802.11p. For instance, with 100 nodes, PE-MAC achieved a delay of 40s, while IEEE 802.11p had 98s (a ~60% improvement).
  • Throughput: PE-MAC maintained better throughput, delivering approximately 15.8 Kbps with 100 nodes, compared to 5 Kbps for IEEE 802.11p (a ~70% improvement).
  • Energy Consumption: PE-MAC consumed almost 50% less energy than IEEE 802.11p.
  • Comparison with Other Protocols: PE-MAC also outperformed IEEE 802.15.4 and EBSS in terms of average end-to-end delay, with improvements up to 45% over IEEE 802.15.4 and 16.6% over EBSS at a 60s transmission interval.
  • Emergency Vehicle Prioritization: The PE-MAC protocol effectively prioritizes ambulance data, showing the smallest end-to-end delay among all data types.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Conditions: The authors acknowledge that sensor performance, particularly for distance calculation, can be highly dependent on environmental conditions.
  • Bad Weather and High Traffic: Future research should focus on improving distance measurement accuracy in challenging conditions like bad weather and extremely high traffic densities.
  • Real-World Deployment: While simulated, the practical implementation and scalability of the system in a real-world urban environment would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Vehicular traffic is endlessly increasing everywhere in the world and can cause terrible traffic congestion at intersections. Most of the traffic lights today feature a fixed green light sequence, therefore the green light sequence is determined without taking the presence of the emergency vehicles into account. Therefore, emergency vehicles such as ambulances, police cars, fire engines, etc. stuck in a traffic jam and delayed in reaching their destination can lead to loss of property and valuable lives. This paper presents an approach to schedule emergency vehicles in traffic. The approach combines the measurement of the distance between the emergency vehicle and an intersection using visual sensing methods, vehicle counting and time sensitive alert transmission within the sensor network. The distance between the emergency vehicle and the intersection is calculated for comparison using Euclidean distance, Manhattan distance and Canberra distance techniques. The experimental results have shown that the Euclidean distance outperforms other distance measurement techniques. Along with visual sensing techniques to collect emergency vehicle information, it is very important to have a Medium Access Control (MAC) protocol to deliver the emergency vehicle information to the Traffic Management Center (TMC) with less delay. Then only the emergency vehicle is quickly served and can reach the destination in time. In this paper, we have also investigated the MAC layer in WSNs to prioritize the emergency vehicle data and to reduce the transmission delay for emergency messages. We have modified the medium access procedure used in standard IEEE 802.11p with PE-MAC protocol, which is a new back off selection and contention window adjustment scheme to achieve low broadcast delay for emergency messages. A VANET model for the UTMS is developed and simulated in NS-2. The performance of the standard IEEE 802.11p and the proposed PE-MAC is analysed in detail. The NS-2 simulation results have shown that the PE-MAC outperforms the IEEE 802.11p in terms of average end-to-end delay, throughput and energy consumption. The performance evaluation results have proven that the proposed PE-MAC prioritizes the emergency vehicle data and delivers the emergency messages to the TMC with less delay compared to the IEEE 802.11p. The transmission delay of the proposed PE-MAC is also compared with the standard IEEE 802.15.4, and Enhanced Back-off Selection scheme for IEEE 802.15.4 protocol [EBSS, an existing protocol to ensure fast transmission of the detected events on the road towards the TMC] and the comparative results have proven the effectiveness of the PE-MAC over them. Furthermore, this research work will provide an insight into the design of an intelligent urban traffic management system for the effective management of emergency vehicles and will help to save lives and property.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kapileswar2016traffic,
  author = {Nellore Kapileswar and Gerhard P. Hancke},
  title = {{Traffic Management for Emergency Vehicle Priority Based on Visual Sensing}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=56wncImzrL0v},
}

Loading related content...

Figure