Towards the optimisation of direct laser acceleration

Amina Hussein, Alexey Arefiev, Thomas Batson, H Chen, R. S. Craxton, Andrew Davies, D. H. Froula, Zheng Gong, D. Haberberger, Y. Ma, P. M. Nilson, W. Theobald, T. Wang, Kathleen Weichman, G. J. Williams, L. Willingale

TL;DR

Researchers have demonstrated direct laser acceleration (DLA) of electrons to MeV energies with significant charge (nC range) using picosecond laser pulses on low-density plasmas. This work highlights the crucial role of self-generated magnetic fields within the plasma channel, alongside electric fields, in confining and accelerating electrons, offering a promising avenue for generating high-energy, high-charge electron beams for various applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The generation of high-energy electron beams is a key goal in plasma physics, with applications ranging from advanced X-ray sources to particle accelerators. While laser wakefield acceleration (LWFA) is known for producing high-energy, low-divergence electron beams, it typically yields low charge. Direct Laser Acceleration (DLA), particularly with longer (picosecond) laser pulses, offers the potential for higher charge, which is desirable for many applications. However, the precise mechanisms governing DLA, especially the interplay of laser fields and plasma-induced fields, and how to optimize it, remain areas of active investigation. This paper aims to experimentally and computationally explore the optimal conditions for DLA using picosecond pulses and to elucidate the roles of various plasma fields in the acceleration process.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Experimental Measurements: Experiments were conducted at the OMEGA EP laser facility. A 1.0 ps, 400 J laser pulse was used to interact with an underdense hydrocarbon plasma plume. Electron beams were diagnosed using radiochromic film (RCF) stacks for beam pointing and divergence, and an absolutely calibrated magnetic spectrometer for electron energy spectra. Plasma density was varied by adjusting the laser interaction height and measured using angular filter refractometry (AFR).
  • 2D Particle-in-Cell (PIC) Simulations: Fully self-consistent 2D PIC simulations using the EPOCH code were performed to model the laser-plasma interaction. These simulations were designed to match the experimental conditions, including laser parameters and plasma densities. The simulations allowed for detailed examination of the laser propagation, plasma response, and electron dynamics, including the evolution of electric and magnetic fields within the plasma channel.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper presents experimental data and simulation results, but does not refer to pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Optimal Plasma Density for DLA: The research identified a specific "sweet spot" in plasma density (around 0.028 $n_{crit}$) where DLA is most effective, leading to the highest electron energies and charges.
  • Crucial Role of Channel Magnetic Fields: Contrary to previous focus on electric fields, this work strongly emphasizes the significant contribution of self-generated quasi-static azimuthal magnetic fields within the plasma channel. These magnetic fields act as a confinement boundary for electrons, comparable to the transverse electric field.
  • DLA Dominance: The study confirms DLA as the primary acceleration mechanism for picosecond pulses in this regime, characterized by electrons being expelled from the laser axis and accelerated within a formed channel.
  • Magnetic Field Robustness: The authors highlight that magnetic fields are less susceptible to ion motion compared to electric fields, making them a more stable influence for electron acceleration, especially at higher laser intensities and longer pulse durations.
  • Electron Dynamics and X-ray Generation Potential: The observed acceleration and deceleration of electrons within the channel suggest potential for generating high-energy X-ray sources, with DLA potentially producing higher-amplitude betatron oscillations than LWFA.

Key Results

  • Experimental: Electron beams with energies up to (505 ± 75) MeV and charges up to (140 ± 30) nC were achieved at the optimal plasma density of 0.028 $n_{crit}$.
  • Simulations: 2D PIC simulations reproduced the experimental trends of electron energy gain as a function of target density, providing insight into the underlying physics.
  • Field Contributions: Simulations revealed that the quasi-static transverse electric field and the self-generated magnetic field play comparable roles in defining the boundary of electron motion. The magnetic field's relative magnitude was found to be comparable to that of the transverse electric field.
  • Beam Characteristics: Electron beams were observed to be broadband, with divergence and pointing influenced by plasma density and potential refraction effects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • 2D vs. 3D Simulations: The authors acknowledge that 2D simulations may underestimate effects like diffraction and self-focusing, which could impact a direct quantitative comparison with experimental results. However, they note that 2D simulations are qualitatively similar to 3D simulations in capturing key phenomena.
  • Discrepancy in Electron Injection: A discrepancy between the predicted maximum transverse displacement from theory and the observed width in simulations is noted, potentially due to higher initial y-factors from transverse injection.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that the demonstrated capability to generate high-energy, high-charge electron beams using DLA could enable new applications such as positron production and experimental verification of the two-photon Breit-Wheeler process. Furthermore, the ability to drive bright X-ray sources with ultrashort duration and synchronize them with laser-initiated events is highlighted as a promising future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Experimental measurements using the OMEGA EP laser facility demonstrated direct laser acceleration (DLA) of electron beams to (505 ± 75) MeV with (140 ± 30) nC of charge from a low-density plasma target using a 400 J, picosecond duration pulse. Similar trends of electron energy with target density are also observed in self-consistent two-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations. The intensity of the laser pulse is sufficiently large that the electrons are rapidly expelled along the laser pulse propagation axis to form a channel. The dominant acceleration mechanism is confirmed to be DLA and the effect of quasi-static channel fields on energetic electron dynamics is examined. A strong channel magnetic field, self-generated by the accelerated electrons, is found to play a comparable role to the transverse electric channel field in defining the boundary of electron motion.
BibTeX
@article{hussein2021towards,
  author = {Amina Hussein and Alexey Arefiev and Thomas Batson and H Chen and R. S. Craxton and Andrew Davies and D. H. Froula and Zheng Gong and D. Haberberger and Y. Ma and P. M. Nilson and W. Theobald and T. Wang and Kathleen Weichman and G. J. Williams and L. Willingale},
  title = {{Towards the optimisation of direct laser acceleration}},
  journal = {New Journal of Physics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1367-2630/abdf9a},
}
Figure