Abstract: Twisted 2D materials form complex moiré structures that spontaneously reduce symmetry through picoscale deformation within a mesoscale lattice. We show twisted 2D materials contain a torsional displacement field comprised of three transverse periodic lattice distortions (PLD). The torsional PLD amplitude provides a single order parameter that concisely describes the structural complexity of twisted bilayer moirés. Moreover, the structure and amplitude of a torsional periodic lattice distortion is quantifiable using rudimentary electron diffraction methods sensitive to reciprocal space. In twisted bilayer graphene, the torsional PLD begins to form at angles below 3.89° and the amplitude reaches 8 pm around the magic angle of 1.1°. At extremely low twist angles (e.g. below 0.25°) the amplitude increases and additional PLD harmonics arise to expand Bernal stacked domains separated by well defined solitonic boundaries. The torsional distortion field in twisted bilayer graphene is analytically described and has an upper bound of 22.6 pm. Similar torsional distortions are observed in twisted WS$_2$, CrI$_3$, and WSe$_2$ / MoSe$_2$.
Introduction
When two layers of a 2D material, such as graphene, are stacked with a small relative twist, they form a moiré pattern. At large twist angles, the layers behave as independent sheets. However, as the twist angle decreases toward the "magic angle," the atoms undergo spontaneous picoscale shifts to minimize the system's total energy. This structural restructuring is fundamental to the emergence of exotic electronic states, including unconventional superconductivity and correlated magnetism.
Historically, describing this restructuring has been challenging, often requiring complex local stacking descriptions or intensive computational simulations. There has been a lack of a simple, universal "order parameter"—a single metric to quantify lattice deformation across a sample. This research introduces the torsional periodic lattice distortion (PLD) model to address this gap, transforming a complex structural problem into a manageable mathematical framework.
The Torsional PLD Model
The core of the proposed model is that atomic shifts in twisted bilayers can be represented as a torsional PLD field. This field consists of three transverse displacement waves oriented 120° apart, creating a rotational displacement pattern around high-symmetry stacking sites.
The researchers validated this model using several techniques:
- Quantitative Electron Diffraction: Selected Area Electron Diffraction (SAED) was used to observe superlattice peaks. The intensity of these peaks allows for the direct calculation of the distortion amplitude ($A_1$).
- Multislice Simulations: Quantum mechanical simulations of electron scattering confirmed that the PLD model accurately reflects experimental data.
- Analytical Modeling: A semi-empirical model was derived based on the competition between interlayer van der Waals (vdW) forces (favoring stable Bernal stacking) and intralayer elastic forces (resisting lattice deformation).
Key Insights and Structural Evolution
The complex, picoscale "tug-of-war" in a moiré lattice is effectively described by the PLD amplitude ($A_1$). The relationship between twist angle and distortion amplitude follows a Lorentzian function: as the angle decreases, the amplitude increases toward a physical limit. For twisted bilayer graphene, the theoretical maximum distortion is calculated to be 22.6 pm.
At angles near 1°, the distortion is a smooth sinusoidal wave. At very low angles (<0.5°), higher harmonics emerge, sharpening the waves into distinct Bernal-stacked domains separated by narrow soliton boundaries.
Experimental Results Across Systems
The model was successfully applied to various 2D systems beyond graphene:
- Twisted Bilayer Graphene (TBG): Distortions become measurable below 3.89°. At the 1.1° magic angle, the atomic shift is approximately 8 pm.
- Transition Metal Dichalcogenides and Magnets: The model matched diffraction patterns for twisted $WS_2$, $CrI_3$, and $WSe_2/MoSe_2$ heterostructures, demonstrating its universality.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While the Fourier-series-based PLD model is highly effective, it becomes computationally heavy as the twist angle approaches zero due to the high number of harmonics needed for sharp soliton boundaries. In such extreme cases, dislocation-based models may be more efficient.
Future applications of the PLD amplitude include using it as a standard metric to correlate structural quality with electronic performance. This could provide insights into why devices with identical nominal twist angles can exhibit vastly different physical properties.
Summary updated