Abstract
The local Lie algebra of the Standard Model (SM) is $su(3)\times su(2) \times u(1)$, yet its global gauge group, $G_{{\rm SM}_{\rm q}}=$SU(3)$\times$SU(2)$\times$U(1)/$\mathbb{Z}_{\rm q}$, q$=1,2,3,6$ remains undetermined. Building on previous work on 4d anomalies and 5d cobordism invariants, we classify lower-dimensional invertible field theories (iFTs) or symmetry-protected topological states (SPTs) in 4d, 3d, 2d, and 1d. While the integer SPTs are hard to detect, the fractional SPTs produce measurable topological responses. In particular, the symmetry fractionalization labeled by $k\in\mathbb{Z}_{6/{\rm q}}$ in [arXiv:2411.18160] introduces the symmetry-enriched SM variants, denoted as SM$_{({\rm q},k)}$. We further introduce a new integer $n$ series of baryon-minus-lepton $({\bf B}-{\bf L})$-like U(1) symmetries, $X_n \equiv n (\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{L}) + (1-\frac{n}{N_c})\tilde{Y}$ with electroweak hypercharge $\tilde{Y}$, $n\ge1$, $N_c=3$, where the charge $q_{X_n} = q_{\tilde{Y}} \mod n$. Analyzing the symmetry-enriched SM with 0-form and 1-form symmetries $(G_{[0]}, G_{[1]})$, symmetry-twist group homomorphism $ρ$, and symmetry frationalization obstruction $[β]$, their spacetime-internal gauge bundle constraints, and their mixed anomalies, we derive the fractional topological response $σ_n({\rm q},k)=\frac{{\rm q}(1-n)\gcd(2,n)}{2n}+\frac{k{\rm q}}{6}\mod1.$ Our $σ_n$ response requires more general Spin$^c$ manifolds for odd $n$ and Spin manifolds for even $n$. For a given $n$ (with $n\ge 7$ and $n\ne 10,12,15,30$), $σ_n$ uniquely fixes the gauge group parameter q and fractionalization label $k$. Moreover, using pairs such as $(n_1,n_2)=(2,3),(2,5),(3,4),(3,5),(4,5)$, etc. uniquely distinguishes SM$_{({\rm q},k)}$. Our results illuminate the global structure of the SM gauge group via measurable topological responses.
Introduction: The Global Structure Problem
A fundamental mystery in particle physics is the global structure of the Standard Model (SM) gauge group. While the local Lie algebra is well-established as $su(3) \times su(2) \times u(1)$, the global Lie group—the actual topology of the symmetry space—remains undetermined. It could be any of four possibilities: $G_{SM_q} = (SU(3) \times SU(2) \times U(1))/\mathbb{Z}_q$, where $q \in \{1, 2, 3, 6\}$.
Current experimental data cannot distinguish between these variants because they share the same local physics. The differences emerge only in topological properties, such as the spectrum of allowed line operators (e.g., Wilson lines) and interactions with the global topology of spacetime. This work proposes using fractional topological responses, which are robust and potentially measurable, to reveal the SM's global identity.
Methodology: The $X_n$ Symmetry Probe
To probe the gauge group, the authors introduce a new integer series of $U(1)$ symmetries, denoted as $X_n$. These are linear combinations of the Baryon-minus-Lepton number ($B-L$) and the electroweak hypercharge ($\tilde{Y}$): $$X_n \equiv n(\mathbf{B}-\mathbf{L}) + (1-\frac{n}{N_c})\tilde{Y}$$ where $N_c=3$ is the number of colors. By varying the integer $n$, the gauge group can be probed at different scales, effectively providing a "multi-frequency" analysis of the global structure.
The analysis involves deriving how the flux of these $X_n$ symmetries must be mathematically consistent with the curvature of spacetime (represented by Stiefel-Whitney classes). By looking at "mixed anomalies" (mathematical inconsistencies that occur when certain symmetries are combined), the authors calculate the 4D fractional response that must exist to cancel out 5D effects.
Key Results: Uniquely Identifying the Gauge Group
The central achievement is the derivation of the fractional topological response formula: $$\sigma_n(q, k) = \frac{q(1-n)\gcd(2,n)}{2n} + \frac{kq}{6} \mod 1$$
This formula shows that for a fixed $n$, different $(q, k)$ pairs yield distinct fractional values. These values act as measurable "fingerprints" for the global gauge group.
- Discrimination Power: For $n \ge 7$ (excluding specific values like 10, 12, 15, 30), a single measurement of $\sigma_n$ uniquely determines both $q$ and $k$.
- Pairing Strategy: For lower values of $n$, measuring a pair of responses (e.g., $\sigma_2$ and $\sigma_3$) is sufficient to uniquely identify the SM variant.
- Spacetime Sensitivity: The response is sensitive to the underlying spacetime manifold, requiring Spin manifolds for even $n$ and Spin$^c$ manifolds for odd $n$.
Conclusion and Future Directions
This research provides a theoretical roadmap for determining the global structure of the Standard Model gauge group through measurable topological responses. While the paper establishes the mathematical framework, the next major challenge is designing experimental setups capable of detecting these fractional signals. Future work may also explore more complex symmetry extensions where 1-form symmetries are non-trivially intertwined with other discrete symmetries like parity or time-reversal.
Summary updated