Topological defects and bulk melting of hexagonal ice

Davide Donadio, Paolo Raiteri, Michele Parrinello

Abstract: We use classical molecular dynamics combined with the recently developed metadynamics method to study the process of bulk melting in hexagonal ice. Our simulations show that bulk melting is mediated by the formation of topological defects which preserve the coordination of the tetrahedral network. Such defects cluster to form a defective region involving about 50 molecules with a surprisingly long life-time. The subsequent formation of coordination defects triggers the transition to the liquid state.

Introduction

Under standard conditions, ice melts from the surface inward. However, understanding bulk melting—the internal breakdown of a solid lattice in the absence of surface effects—remains a fundamental challenge in condensed matter physics. Because bulk melting is a "rare event" on the timescales of standard molecular dynamics (MD), researchers often rely on extreme superheating, which can obscure the underlying physical mechanism. This study investigates the melting process near the actual melting temperature (~270 K) to determine whether the lattice collapses catastrophically or through the systematic accumulation of structural flaws.

Methods

The researchers employed classical molecular dynamics enhanced by metadynamics, a technique that allows for the exploration of complex free-energy landscapes by adding a history-dependent bias potential. This bias prevents the system from remaining trapped in the stable crystal state, accelerating the discovery of transition states and defects.

To monitor the transition, the authors utilized specific Collective Variables (CVs): potential energy and ring statistics. They developed a continuous function to count 5- and 6-membered water molecule rings, enabling the identification of topological shifts in the tetrahedral network. The TIP5P force field was used as the physical model, chosen for its accuracy in reproducing water's density anomaly and hydrogen bond dynamics near the melting point.

The Role of Topological Defects

The study identifies the "5+7" defect as the primary driver of melting. In these defects, the standard 6-membered rings of the hexagonal ice (Ih) lattice transform into pairs of 5- and 7-membered rings. Crucially, these topological changes preserve the four-fold coordination of the water molecules; the hydrogen bond network remains intact even as the local geometry is distorted.

Visualization of a topological defect cluster (red) embedded within the hexagonal ice lattice (grey).

The Pre-Melt Basin and Cluster Formation

Rather than appearing as isolated, random occurrences, these defects tend to condense into clusters. The simulations revealed a metastable "pre-melt" basin consisting of a cluster of approximately 50 molecules. These clusters are remarkably long-lived, with an average lifetime of ~0.4 ns at 270 K, acting as a nucleus for further disorder.

Free energy landscape showing the transition from solid ice to liquid via a metastable pre-melt basin characterized by the accumulation of 5-membered rings.

Analysis of the free energy landscape shows that the most stable 5+7 defect sits 6.9 kcal/mol above the ideal crystal, with a formation barrier of roughly 8.9 kcal/mol. The transition to the "pre-melt" cluster state requires overcoming a barrier of approximately 12 kcal/mol. The final collapse into the liquid state is only triggered when "coordination defects" (molecules with more or fewer than four neighbors) finally emerge within these topological clusters.

Conclusion

These findings suggest that bulk melting in hexagonal ice is a choreographed process rather than a sudden collapse. The identification of elongated, anisotropic defect clusters aligned along specific crystallographic directions (331) provides a potential target for experimental validation. Furthermore, the observation of similar 5+7 defect aggregations in materials like silicon suggests that this may be a universal mechanism for the melting of tetrahedral networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

We use classical molecular dynamics combined with the recently developed metadynamics method [A. Laio and M. Parrinello, Procs. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99, 20 (2002)] to study the process of bulk melting in hexagonal ice. Our simulations show that bulk melting is mediated by the formation of topological defects which preserve the coordination of the tetrahedral network. Such defects cluster to form a defective region involving about 50 molecules with a surprisingly long life-time. The subsequent formation of coordination defects triggers the transition to the liquid state.
BibTeX
@article{donadio2005topological,
  author = {Davide Donadio and Paolo Raiteri and Michele Parrinello},
  title = {{Topological defects and bulk melting of hexagonal ice}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry B},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1021/jp050690z},
}
Figure