Topographical Discrepancy in Heavy Metal Pollution and Risk Assessment from Cornfields in the Licheng District, China

Haiyang Jiang, Wenxian Sun, Rui Li, Yanling Cao, Wenfeng Zhu, Chao ZhangSustainability 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how topography influences heavy metal (HM) pollution and ecological risk in cornfields in China's Licheng District. It reveals that higher elevations generally exhibit greater HM contamination, likely due to stronger anthropogenic activities, but overall risks remain low across the district.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heavy metal (HM) contamination in agricultural soils is a significant global concern, posing risks to human health and ecosystem stability. While various factors contribute to HM disparities in soils, the role of topography, particularly in diverse agricultural landscapes, is not fully understood. This paper aims to address this gap by examining how elevation differences (high vs. low terrain) affect HM pollution levels, sources, and associated ecological risks in cornfields within the Licheng District, China. Understanding these topographical influences is crucial for developing targeted remediation strategies and promoting sustainable land management.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess HM pollution and risk. They collected topsoil samples from 90 sampling grids across the Licheng District. Key analytical techniques included:

  • Physicochemical Analysis: Soil pH and organic matter content were measured using standard laboratory methods (FE28-FiveEasy pH meter and a specific wet chemistry method for organic matter).
  • Heavy Metal Analysis: Concentrations of nine HMs (Cu, Zn, Cd, Cr, Ni, Pb, As, and Hg) were determined. Digestion of soil samples was followed by analysis using Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission Spectrometry (ICP-OES) for most metals and Atomic Fluorescence Spectrometry (AFS) for As and Hg.
  • Pollution Assessment: The single-factor pollution index ($P_i$) and the Nemerow comprehensive pollution index ($P_N$) were used to evaluate the degree of HM contamination.
  • Ecological Risk Assessment: The potential ecological risk index ($E_i$) for individual metals and the integrated potential ecological risk index (RI) were calculated to assess the environmental hazards posed by HMs.
  • Statistical Analysis: ArcGIS 10.2 was used for spatial mapping, Origin 2020 for data visualization, and SPSS 22 for Principal Component Analysis (PCA) with varimax rotation to identify HM sources. Pearson correlation analysis was used to explore relationships between HMs and soil properties.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples collected from the corn-growing region of the Licheng District, Jinan City, Shandong Province, China. The background values for soil HMs in Shandong Province were used for comparison. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Topography Matters: Higher elevations in the Licheng District generally show higher concentrations of most heavy metals compared to lower-lying areas. This suggests that topographical features play a significant role in HM distribution.
  • Anthropogenic Influence Amplified by Elevation: Stronger anthropogenic influences, such as industrial activities, traffic emissions, and agricultural practices (fertilization), appear to be more pronounced in high-terrain areas, leading to increased HM contamination.
  • Cd and As are Key Concerns: Cadmium (Cd) and Arsenic (As) showed particularly high over-standard rates in both low-lying and high-lying areas, indicating their widespread presence beyond natural background levels.
  • Overall Low Risk, but Nuances Exist: Despite some localized high concentrations, the integrated ecological risk assessment indicated a generally low risk for HMs across the entire district. However, specific metals like Cd and Hg exhibited moderate ecological hazards at certain sites.
  • Soil Properties Play a Role: Soil pH and organic matter content were found to influence HM behavior. For instance, low-terrain Cu, Zn, and Cd showed negative associations with pH, while other HMs were positively correlated with organic matter, suggesting complex interactions.

Key Results

  • Over-Standard Rates: Cd and As had over-standard rates exceeding 50% in low-lying areas, while high-lying areas also showed over-standard rates for HMs above 50%, with generally higher rates in high terrain.
  • Pollution Index: Only Cu, Ni, Pb, and Hg showed "clean" levels in both low- and high-lying areas based on the single-factor pollution index. Zn, Cd, and Cr indicated potential pollution.
  • Contamination Factor (CF): The CF values indicated that while most metals were within acceptable ranges, Cd and Hg showed higher CF values, particularly in high terrain, suggesting potential contamination.
  • Ecological Risk: The integrated potential ecological risk index (RI) for the low-lying area averaged 106.48, indicating low integrated risk. The high-lying area averaged 144.03, also suggesting low comprehensive ecological risk, though some sites exhibited moderate to exacerbated risks.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA): PCA identified two major components explaining 76% of the variance in the low-lying region, suggesting mixed natural and anthropogenic sources. In the high-lying region, PC1 (45% variance) was heavily weighted by HMs associated with anthropogenic activities.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope: The study focused on cornfields and did not explore other agricultural land uses or non-agricultural areas.
  • Other Physicochemical Properties: The authors acknowledge that other soil physicochemical properties, such as soil texture and cation exchange capacity, were not explored but could influence HM behavior. This is suggested as a direction for future research.
  • Specific Anthropogenic Sources: While anthropogenic influences were identified as key drivers, a more detailed breakdown of specific industrial, traffic, and agricultural sources could provide more targeted remediation insights.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that promoting scientific agricultural techniques, new energy vehicles, and cleaner production can further reduce HM pollution and associated risks. Future studies could delve deeper into the specific mechanisms of HM accumulation and transport influenced by topography and explore a wider range of soil properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

Heavy metal pollution refers to the presence of excessive levels of heavy metal elements in soil beyond their natural background concentrations, posing serious threats to human health and ecological systems. Several factors are involved in the contamination disparity in agriculture soils from various terrains, demanding extra care. An examination of the topographical HM dispersions in farmland soils from the Licheng District was conducted to reveal spatial changes in pollution levels and sources and to establish an empirical framework to develop targeted remediation strategies and promote sustainable land management practices. Cd and As had over-standard rates of more than 50% in the low-lying area, whereas the HMs in the high-lying area had over-standard rates of more than 50%. Also, the rates of HMs in high terrain were higher than in low terrain. Using the single-factor pollution index, only low-lying Cu, Ni, Pb, and Hg contamination levels were clean in low-lying and high-lying areas. The overall decline in HM pollution occurred from high to low terrain, triggered by soil physicochemical properties and human interventions. Meanwhile, strong anthropogenic influence fell in high terrain for pollution. Nevertheless, low levels of HM-integrated contamination prevailed in both topographies. Natural and anthropogenic processes gave rise to environmental pollution, such as soil formation, fertilization, metal smelting, and traffic emissions. Overall, the district held a low risk for HMs. The results highlight that strong anthropogenic interventions resulted in increased HM contamination, in addition to natural processes. It is possible to further reduce HM pollution and risk by promoting scientific agricultural techniques, new energy vehicles, and cleaner production.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2025topographical,
  author = {Haiyang Jiang and Wenxian Sun and Rui Li and Yanling Cao and Wenfeng Zhu and Chao Zhang},
  title = {{Topographical Discrepancy in Heavy Metal Pollution and Risk Assessment from Cornfields in the Licheng District, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/su17104420},
}
Figure