To Share or Not to Share? The Optimal Technology Investment in a Virtual Product Supply Chain

Yuan Fang, Bin Shen, Yifan CaoSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how virtual technology platforms and brand owners should share consumer preference information in the burgeoning virtual goods market. It finds that platforms generally benefit from sharing this information, and both parties can achieve a "win-win" scenario when consumers strongly prefer virtual products.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The virtual economy, particularly through platforms like the Metaverse, is rapidly growing, with brands increasingly selling virtual products. A key challenge in this "brand + platform" model is information asymmetry: the virtual technology platform often has superior insights into consumer preferences for virtual goods compared to the brand owner. This paper investigates how this information asymmetry impacts optimal technology investment and pricing decisions within the supply chain, and crucially, whether and when sharing this private information benefits all parties involved.

Methods

The authors employ a game-theoretic approach, specifically a signaling game, to model the interactions between a brand owner and a virtual technology platform. The core of their model is the virtual technology investment (VTI) made by the platform, which acts as a signal of consumer preference. They analyze two main scenarios: "no information sharing," where the platform's VTI is used to infer consumer preferences, and "information sharing," where the platform directly reveals its knowledge. They use backward induction to solve for optimal strategies and profits under different equilibrium conditions (separating and pooling).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • VTI as a Signal: The paper highlights that a platform's investment in virtual technology can serve as a credible signal to the brand owner about consumer preferences, even without direct information sharing.
  • Platform's Preference for Sharing: The virtual technology platform consistently prefers to share its private consumer preference information. This is because, in a no-sharing scenario, the platform might incur "signaling costs" by distorting its investment to influence the brand owner's perception.
  • Win-Win Scenario: A mutually beneficial outcome (win-win) for both the brand owner and the platform occurs when consumers are highly likely to prefer virtual technology. In this situation, information sharing leads to higher profits for both.
  • Consumer Welfare Nuances: Consumer surplus is not always maximized with information sharing. It tends to be higher when consumers have a moderate likelihood of preferring virtual technology. In cases of very high or very low preference probability, consumers might be worse off with information sharing.

Key Results

  • Optimal Signaling: When consumers are less inclined towards virtual tech, platforms increase VTI to signal high preference. As consumer preference grows, platforms become less eager to signal.
  • Brand Owner's Preference: The brand owner's preference for information sharing depends on the probability of high consumer preference. They prefer sharing when this probability is high, but may favor no sharing when it's low.
  • Consumer Surplus Impact: Information sharing can lead to higher consumer surplus when consumer preference for virtual technology is moderate.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • No Market Entry Risk: The model assumes no risk associated with entering a new market. Future work could incorporate business risks and risk attitudes of supply chain members.
  • Perfect Information for Platform: The model assumes the virtual technology platform has perfect knowledge of consumer preferences. Future research could explore scenarios where platforms have more information than brands, but not perfect information.
  • Horizontal Competition: The current model focuses on a two-echelon supply chain. Expanding the analysis to include situations with horizontal competition among developers and/or platforms would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid rise of the virtual economy, the “brand + platform” virtual product distribution model led by virtual technology platforms has emerged, bringing a series of new virtual experiences to consumers. Considering that consumers have heterogeneous preferences for virtual technologies, we investigate a virtual product supply chain consisting of a brand owner, a virtual technology platform, and consumers (where the virtual technology platform has superior information about consumer preferences). We develop a signaling game model with preference information signaled by the virtual technology investment to study the optimal information-sharing strategy for the virtual product supply chain. We find that the virtual technology platform always prefers information sharing without paying any signaling cost. Moreover, we also observe that the brand owner and the platform can achieve alignment, that is, when consumers are more likely to prefer virtual technology, both the brand owner and the virtual technology platform are better off if the virtual technology platform chooses to share information with the brand owner. Finally, we analyze the consumer welfare and find that when consumers are moderately likely to prefer virtual technology, consumers can gain more benefits in the information-sharing scenario.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fang2022share,
  author = {Yuan Fang and Bin Shen and Yifan Cao},
  title = {{To Share or Not to Share? The Optimal Technology Investment in a Virtual Product Supply Chain}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141912858},
}
Figure