Abstract
Traditional robot path planning for high-level tasks often assumes a perfect map, which is rarely available in real-world scenarios. This paper introduces a "regret-based" framework for planning under Linear Temporal Logic (LTL) specifications in environments where the map is only partially known. By minimizing the difference between the actual cost incurred and the best possible cost achievable with hindsight, the proposed algorithm allows robots to intelligently balance the risks of exploration against the potential rewards of finding shortcuts. We demonstrate that our approach is computationally efficient and more robust than traditional optimistic or pessimistic strategies.
Introduction
Robot path planning for complex tasks—often described using Linear Temporal Logic (LTL)—typically relies on the assumption of a complete and accurate environment map. In practice, however, robots frequently operate in partially-known environments where certain paths or "successor regions" remain unknown until the robot physically reaches them.
Existing approaches to this uncertainty typically fall into two extremes:
- Worst-Case (Pessimistic): The robot assumes every unknown region is a dead end. While safe, this leads to highly inefficient, overly conservative paths.
- Best-Case (Optimistic): The robot assumes every unknown region is a shortcut. This can lead to massive "regret" and wasted energy if those shortcuts do not exist.
The authors propose a middle ground: a regret-minimization strategy that decides if it is worth taking a detour to check for a potential shortcut based on the value of information.
Methods
The framework formalizes the problem through several novel structures:
- Partially-Known Weighted Transition Systems (PK-WTS): A modeling framework where states have "successor patterns." Connectivity is revealed only when the robot visits an adjacent state.
- Regret as a Metric: Instead of minimizing total cost, the robot minimizes regret—the difference between its actual cost and the cost it would have paid if it had known the true environment from the start.
- Knowledge-Based Game Arena: The problem is transformed into a two-player game on a bipartite graph between the robot and the "environment" (which reveals the truth of unknown regions). This arena tracks the robot's "knowledge set" to ensure consistent decision-making.
- Polynomial-Time Synthesis: The authors provide a value-iteration algorithm that reduces the regret-minimization problem to a min-max game. By introducing a new weight function construction that identifies "critical plays" (shortest paths to the goal), they achieve polynomial complexity, avoiding the exponential "graph-unfolding" required by previous methods.
Experimental Results
The approach was evaluated using synthetic benchmarks and a simulated firefighting case study.
Computational Efficiency
In tests with 80 nodes, the proposed algorithm required a state space of only 827 units. In contrast, the previous state-of-the-art regret-minimization algorithm required 6,700,000 units, demonstrating a massive improvement in scalability.
Performance Trade-offs
In simulations, the regret-based strategy consistently outperformed the worst-case strategy when the probability of obstacles was low-to-medium. It also proved significantly more robust than the "best-case" strategy, which fails catastrophically when obstacles are frequent.
In the firefighting case study—where a ground robot must find an extinguisher to put out a fire—the regret-based robot chose to explore a single promising unknown region. In a "good" environment, it saved 14 units of cost over the pessimistic approach. In a "bad" environment where the shortcut was blocked, it only paid a small penalty (8 units) for the attempt, whereas an optimistic approach would have incurred a much higher cost.
Conclusion and Future Work
Regret is a powerful metric for capturing the trade-off between actual cost and the potential benefit of exploration. By explicitly modeling the robot's memory in a Knowledge-Based Game Arena, the proposed framework ensures consistent and efficient planning.
Current limitations include a focus on "co-safe" LTL formulae (finite-time tasks) and static environments. Future work will aim to extend this framework to infinite-horizon tasks (e.g., perpetual patrolling), dynamic environments with moving obstacles, and multi-agent coordination with shared knowledge.
Summary updated