Regret-Free Reinforcement Learning for Temporal Logic Specifications

R Majumdar, Mahmoud Salamati, Sadegh SoudjaniICML 2025 · OpenReview

Introduction

In traditional reinforcement learning (RL), an agent learns to maximize a scalar reward. However, in robotics and safety-critical control, we often want the agent to satisfy complex, high-level requirements like "Visit region A, then B, while never entering C." These requirements are formally expressed using Linear Temporal Logic (LTL).

This paper introduces the first "regret-free" RL algorithm for systems with unknown dynamics governed by high-level LTL specifications. By reducing complex LTL tasks to simpler "reach-avoid" problems and implementing an optimistic learning strategy with episode-specific deadlines, the authors provide finite-time performance guarantees where previous methods only offered asymptotic convergence.

The Challenge of LTL in Unknown Environments

Applying RL to LTL specifications presents two primary challenges:

  1. Unknown Dynamics: The agent does not know the transition probabilities of the environment, which is modeled as a Markov Decision Process (MDP).
  2. Performance During Learning: Most existing LTL-RL algorithms only guarantee that the agent will eventually find the optimal policy (asymptotic convergence). They provide no insight into how much the agent "fails" or underperforms during the learning process itself.

To address this, the paper focuses on regret minimization. Regret is the difference in performance between an optimal policy (which has perfect knowledge of the dynamics) and the learning algorithm. A "regret-free" algorithm ensures that this performance gap grows sublinearly over time, meaning the agent's average performance approaches optimality rapidly.

Methods: The ZeroReg Architecture

The authors propose a novel algorithm called ZeroReg. Its architecture relies on several key innovations to bridge the gap between LTL specifications and regret-free learning.

Architecture of the ZeroReg algorithm, illustrating the separation of graph identification and regret-free policy synthesis, which outputs both a policy and an episode-specific deadline.
  • LTL to Reach-Avoid Reduction: The authors demonstrate that any general LTL specification can be transformed into a "reach-avoid" problem (reaching a set of "good" states while avoiding "bad" states) on a product MDP. This product MDP is a combination of the system dynamics and a deterministic Rabin automaton (DRA) representing the LTL formula.
  • Optimism in the Face of Uncertainty (OFU): The agent maintains an interval MDP (iMDP), representing the range of possible transition probabilities consistent with observed data. In each episode, the agent selects the "most optimistic" transition function within those intervals to compute its policy.
  • Episode-Specific Deadlines ($H_k$): A major hurdle in LTL is that the resulting product MDP is often "non-communicating"—meaning the agent can get permanently stuck in certain parts of the state space. To prevent the agent from being trapped in a sub-optimal loop during exploration, the algorithm introduces a deadline $H_k$ for each episode. If the goal isn't reached by the deadline, the episode resets.
  • Graph Identification: To handle general LTL, the agent needs to know which transitions are possible (the graph structure). The authors provide a separate polynomial-time algorithm to learn this structure, assuming a known minimum non-zero transition probability ($p_{min}$). As seen in the architecture diagram, this graph identification operates independently and feeds into the main policy synthesis module.

Experimental Validation

As a theoretical reinforcement learning paper, the authors evaluate their work using a simulated Gridworld environment.

  • The Map: A grid with walls acting as absorbing "avoid" states, a starting position, and a target "goal" state.
  • Dynamics: Movement succeeds with 90% probability and fails (resulting in no movement) with 10% probability.
  • Benchmarks: ZeroReg is compared against the $\omega$-PAC algorithm, the current state-of-the-art for PAC-learning (Probably Approximately Correct) in LTL environments.

Key Results and Insights

  • Finite-Time vs. Asymptotic Guarantees: The most significant contribution is the shift from asymptotic guarantees to finite-time bounds. Knowing exactly how much an algorithm might fail after $K$ episodes is crucial for deploying RL in real-world engineering, where bounding the cost of learning is necessary.
  • Sublinear Regret: The authors prove that ZeroReg achieves a regret bound of $O(\sqrt{K})$, where $K$ is the number of episodes. This is the gold standard for online learning algorithms.
  • Handling Non-Communicating MDPs: Most regret-free algorithms assume the MDP is "communicating" (any state can be reached from any other). Because LTL tasks naturally break this assumption, the use of the $H_k$ deadline serves as a clever "reset" mechanism, allowing the algorithm to remain regret-free even in restrictive environments.
  • Faster Convergence & Sample Efficiency: In gridworld experiments, ZeroReg converged significantly faster than the $\omega$-PAC algorithm. While $\omega$-PAC waits to collect a massive batch of samples before updating its policy, ZeroReg uses intermediate confidence bounds to improve its policy incrementally. The theoretical bounds for graph learning and policy synthesis are also sharper, requiring fewer environment interactions to reach target performance levels.

Limitations and Future Directions

While a significant step forward, the approach has a few limitations:

  • The $p_{min}$ Assumption: The graph-learning algorithm requires knowing a minimum transition probability. In highly complex or continuous-state systems, establishing a meaningful $p_{min}$ might be difficult.
  • Discrete State Spaces: The current work is limited to finite-state and action MDPs. Extending these regret-free guarantees to continuous state spaces—perhaps using function approximation or neural networks—remains a major open challenge.
  • Computational Complexity: The Extended Value Iteration (EVI) used to find the optimistic policy can become computationally expensive as the state space grows, particularly when combined with complex LTL-to-Automaton translations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Learning to control an unknown dynamical system with respect to high-level temporal specifications is an important problem in control theory. We present the first regret-free online algorithm for learning a controller for linear temporal logic (LTL) specifications for systems with unknown dynamics. We assume that the underlying (unknown) dynamics is modeled by a finite-state and action Markov decision process (MDPs). Our core technical result is a regret-free learning algorithm for infinite-horizon reach-avoid problems on MDPs. For general LTL specifications, we show that the synthesis problem can be reduced to a reach-avoid problem once the graph structure is known. Additionally, we provide an algorithm for learning the graph structure, assuming knowledge of a minimum transition probability, which operates independently of the main regret-free algorithm. Our LTL controller synthesis algorithm provides sharp bounds on how close we are to achieving optimal behavior after a finite number of learning episodes. In contrast, previous algorithms for LTL synthesis only provide asymptotic guarantees, which give no insight into the transient performance during the learning phase.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{majumdar2025regret,
  author = {R Majumdar and Mahmoud Salamati and Sadegh Soudjani},
  title = {{Regret-Free Reinforcement Learning for Temporal Logic Specifications}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Machine Learning},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=SqhhqMbqV3},
}
Figure