Time-resolved connectome of the five-factor model of personality

Luca Passamonti, Roberta Riccelli, Iole Indovina, Andrea Duggento, Antonio Terracciano, Nicola ToschiScientific 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the dynamic patterns of brain connectivity, or "connectome," relate to personality traits. They found that conscientiousness, a personality trait associated with self-discipline and goal-directedness, is linked to more stable, less dynamic functional connections between brain networks. This suggests a neural mechanism for how conscientious individuals maintain focus and resist distractions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the neural basis of personality is a major goal in psychology and neuroscience. While previous research has linked personality traits to static (time-averaged) brain structure and function, the dynamic, moment-to-moment fluctuations in brain connectivity – the "time-resolved connectome" – and their relationship to personality have remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating whether individual differences in personality, specifically the Big Five traits, are associated with variations in the dynamic patterns of functional connectivity between large-scale brain networks.

Methods

The researchers employed a Dynamic Conditional Correlation (DCC) model to estimate time-varying functional connectivity between 15 large-scale brain networks. This model, based on a generalized autoregressive conditional heteroscedastic (GARCH) approach, is designed to be robust to noise and capture temporal fluctuations in connectivity. To quantify the dynamism of these connections, they used a "T-index," which measures the extent and duration of deviations from the average connectivity strength. To ensure the reliability and generalizability of their findings, they split their dataset into training and testing sets, using the training set to identify associations and the testing set to validate them. Statistical analyses involved multivariate regression models, controlling for potential confounding factors like age, sex, education, and handedness.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Human Connectome Project (HCP) Young Adult dataset, comprising resting-state fMRI data from n=818 healthy participants. This dataset is a well-established resource for neuroimaging research and includes extensive behavioral and demographic information. The data was split into a training set (n=613) and a testing set (n=205) for model validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic connectivity matters for personality: This study moves beyond static brain measures to show that the way brain networks communicate over time is linked to individual differences in personality.
  • Conscientiousness as a "stability" trait: The findings strongly suggest that conscientiousness is associated with stable (less dynamic) brain network interactions, particularly in networks involved in cognitive control and attention. This provides a potential neural basis for the behavioral characteristic of maintaining focus on long-term goals.
  • Specificity of the finding: Notably, conscientiousness was the only personality trait that showed a significant association with time-resolved connectivity. This highlights the unique role of conscientiousness in shaping brain dynamics.
  • Mechanistic explanation for goal pursuit: The stable connectivity in conscientious individuals might allow them to "shield" their goal-directed processes from interfering stimuli, both internal and external.

Key Results

  • Conscientiousness and stationary connectivity: A significant negative association was found between conscientiousness scores and the "T-index" (dynamicity) across several large-scale brain networks. This means higher conscientiousness was linked to lower dynamicity, or higher stationarity, in these connections.
  • Networks involved: These associations were observed in networks crucial for cognitive control (e.g., prefronto-parietal, default mode, cingulate) and sensory processing (e.g., visual, sensory-motor).
  • Generalizability: The findings were robust and showed good generalizability across the training and testing datasets, with a median relative root mean square error (RRMSE) of 0.14.
  • Other personality traits: No significant associations were found between neuroticism, extraversion, openness, or agreeableness and network dynamicity.
  • Baseline network dynamics: Independently of personality, networks involved in processing external sensory input (e.g., occipito-parietal, occipito-frontal) showed higher dynamicity, while cognitive control networks exhibited more stationary patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specificity of conscientiousness: The authors acknowledge that the lack of findings for other personality traits doesn't definitively mean they have no brain correlates. It could be due to type II errors, non-linear relationships, or the need for more specific personality measures (e.g., facets) or task-based functional measures.
  • Anatomical granularity: The study used large-scale networks. Future work could explore whether more fine-grained interactions within networks are also related to personality.
  • Eye movements: While they conducted a supplementary analysis to assess the impact of eye movements, they acknowledge that this was done on a subset and on different days, so a complete exclusion of this confound cannot be guaranteed.
  • Future directions: The authors suggest that their findings provide a foundation for developing more realistic models of brain dynamics that mediate personality differences. Future research could explore how these dynamic connectivity patterns change with interventions or in clinical populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The human brain is characterized by highly dynamic patterns of functional connectivity. However, it is unknown whether this time-variant 'connectome' is related to the individual differences in the behavioural and cognitive traits described in the five-factor model of personality. To answer this question, inter-network time-variant connectivity was computed in n = 818 healthy people via a dynamical conditional correlation model. Next, network dynamicity was quantified throughout an ad-hoc measure (T-index) and the generalizability of the multi-variate associations between personality traits and network dynamicity was assessed using a train/test split approach. Conscientiousness, reflecting enhanced cognitive and emotional control, was the sole trait linked to stationary connectivity across several circuits such as the default mode and prefronto-parietal network. The stationarity in the 'communication' across large-scale networks offers a mechanistic description of the capacity of conscientious people to 'protect' non-immediate goals against interference over-time. This study informs future research aiming at developing more realistic models of the brain dynamics mediating personality differences.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{passamonti2019time,
  author = {Luca Passamonti and Roberta Riccelli and Iole Indovina and Andrea Duggento and Antonio Terracciano and Nicola Toschi},
  title = {{Time-resolved connectome of the five-factor model of personality}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-019-51469-2},
}
Figure