Time-Efficient Allocation Mechanisms for Crowdsensing Tasks with Precedence Constraints

Xiaocan Wu, Yu-e Sun, He Huang, Yang Du, Danlei Huang

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel task allocation mechanism for crowdsensing systems that accounts for task dependencies (precedence constraints) and aims to minimize the overall execution time. The proposed algorithm is demonstrated to be efficient and achieve good approximate optimal ratios, particularly in the context of Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) crowdsensing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Crowdsensing, which leverages distributed mobile devices to collect data, offers a cost-effective way to perform large-scale sensing tasks. However, many real-world crowdsensing scenarios involve tasks with dependencies – meaning some tasks cannot start until others are completed. This is particularly relevant in systems like Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) operations, where tasks like surveillance might precede target identification. Existing research has largely overlooked these precedence constraints, and even fewer have focused on minimizing the total execution time for such dependent tasks. This paper addresses this gap by proposing a method to efficiently allocate tasks with precedence constraints to minimize the overall completion time.

Methods

The core of this paper is an approximation algorithm designed to tackle the NP-hard problem of task allocation with precedence constraints. The algorithm proceeds in four main steps:

  1. Task Level Division: Tasks are categorized into levels based on their precedence relationships. Tasks with no dependencies are assigned to the lowest level (level 1), and subsequent levels are determined by the dependencies.
  2. Final Task Set Construction: A "final task set" is identified, consisting of tasks that are not prerequisites for any other task. The total execution time of the entire task set is ultimately determined by the completion of these final tasks.
  3. Allocation Priority Sequence Construction: This is a crucial step where tasks are ordered based on their expected finishing times. The algorithm iteratively identifies "critical task sequences" (sequences with the maximum expected finishing time) and selects the lowest-level task from these sequences to build an allocation priority list. This process aims to prioritize tasks that are bottlenecks.
  4. Task Allocation: Once the priority sequence is established, tasks are allocated to available users (e.g., mobile devices or UAVs) greedily. In each step, the platform assigns the highest-priority available task to the user who can complete it with the minimum expected execution time, considering factors like travel duration and task performance time.

A case study is presented to illustrate how this mechanism can be applied to a UAV crowdsensing system, where task execution time is influenced by flight duration and the task itself.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a simulation-based evaluation of the proposed algorithm.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Precedence Constraints are Critical: The paper highlights that ignoring task dependencies can lead to suboptimal and inefficient task execution, especially in complex systems like UAV operations.
  • Minimizing Total Execution Time is Challenging: The problem of allocating tasks with precedence constraints to minimize total execution time is NP-hard, necessitating approximation algorithms.
  • Level-Based Prioritization Works: Dividing tasks into levels based on dependencies and then constructing a priority sequence based on critical paths effectively identifies bottlenecks and guides allocation.
  • UAVs as a Practical Use Case: The paper demonstrates the applicability of the proposed mechanism to real-world scenarios like UAV crowdsensing, where factors like flight time are integral to task execution.
  • More Users, Better Performance: Simulation results consistently show that increasing the number of available users leads to a lower approximate optimal ratio, indicating better overall efficiency.

Key Results

The simulation results demonstrate that the proposed algorithm achieves good approximate optimal ratios across various parameter settings. Specifically:

  • The approximate optimal ratio generally decreases as the number of mobile device users increases, suggesting improved efficiency with more resources.
  • Increasing the number of task levels tends to decrease the approximate optimal ratio, indicating that a more granular task structure can lead to better allocation.
  • The algorithm shows robustness across different distributions for task execution times and user task interests.
  • The case study on UAV systems shows how the mechanism can be adapted to account for specific constraints like flight duration.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the proposed algorithm is an approximation mechanism, meaning it aims for near-optimal solutions rather than guaranteed optimality due to the NP-hard nature of the problem.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Incorporating task deadlines and user availability intervals into the allocation mechanism.
  • Developing a mobile crowdsensing system for traffic congestion monitoring.
  • Conducting real-world experimentation to validate the proposed task allocation mechanism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Crowdsensing has emerged as an efficient and inexpensive way to perform specialized tasks by leveraging external crowds. In some crowdsensing systems, different tasks may have different requirements, and there may be precedence constraints among them, such as the Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) crowdsensing systems. Moreover, minimizing the total execution time is a regular target for finishing the crowdsensing tasks with precedence constraints. As far as we know, only a few existing studies consider the precedence constraints among crowdsensing tasks, and none of them can minimize the total execution time simultaneously. To tackle this challenge, an efficient allocation mechanism for tasks with precedence constraints is first proposed, which can minimize the total execution time. Then, a case study is given to show how to fit our mechanism in the UAV crowdsensing system. Finally, the simulation results show that the proposed mechanisms have good approximate optimal ratios under different parameter settings and are efficient for the UAV crowdsensing system as well.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2019time,
  author = {Xiaocan Wu and Yu-e Sun and He Huang and Yang Du and Danlei Huang},
  title = {{Time-Efficient Allocation Mechanisms for Crowdsensing Tasks with Precedence Constraints}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=FSlayKD80t},
}
Figure