Abstract
Interpersonal networks facilitate business cooperation and socioeconomic exchange. But how can outsiders demonstrate their trustworthiness to join existing networks? Focusing on the puzzling yet common phenomenon of heavy drinking at China’s business banquets, we argue that this costly practice can be a rational strategy intentionally used by entrants to signal trustworthiness to potential business partners. Because drinking alcohol can lower one’s inhibitions and reveal one’s true self, entrants intentionally drink heavily to show that they have nothing to hide and signal their sincere commitment to cooperation. This signaling effect is enhanced if the entrants have low alcohol tolerance, as their physical reactions to alcohol (e.g., red face) make their drunkenness easier to verify. Our theory of heavy social drinking is substantiated by both ethnographic fieldwork and a discrete-choice experiment on Chinese entrepreneurs. This research illuminates how trust can be built absent sufficient support from formal institutions.
Introduction: The Heavy Drinking Paradox
In transitional economies like contemporary China, formal institutions—such as courts and contract law—are often weak or politically influenced. In this environment, economic cooperation relies heavily on guanxi (interpersonal networks). For outsiders, the barrier to entry is high: how can a new player prove they are a reliable partner rather than a "cheater" seeking a quick profit?
This paper addresses the "heavy drinking paradox." Why do Chinese businesspeople engage in the physically taxing and often "tormenting" practice of heavy drinking at banquets? While previous scholarship viewed moderate drinking as a bonding exercise, we propose that heavy drinking serves as a strategic, costly signal used to overcome information asymmetry and establish trust.
Theoretical Framework: Costly Signaling and In Vino Veritas
The core of our argument rests on two pillars: Costly Signaling Theory and the physiological effects of alcohol.
Alcohol as a Catalyst for Truth
The ancient adage In vino veritas (in wine, there is truth) has a biological basis. Alcohol suppresses the prefrontal cortex, the brain region responsible for cognitive control and deception. By drinking to the point of intoxication, an individual effectively lowers their "mask," making it difficult to hide ulterior motives. Thus, an entrant who drinks heavily signals they have nothing to hide.
The Verification Mechanism: The "Red Face"
A signal is only effective if it is credible and verifiable. We argue that the "alcohol flush reaction" (turning red) acts as a biological "proof-of-work." When a drinker turns red or vomits, it provides involuntary physical evidence that they have reached their physiological limit. This makes their state of intoxication—and the subsequent revelation of their "true self"—easier for a potential partner to verify.
The Cost of Entry
For a signal to be honest, it must be more expensive for "cheaters" than for "honest" players. The health risks (liver damage), the immediate physical discomfort (hangovers), and the social risk of revealing secrets constitute a high-stakes commitment device that a short-term opportunist would be less willing to pay.
Methodology
We employed a mixed-methods approach to test our theory:
- Ethnographic Fieldwork (2021–2024): We observed 20 business banquets and interviewed 14 frequent participants across Guangdong, Jiangxi, and Hebei provinces. This provided qualitative insights into norms like datongguan (drinking a glass with every attendee).
- Discrete-Choice Experiment (DCE): We conducted a conjoint analysis with 272 Chinese entrepreneurs and sales professionals. Participants chose between hypothetical business partners based on drinking effort (heavy vs. token), alcohol tolerance (high vs. low/red face), and liquor brand (luxury vs. ordinary).
Key Results: The Drinking Premium
Our quantitative analysis revealed several significant findings regarding the selection of business partners:
- Behavioral Dominance: Entrants who engaged in heavy drinking were 10.9% more likely to be selected as partners than those who only made a token gesture.
- The "Red Face" Boost: The signaling effect was significantly stronger for those with low alcohol tolerance. In heavy-drinking scenarios, individuals who displayed a "red face" were 8.2% more likely to be trusted than those showing no physical reaction.
- Substance vs. Style: While serving luxury liquor (e.g., Maotai) provided a 6.6% advantage, the behavioral signal of heavy drinking remained a more powerful predictor of cooperation than the brand of alcohol.
Conclusion
Heavy drinking at Chinese business banquets is more than a cultural quirk; it is an informal institution that fills the gap left by inadequate formal legal protections. By intentionally incurring physical and social costs, entrants provide a verifiable signal of their sincere commitment to cooperation. While this practice facilitates business in the short term, it imposes significant social costs on public health and may deter investment from those unable or unwilling to participate in such high-stakes rituals.
Summary updated