Tight Bounds on the Round Complexity of the Distributed Maximum Coverage Problem

Sepehr Assadi, Sanjeev Khanna

TL;DR

This paper tackles the fundamental trade-off between approximation quality, communication cost, and computation rounds for the distributed maximum coverage problem. The authors establish tight bounds, showing that achieving good approximation and low communication inherently requires a logarithmic number of rounds. They also introduce a general framework for proving communication lower bounds in distributed settings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In distributed computing, especially with massive datasets, we often partition data across multiple machines and have them collaborate to compute a function. The "coordinator model" is a common paradigm where machines send messages to a central coordinator, who then guides them in subsequent rounds. For problems like maximum coverage (finding $k$ sets that cover the most elements), efficiency is measured by approximation ratio (how close the solution is to optimal), communication cost (how much data is sent), and round complexity (how many communication rounds are needed).

Existing work had a dilemma: either achieve constant-factor approximation with low communication but many rounds (linear in the number of machines), or achieve constant approximation in few rounds but with very high communication. This paper asks: can we have it all – good approximation, low communication, and few rounds? They investigate the fundamental limits of this trade-off.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in establishing tight lower bounds on the communication complexity for distributed algorithms. They introduce a novel general framework for proving communication lower bounds for bounded-round protocols in the distributed coordinator model. This framework relies on constructing a "hard" input distribution that is recursively defined. The key idea is to create instances where distinguishing between "good" and "bad" solutions requires significant communication, especially in early rounds. This framework abstracts away problem-specific details, allowing researchers to focus on designing combinatorial "gadgets" to prove lower bounds for various problems.

For the specific problem of maximum coverage, they design a "randomly nearly disjoint" (RND) set-system as a crucial building block for their packing function within the framework. This system has the property that random subsets of one set are essentially disjoint from other sets, which is key to creating hard instances.

On the upper bound side, they present two main algorithms:

  1. An algorithm based on a thresholding greedy approach, adapted for the distributed setting using a "sample-and-prune" technique. This achieves a good approximation with sublinear communication.
  2. A more specialized algorithm for maximum coverage that uses an iterative sketching method. This algorithm is designed to be more efficient in terms of communication for this specific problem.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical bounds and algorithmic constructions rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fundamental Trade-off: The paper definitively shows that for the distributed maximum coverage problem, there's an inherent trade-off: achieving a constant approximation with low communication requires a logarithmic number of rounds. You can't have all three simultaneously at their best.
  • General Lower Bound Framework: The introduction of a general framework for proving communication lower bounds in bounded-round distributed protocols is a significant methodological contribution. This framework aims to unify and simplify the process of establishing such bounds across different problems.
  • RND Set-Systems: The construction of "randomly nearly disjoint" set-systems is a novel combinatorial tool used to build the hard instances for the lower bound proofs.
  • Tightness of Bounds: The paper not only provides lower bounds but also constructive algorithms that match these bounds, demonstrating that the established trade-offs are essentially tight.

Key Results

  • Lower Bound (Result 1): For any $r$-round protocol, either the communication cost is at least $k \cdot m^{O(1/r)}$ or the approximation factor is at least $k \cdot n^{O(1/r)}$. This implies that achieving constant approximation and $O(n)$ communication requires $\Omega(\log k)$ rounds.
  • Upper Bounds (Result 2):
    • An $r$-round protocol achieving an approximation factor of $O(k^{1/r})$ with $k \cdot m^{O(1/r)}$ communication per machine.
  • An $r$-round protocol achieving a $k^{o(1/r)}$-approximation with $O(n)$ communication per machine.
  • Applications: The results are extended to dynamic streaming and MapReduce models, providing new bounds for these settings. For instance, they establish the first upper and lower bounds for maximum coverage in dynamic streams.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Adversarial vs. Random Partitions: The paper focuses on adversarial input partitions. The authors note that with random partitions, better results (constant approximation in one round with $O(n)$ communication) are achievable, highlighting a significant gap between these two scenarios.
  • Open Questions: The paper leaves open questions regarding achieving constant-pass semi-streaming algorithms for maximum coverage and matching lower bounds in dynamic streaming.
  • Generalization: While the framework is general, applying it to specific problems still requires designing appropriate combinatorial "gadgets," which can be challenging. The paper suggests their framework can unify proofs for various problems, but the combinatorial part remains problem-specific.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{assadi2018tight,
  author = {Sepehr Assadi and Sanjeev Khanna},
  title = {{Tight Bounds on the Round Complexity of the Distributed Maximum Coverage Problem}},
  booktitle = {SODA},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1137/1.9781611975031.155},
}

Loading related content...

Figure