Three-month functional training programme improves knee joint function in athletes post-ACL reconstruction surgery

Chuanjia Du, Jiao Jiao, Jihe Zhou, Bik Chu Chow, Qiuqiong Shi, Xiao-Pei Zhang, Siyu Liu, Shuicheng YanJournal of Rehabilitation Medicine 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Objective: This study aimed to explore the impact of a 3-month functional training programme aligned with Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) protocols on recuperation following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Design: A quasi-experimental study. Methods: Thirty-four athletes (aged 14–24) post-ACLR were allocated to an experimental group (EG, n=15) or a control group (CG, n=19). The EG underwent a 3-phase functional training regimen, while the CG followed conventional recovery. Evaluations were conducted prior to and following the 3-month interval using the Y-Balance Test (YBT), Functional Movement Screening (FMS), and Isokinetic Knee Test (IKT). Results: Assessment outcomes exhibited significant enhancement (p < 0.05) within the experimental group compared to the control group across all metrics. Conclusion: A structured 3-month functional training protocol effectively facilitates recovery and restores knee joint function post-ACLR.

Introduction

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries are a major hurdle in sports medicine, affecting over 200,000 athletes annually. While surgery can restore the physical structure of the knee, the recovery process is often plagued by "neuromuscular amnesia"—changes in the brain's control over the muscle—as well as atrophy and persistent weakness. The first three months post-surgery are a critical window for rehabilitation. However, a gap often exists between standard clinical physical therapy and the high-level functional demands of returning to sport. This study evaluates a specific 3-month functional training regimen, aligned with modern ERAS principles, designed to bridge this gap.

Methodology

The study involved 34 young athletes recruited from the Sichuan Province Orthopaedic Hospital. The experimental group followed a meticulously designed 3-phase protocol over 12 weeks:

  1. Stage 1 (Weeks 1–4): Focused on foundational movement, range of motion (ROM), and proprioceptive activation.
  2. Stage 2 (Weeks 5–8): Introduced weight-bearing resistance and intensified proprioceptive challenges to build fundamental strength.
  3. Stage 3 (Weeks 9–12): Emphasized dynamic neuromuscular strength, endurance, and complex balance tasks.
Study protocol flowchart showing the timeline from pre-operation to post-test assessments, including visual examples of the YBT, FMS, and IKT tests.

Primary assessment tools included the Y-Balance Test (YBT) for dynamic stability, Functional Movement Screening (FMS) for movement quality, and the Isokinetic Knee Test (IKT) for objective muscle strength and balance.

Results and Discussion

The experimental group demonstrated statistically significant improvements across all metrics compared to the control group.

Movement Quality and Injury Risk

Athletes with FMS scores below 14 are statistically more prone to non-contact ACL injuries. The experimental group's scores improved from an average of 11.53 to 16.07, effectively moving them out of the high-risk category. Significant gains were noted in deep squats, hurdle steps, and in-line lunges, indicating superior motor control.

Muscle Strength and Symmetry

A critical metric in ACL recovery is the Hamstring-to-Quadriceps (H/Q) strength ratio. An optimal ratio (around 60%) is vital for knee stability. The functional training group saw their H/Q ratio on the injured side jump from approximately 36% to over 67%, significantly outperforming the control group (~56%).

Dynamic Stability

The EG showed a 5.25% greater increase in injured leg YBT scores and a 6.38% higher increase for the non-injured leg compared to the CG, suggesting better neuromuscular re-programming through closed kinetic chain exercises.

Detailed comparison of pre- and post-test outcomes between the experimental and control groups across YBT, IKT, and FMS metrics.

Conclusion

The integration of ERAS principles with structured functional training creates a compounding effect on recovery speed and quality. By utilizing targeted exercises early on, the protocol likely activated a broader array of joint receptors, "re-teaching" the brain how to stabilize the knee under load. While limited by a small sample size and a lack of long-term follow-up, these findings underscore the efficacy of a 3-month functional training protocol in facilitating robust recuperation subsequent to ACL reconstruction surgery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective: Rehabilitation and recovery duration following anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery play a pivotal role in restoring optimal knee functionality in athletes. This study aimed to explore the impact of a 3-month functional training programme aligned with enhanced recovery after surgery on recuperation subsequent to anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery. Design: A quasi-experimental study. Subjects: A cohort of 34 patients aged 14 to 24, who underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery and adhered to enhanced recovery after surgery protocols during the perioperative period, were allocated to an experimental group and a control group according to their eligibility, capacity, and willingness to engage in the functional training programme. Methods: The participants in the experimental group underwent a 3-month regimen of functional training following anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery, whereas the control group followed a conventional recovery approach. Evaluations were conducted both prior to and following the 3-month recovery interval, utilizing the Y-Balance Test, Functional Movement Screening, and Isokinetic Knee Test. Results: Assessment outcomes of the Y-Balance Test, Isokinetic Knee Test, and Functional Movement Screening exhibited significant enhancement (p &lt; 0.05) within the experimental group, as opposed to the control group. These findings underscore that those athletes who undertook the 3-month functional training regimen within the experimental group exhibited heightened dynamic balance capabilities, increased knee joint mobility, and enhanced stability compared with their counterparts in the control group. Conclusion: Consequently, this underscores the efficacy of the 3-month functional training protocol aligned with enhanced recovery after surgery, as a means to effectively facilitate recuperation subsequent to anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery.
BibTeX
@article{du2024three,
  author = {Chuanjia Du and Jiao Jiao and Jihe Zhou and Bik Chu Chow and Qiuqiong Shi and Xiao-Pei Zhang and Siyu Liu and Shuicheng Yan},
  title = {{Three-month functional training programme improves knee joint function in athletes post-ACL reconstruction surgery}},
  journal = {Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2340/jrm.v56.18701},
}
Figure