Three High-Rate Beamforming Methods for Active IRS-Aided Wireless Network

Feng Shu, Jing Liu, Yeqing Lin, Yang Liu, Zhilin Chen, Xuehui Wang, Rongen Dong, Jiangzhou WangIEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces three novel beamforming methods (MRR, SRR, and Max-ASNR) for active Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (IRS) in wireless networks. These methods significantly boost data rates by effectively utilizing the amplifying capabilities of active IRS, outperforming existing techniques and offering a good balance between performance and computational complexity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of improving data rates in wireless networks, particularly in the context of emerging active Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (IRS). While passive IRS can mitigate the "double-fading" effect, active IRS offers an amplifying gain that can further enhance performance. However, existing methods like Equal-Gain Reflecting (EGR) don't fully exploit this amplifying potential, especially in scenarios with channels experiencing deep fading. The core problem is how to optimally design the IRS beamforming (amplitude and phase) to maximize the achievable data rate, considering the unique properties of active IRS and the practical constraints of wireless communication.

Methods

The authors propose three new beamforming methods for active IRS:

  • Maximum Ratio Reflecting (MRR): Inspired by Maximum Ratio Combining (MRC), MRR optimizes both the amplitude and phase of the IRS reflection coefficients to align with the direct path signal, aiming to maximize the received signal power. It provides a closed-form solution.
  • Selective Ratio Reflecting (SRR): Motivated by Selective Ratio Combining (SRC), SRR activates only a subset of IRS elements with the strongest channel gains. This reduces the communication overhead between the base station (BS) and the IRS, as not all channel information needs to be transmitted. It also offers a closed-form solution.
  • Maximum Approximate-Signal-to-Noise Ratio (Max-ASNR): This method aims to directly maximize an approximate signal-to-noise ratio (ASNR) at the user. It employs an iterative approach that alternates between adjusting the norm and the normalized vector of the IRS beamforming vector. This iterative process allows for a more refined optimization compared to the closed-form methods.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on simulations with specified parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Active IRS Amplification is Key: The paper strongly emphasizes that active IRS's amplifying capability is crucial for significant rate improvements, especially when compared to passive IRS or simpler reflection schemes.
  • Exploiting Channel Diversity: SRR's approach of selectively activating IRS elements with the best channels is a smart way to reduce overhead and focus resources where they matter most, particularly relevant in large-scale IRS deployments.
  • Iterative Optimization for Peak Performance: Max-ASNR demonstrates that an iterative approach, while more complex than closed-form solutions, can achieve higher rates by more precisely optimizing the beamforming parameters.
  • Trade-off Between Complexity and Performance: The paper clearly illustrates that there's a spectrum of performance and complexity, with closed-form methods (MRR, SRR) offering good gains with low complexity, and iterative methods (Max-ASNR) pushing performance further at a slightly higher computational cost.

Key Results

  • The proposed MRR and SRR methods achieve approximately a 1-bit rate gain over the existing EGR method.
  • Max-ASNR shows a significant improvement, achieving about a 2-bit rate enhancement over EGR and outperforming MRR and SRR.
  • The Max-ASNR method demonstrates rapid convergence, typically requiring only two to three iterations to reach its performance floor.
  • For SRR, selecting half of the IRS elements (K=N/2) provides a rate close to MRR with negligible performance loss, making it a practical choice.
  • In terms of rate performance, the paper ranks the methods as: Max-ASNR > MRR > SRR > EGR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Max-ASNR: While Max-ASNR offers superior performance, its iterative nature makes it more computationally intensive than MRR and SRR, though still significantly less complex than some other advanced iterative methods like AO and SCA.
  • Channel State Information (CSI): The methods assume perfect CSI. Real-world scenarios with imperfect CSI would require robust beamforming designs.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests exploring more advanced iterative optimization techniques for Max-ASNR and investigating robust beamforming strategies for scenarios with imperfect CSI. Further research could also delve into the practical implementation challenges and energy efficiency aspects of these active IRS beamforming methods.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{shu2023three,
  author = {Feng Shu and Jing Liu and Yeqing Lin and Yang Liu and Zhilin Chen and Xuehui Wang and Rongen Dong and Jiangzhou Wang},
  title = {{Three High-Rate Beamforming Methods for Active IRS-Aided Wireless Network}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/tvt.2023.3279840},
}
Figure