Three-dimensional structure and formation mechanism of biskyrmions in uniaxial ferromagnets

Chengjie Wang, Wang, Pengfei, Zhou, Yan, Wenhong Wang, Fazhan Shi, Du, JiangfengarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Magnetic biskyrmions are observed in experiments but their existences are still under debate. In this work, we present the existence of biskyrmions in a magnetic film with tilted uniaxial anisotropy via micromagnetic simulations. We find biskyrmions and bubbles share a unified three-dimensional structure, in which the relative position of two intrinsic Bloch points dominates the two-dimensional topological property in the film middle. The film edge can drive Bloch points and transform bubbles into biskyrmions via the demagnetizing field. This mechanism is found in the formation process of biskyrmions in confined geometry under zero field. Our work clarifies the structure and formation mechanism of biskyrmions, emphasizing the three-dimensional aspect of skyrmion-related nanostructures.

Introduction

Magnetic skyrmions, localized whirlpool-like spin textures, are promising candidates for next-generation high-density data storage due to their small size and topological stability. Among these, "biskyrmions"—textures carrying a double topological charge ($Q=2$)—have garnered significant interest but remain controversial. While Lorentz Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) has identified patterns consistent with biskyrmions, some researchers argue these are merely trivial magnetic bubbles ($Q=0$) that mimic the biskyrmion's appearance in 2D projections. This study addresses the controversy by investigating the full three-dimensional (3D) structure and formation dynamics of these objects in thin-film ferromagnets.

Methodology

The researchers utilized micromagnetic simulations via the Mumax3 software to model a 160 nm thick film of MnNiGa alloy. A critical feature of the model is the inclusion of tilted uniaxial anisotropy, where the magnetic easy axis is inclined at 31° to match experimental crystal orientations. The simulations accounted for exchange stiffness, dipolar interactions, Zeeman energy, and demagnetizing fields. By analyzing the topological charge $Q$ at various depths ($z$-positions) and generating synthetic Lorentz TEM images, the team could directly compare their 3D models with experimental observations.

A Unified 3D Perspective

The study reveals that biskyrmions and type-II bubbles are not entirely different species but rather variations of a single unified 3D structure. Both textures feature "Néel-caps" at the film surfaces, where magnetization points radially. The defining difference lies in the vertical arrangement of two Bloch points—singularities where local magnetization vanishes.

3D schematic (a) and visualization (b) of the spin texture, highlighting the internal Bloch points (BP) that define the topological state.

When these Bloch points are positioned "across" each other along the film's thickness, the central region of the film exhibits a $Q=2$ biskyrmion state. If their relative positions shift, the texture can revert to a topologically trivial bubble. This insight suggests that the "true" topological nature of these nanostructures is often hidden within the bulk of the material, while surface layers may present a misleading appearance.

Formation Mechanism and Experimental Validation

The transition from a trivial bubble to a biskyrmion is driven by the demagnetizing field at the sample edges. As the external magnetic field is lowered, the edge-induced field "pumps" the Bloch points, forcing them past one another and switching the internal topology.

Magnetization maps (a, b), topological charge density (c, d), and simulated Lorentz TEM images (e-h) demonstrating the $Q=2$ state and its characteristic contrast.

The simulated Lorentz TEM images perfectly replicate the "black and white semicircle" contrast observed in experiments, providing strong evidence that the simulated 3D biskyrmions are accurate representations of real-world phenomena. Furthermore, the study explains the large Topological Hall Effect (THE) associated with these structures: even if the film's center is trivial, the overall 3D structure maintains non-zero topological character near the surfaces.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work clarifies the long-standing debate over biskyrmions by demonstrating their stability in films with tilted anisotropy and uncovering their 3D formation mechanism. The primary challenge remains the experimental 3D reconstruction of these textures, as standard TEM provides only a 2D average. Future research should leverage THE measurements as a sensitive probe for internal 3D structures and explore confined geometries to precisely control biskyrmion formation for potential multi-level data storage applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Magnetic biskyrmions are observed in experiments but their existences are still under debate. In this work, we present the existence of biskyrmions in a magnetic film with tilted uniaxial anisotropy via micromagnetic simulations. We find biskyrmions and bubbles share a unified three-dimensional structure, in which the relative position of two intrinsic Bloch points dominates the two-dimensional topological property in the film middle. The film edge can drive Bloch points and transform bubbles into biskyrmions via the demagnetizing field. This mechanism is found in the formation process of biskyrmions in confined geometry under zero field. Our work clarifies the structure and formation mechanism of biskyrmions, emphasizing the three-dimensional aspect of skyrmion-related nanostructures.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2022three,
  author = {Chengjie Wang and Wang, Pengfei and Zhou, Yan and Wenhong Wang and Fazhan Shi and Du, Jiangfeng},
  title = {{Three-dimensional structure and formation mechanism of biskyrmions in uniaxial ferromagnets}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2201.06772},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.06772},
}
Figure