Distinguishing two-component anomalous Hall effect from topological Hall effect

Lixuan Tai, Bingqian Dai, Jie Li, Han-Shen Huang, Su Kong Chong, Kin Wong, H. R. Zhang, Peng Zhang, Peng Deng, Chris Eckberg, Gang Qiu, Haoran He, Di Wu, Shijie Xu, Albert V. Davydov, Ruqian Wu, Kang L. WangarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In transport measurements, the topological Hall effect (THE) is often identified by non-monotonic features like humps and dips in the Hall signal, typically interpreted as a signature of chiral spin textures such as magnetic skyrmions. However, the co-existence of multiple anomalous Hall effect (AHE) components can produce similar artifacts. This study uses transport and magneto-optical Kerr effect (MOKE) microscopy to confirm genuine THE in $Ta/CoFeB/Ir/MgO/Al_2O_3$ thin films and identify artifacts in $MnBi_2Te_4$ systems. We propose three diagnostic methods—minor loops, temperature dependence, and gate dependence—to reliably distinguish genuine THE from multi-component AHE artifacts.

Introduction: The Skyrmion Search and the Hall Effect Pitfall

In the quest for next-generation spintronics, magnetic skyrmions—stable, swirling topological spin textures—are highly sought after due to their potential for low-power data storage. Traditionally, researchers identify these textures in transport experiments by observing "humps" or "dips" in Hall resistance ($R_{yx}$), a phenomenon known as the Topological Hall Effect (THE).

However, a significant challenge persists: if a material has two different magnetic components (e.g., a main phase and a secondary impurity phase), their combined Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE) signals can overlap to create identical-looking features. This "artifact THE" has led to numerous potentially false reports of skyrmions. This paper addresses the urgent need for a reliable way to differentiate these phenomena using standard laboratory transport measurements.

Establishing a Ground Truth: MOKE and Transport

To solve this ambiguity, the researchers compared a "genuine THE" system ($Ta/CoFeB/Ir/MgO/Al_2O_3$) with an "artifact THE" system ($MnBi_2Te_4$ with $MnTe_2$ impurities). In the genuine system, they used Magneto-Optical Kerr Effect (MOKE) microscopy to directly visualize the magnetic textures while simultaneously measuring transport.

Figure 1: Experimental setup and correlation between transport and MOKE signals. (a) Device schematic. (b) Hall resistance $R_{yx}$ showing characteristic 'hump' and 'dip' features. (c) MOKE signal $\theta_K$ tracking the overall magnetization loop.

As shown in the transport data, the "hump" and "dip" features appear during the magnetization reversal. By correlating these with MOKE imaging, the authors confirmed that these features correspond exactly to the emergence of chiral spin textures.

Figure 2: MOKE microscopy images (I-V) corresponding to different stages of the magnetization reversal. Region II shows the nucleation of skyrmions, and Region IV shows a dense skyrmion lattice, providing direct visual evidence for the origin of the THE signal.

A Diagnostic Toolkit for Researchers

The study establishes three robust methods to differentiate genuine topological signals from multi-component artifacts:

  • Location and Saturation: Genuine THE occurs strictly within the AHE transition region (where magnetization is flipping). Artifact THE often persists well into the saturation region, where magnetic moments should be perfectly aligned and unable to form skyrmions.
  • Minor Loop Analysis: In genuine THE, minor loops (partial field sweeps) always reside within the full loop. For artifacts, a minor loop may reveal a single, independent AHE loop that cannot be mathematically decomposed into the assumed "AHE + THE" model.
  • Temperature and Gate Dependence: Tuning temperature or gate voltage in artifact systems often causes the background AHE to change polarity as the humps vanish. Genuine THE does not exhibit this coupling between the background AHE polarity and the topological signal.

Conclusion

By combining direct imaging with transport analysis, this work clarifies the origin of non-monotonic Hall features. The proposed diagnostic methods provide a necessary "stress test" for any new material claiming to host skyrmions based on transport data alone. This ensures that the search for topological magnetic textures remains grounded in verifiable physical phenomena rather than experimental artifacts.

Reference: Tai, L., et al. "Distinguishing two-component anomalous Hall effect from topological Hall effect."

Summary updated

Abstract

In transport, the topological Hall effect (THE) presents itself as non-monotonic features (or humps and dips) in the Hall signal and is widely interpreted as a sign of chiral spin textures, like magnetic skyrmions. However, when anomalous Hall effect (AHE) is also present, the co-existence of two AHEs could give rise to similar artifacts, making it difficult to distinguish between genuine THE with AHE and two-component AHE. Here we confirm genuine THE with AHE by means of transport and magneto-optical Kerr effect (MOKE) microscopy, in which magnetic skyrmions are directly observed, and find that genuine THE occurs in the transition region of the AHE. In sharp contrast, the artifact "THE", or two-component AHE occurs well beyond the saturation of the "AHE component" (under the false assumption of THE+AHE). Furthermore, we distinguish artifact "THE" from genuine THE by three methods: 1. Minor loops, 2. Temperature dependence, 3. Gate dependence. Minor loops of genuine THE with AHE are always within the full loop, while minor loops of the artifact "THE" may reveal a single loop that cannot fit into the "AHE component". Besides, the temperature or gate dependence of the artifact "THE" may also be accompanied by a polarity change of the "AHE component", as the non-monotonic features vanish, while the temperature dependence of genuine THE with AHE reveals no such change. Our work may help future researchers to exercise cautions and use these methods to examine carefully in order to ascertain genuine THE.
BibTeX
@misc{tai2021distinguishing,
  author = {Lixuan Tai and Bingqian Dai and Jie Li and Han-Shen Huang and Su Kong Chong and Kin Wong and H. R. Zhang and Peng Zhang and Peng Deng and Chris Eckberg and Gang Qiu and Haoran He and Di Wu and Shijie Xu and Albert V. Davydov and Ruqian Wu and Kang L. Wang},
  title = {{Distinguishing two-component anomalous Hall effect from topological Hall effect}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2103.09878},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.09878},
}
Figure