Abstract
Understanding (de)lithiation heterogeneities in battery materials is key to ensuring optimal electrochemical performance and developing better energy storage devices. However, this remains challenging due to the complex three dimensional morphology of microscopic electrode particles, the involvement of both solid and liquid phase reactants, and range of relevant timescales (seconds to hours). Here, we overcome this problem and demonstrate the use of bench-top laser scanning confocal microscopy for simultaneous three-dimensional operando measurement of lithium ion dynamics in single particles, and the electrolyte, in batteries. We examine two technologically important cathode materials that are known to suffer from intercalation heterogeneities: Li$_x$CoO$_2$ and Li$_x$Ni$_{0.8}$Mn$_{0.1}$Co$_{0.1}$O$_2$. The single-particle surface-to-core transport velocity of Li-phase fronts, and volume changes - as well as their inter-particle heterogeneity - are captured as a function of C-rate, and benchmarked to previous ensemble measurements. Additionally, we visualise heterogeneities in the bulk and at the surface of particles during cycling, and image the formation of spatially non-uniform concentration gradients within the liquid electrolyte. Importantly, the conditions under which optical imaging can be performed inside absorbing and multiply scattering materials such as battery intercalation compounds are outlined.
Introduction
Lithium-ion batteries do not operate uniformly at the microscopic level. Some electrode particles experience higher local currents than others, and lithium often concentrates at the surface of a particle while the core remains untouched. These heterogeneities—non-uniformities in (de)lithiation—are primary drivers of capacity fade and mechanical failure. Probing these dynamics in 3D has historically been a major challenge; standard optical microscopy is typically limited to 2D surfaces, while high-end techniques like X-ray tomography often require synchrotron facilities and struggle to visualize the liquid electrolyte phase.
Experimental Methodology
This study utilizes Laser Scanning Confocal Microscopy (LSCRM) to perform 3D, real-time (operando) imaging. By using a pinhole to optically "section" the sample, 3D reconstructions are created by stacking 2D images.
The technique relies on two primary optical signals:
- Reflectivity as a Proxy: An 820 nm laser measures the reflectivity of cathode particles (LCO and NMC811). Since the refractive index changes with lithium content, reflectivity serves as a proxy for the state-of-charge (SoC).
- Two-Photon Excited Fluorescence (2PEF): A 1020 nm laser triggers 2PEF in the LiPF$_6$ salt, allowing for the mapping of salt concentration gradients in the electrolyte surrounding the particles.
Results and Discussion
A critical insight from this work is the resolution of the "focus trap." Reflectivity signals can appear to increase or decrease during delithiation depending on whether the focus is on the particle surface or interior, explaining conflicting results in previous literature and underscoring the necessity of 3D sectioning.
Key findings include:
- Kinetic Asymmetry: In LCO, delithiation (charging) is diffusion-limited, moving from surface to core, whereas lithiation (discharging) occurs almost uniformly, suggesting interface-limited kinetics.
- Volume Tracking: The system accurately tracked single-particle volume changes, observing a ~3% expansion in LCO and a ~12% contraction in NMC811 during charging.
- Electrolyte Dynamics: For the first time using optical methods, researchers imaged a ~1.5 μm thick concentration gradient in the electrolyte. At high C-rates (2C), electrolyte diffusion mismatches with the surface reaction, leading to persistent lithium "hot spots" and "cold spots" that contribute to battery aging.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While LSCRM provides unprecedented 3D access to battery interiors at the lab scale, it is currently limited to an imaging depth of ~15 μm due to scattering and absorption. Future research will explore mid-infrared photo-thermal techniques and wavefront shaping to peer deeper into the electrode bulk, alongside chemically specific probes like Raman scattering to further distinguish electrolyte species.
Summary updated