Three-dimensional Cardiomyocytes Structure Revealed By Diffusion Tensor Imaging and Its Validation Using a Tissue-Clearing Technique

Sang‐Eun Lee, Christopher Nguyen, Jongjin Yoon, Hyuk‐Jae Chang, Sekeun Kim, Chul Hoon Kim, Debiao LiScientific 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper validates Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) for mapping the complex 3D structure of cardiomyocytes in the heart. By comparing DTI with a novel 3D tissue-clearing histology technique, they demonstrate DTI's accuracy in characterizing cardiac microstructure, even in diseased hearts, paving the way for non-invasive clinical assessment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the intricate, three-dimensional (3D) arrangement of cardiomyocytes within the heart is crucial for comprehending its mechanical and electrical function, especially in the context of cardiovascular diseases. Traditionally, this detailed microstructural information has been difficult to obtain non-invasively. Existing methods often rely on invasive biopsies or destructive histological sectioning, which can alter or damage the tissue, limiting their accuracy and clinical applicability. While Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) shows promise for visualizing this microstructure, its accuracy in mapping cardiomyocyte orientation has not been rigorously validated against a comprehensive 3D histological standard of intact tissue.

Methods

The core of this study lies in the validation of DTI against a novel 3D histological approach.

  • Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI): Fixed ex-vivo mouse hearts underwent DTI to acquire diffusion-weighted images. From these, the diffusion tensor was calculated for each voxel, and the primary eigenvector was used to infer cardiomyocyte orientation. This allowed for the reconstruction of 3D fiber tracts and the calculation of helix angles (HA) and global helix angle transmurality (HAT).
  • 3D Tissue-Clearing Histology: A key innovation is the use of a tissue-clearing technique (CLARITY) to render intact mouse hearts optically transparent. This allowed for light-sheet fluorescence microscopy to visualize the 3D cardiomyocyte structure without sectioning. Conventional structure tensor analysis was then applied to these cleared images to quantify cardiomyocyte orientation, providing a 3D histological gold standard.
  • Validation Strategy: The study employed a "mirror section" method for initial validation. One half of a heart was processed with standard H&E staining (2D histology), while the other half underwent tissue clearing. This allowed for a direct comparison of in-plane cardiomyocyte angles. For the main validation, DTI-derived HA and HAT were directly compared with those obtained from the 3D tissue-cleared hearts.

Datasets

The study utilized ex-vivo mouse hearts:

  • Control Group: 7 normal mouse hearts.
  • Ischemic Group: 8 mouse hearts from a model of heart failure induced by left anterior descending artery ligation.

These datasets were used for both DTI acquisition and subsequent 3D tissue clearing and histological analysis. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study focused on validating existing DTI techniques against a novel histological standard.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tissue Clearing as a 3D Histological Gold Standard: The CLARITY technique successfully rendered intact hearts optically transparent, allowing for the visualization and analysis of 3D cardiomyocyte architecture without destructive sectioning. This provides a more accurate representation of the native tissue structure compared to traditional 2D histology.
  • DTI's Accuracy in Capturing Cardiac Microstructure: The study strongly validates DTI's ability to accurately map cardiomyocyte orientation and transmural fiber architecture. The high correlation between DTI and 3D histology demonstrates that DTI can reliably capture the complex helical arrangement of cardiac muscle.
  • Disease-Induced Structural Changes: The research highlights significant alterations in cardiomyocyte architecture in ischemic heart failure. Specifically, global HAT was substantially reduced in the ischemic group, indicating a loss of helical winding, which is a critical finding for understanding disease progression.
  • Global Impact of Ischemia: Interestingly, even remote areas of the myocardium in ischemic hearts showed reduced HA compared to controls, suggesting that ischemia can induce global changes in cardiomyocyte architecture, not just localized to the infarct zone. This has implications for understanding the functional consequences of myocardial infarction.

Key Results

  • High Correlation: Significant correlations were observed between DTI and 3D tissue-clearing histology for cardiomyocyte orientation, with R² values of 0.803 for per-sample analysis and 0.872 for per-segment analysis.
  • Agreement in Global HAT: A strong agreement was found between DTI and optical imaging for global HAT, with R² = 0.80 and a Bland-Altman limits of agreement of -0.33 to 0.24°/%TD.
  • Reduced HAT in Ischemia: Global HAT was significantly reduced in ischemic hearts compared to controls, by approximately 40% in both DTI (0.79 vs. 1.31 °/%TD) and optical imaging (0.84 vs. 1.36 °/%TD) (p < 0.001).
  • Regional Agreement: Segmental analysis also showed excellent correlation between DTI and optical imaging for HA, with R² values around 0.72 for both controls and ischemic groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Agreement between 2D and 3D Histology: While good, the agreement between conventional 2D histology and 3D histology using mirror sections was not perfect. This was attributed to potential gaps between sections and tissue swelling during processing.
  • Sheetlet Analysis Challenges: The study noted difficulties in distinguishing secondary and tertiary eigenvectors for sheetlet analysis in cleared tissue, suggesting that optimized imaging or clearing techniques are needed for more detailed microstructural analysis.
  • Ex Vivo Study: The current study was conducted ex vivo, meaning serial imaging to track temporal changes in myocardial remodeling was not possible. The authors suggest future studies should focus on in vivo applications.
  • Future Directions: The authors propose that DTI, validated by this tissue-clearing technique, is a promising tool for non-invasive characterization of cardiomyocyte architecture in various cardiac diseases, enabling earlier detection and better understanding of structure-function relationships. Further work could explore more advanced sheetlet analysis and in vivo longitudinal studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

We characterized the microstructural response of the myocardium to cardiovascular disease using diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) and performed histological validation by intact, un-sectioned, three-dimensional (3D) histology using a tissue-clearing technique. The approach was validated in normal (n = 7) and ischemic (n = 8) heart failure model mice. Whole heart fiber tracking using DTI in fixed ex-vivo mouse hearts was performed, and the hearts were processed with the tissue-clearing technique. Cardiomyocytes orientation was quantified on both DTI and 3D histology. Helix angle (HA) and global HA transmurality (HAT) were calculated, and the DTI findings were confirmed with 3D histology. Global HAT was significantly reduced in the ischemic group (DTI: 0.79 ± 0.13°/% transmural depth [TD] and 3D histology: 0.84 ± 0.26°/%TD) compared with controls (DTI: 1.31 ± 0.20°/%TD and 3D histology: 1.36 ± 0.27°/%TD, all p < 0.001). On direct comparison of DTI with 3D histology for the quantitative assessment of cardiomyocytes orientation, significant correlations were observed in both per-sample (R<sup>2</sup> = 0.803) and per-segment analyses (R<sup>2</sup> = 0.872). We demonstrated the capability and accuracy of DTI for mapping cardiomyocytes orientation by comparison with the intact 3D histology acquired by tissue-clearing technique. DTI is a promising tool for the noninvasive characterization of cardiomyocytes architecture.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2018three,
  author = {Sang‐Eun Lee and Christopher Nguyen and Jongjin Yoon and Hyuk‐Jae Chang and Sekeun Kim and Chul Hoon Kim and Debiao Li},
  title = {{Three-dimensional Cardiomyocytes Structure Revealed By Diffusion Tensor Imaging and Its Validation Using a Tissue-Clearing Technique}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-24622-6},
}
Figure