We study reinforcement learning in settings where sampling an action from the policy must be done concurrently with the time evolution of the controlled system. Much like a person or an animal, a robot must "think and move" at the same time, deciding on its next action before the previous one has completed.
This paper challenges the standard "observe-think-act" paradigm in Reinforcement Learning (RL), where agents assume the world freezes while they compute their next move. By reformulating the Bellman equations to account for system latency and "thinking time," the authors enable robots to act concurrently—achieving comparable success to traditional methods while operating up to 49% faster in real-world tasks.
The Problem: The "Observe-Think-Act" Bottleneck
Most Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) algorithms operate in a blocking fashion: the agent observes a state, pauses the environment (conceptually or literally in simulation), computes an action, and then executes it. While this works for Atari games or static simulations, it fails in the concurrent real world.
In robotics, the environment doesn't stop. If a robot is trying to catch a ball, the ball continues to move while the robot's "brain" (the neural network) processes the camera feed. If the agent doesn't account for the time it takes to "think" and the fact that the previous action is still being executed during that time, its commands will be based on stale data. This leads to jerky motions or total failure in dynamic tasks.
Methodology: Concurrent MDPs
The authors introduce an algorithmic framework for Concurrent MDPs to bridge the gap between discrete-time decision making and continuous-time execution.
Their approach involves four main pillars:
- Theoretical Reformulation: They start with a continuous-time formulation of the Bellman equations and discretize them in a way that is explicitly aware of system delays ($t_{AS}$, or action selection time).
- Modified Bellman Operator: They derive a new Bellman backup operator that incorporates the "spillover" of the previous action. This ensures the Q-function understands that the state will evolve during the computation phase.
- Concurrent Knowledge Representation: To make this practical, they augment the agent's input with "concurrent knowledge." The most effective feature introduced is Vector-to-go (VTG), which encodes the remaining portion of the previous action that is still being executed at the moment the current state is observed.
- Architectural Extension: These changes are implemented as simple additions to existing value-based algorithms like DQN and QT-Opt, requiring minimal changes to the underlying neural network architectures.
Experimental Setup
The researchers evaluated their framework across three main environments:
- Toy Control Tasks: Modified versions of the Cartpole and Pendulum environments from the DeepMind Control Suite, engineered to include variable latencies and concurrent execution.
- Simulated Robotic Grasping: A large-scale simulation of a 7-DoF robotic arm tasked with picking up procedurally generated objects from a bin.
- Real-World Robotics: A physical 7-DoF manipulator arm performing grasping tasks on common household objects to validate the simulation results.
Key Insights and Results
- VTG is the "Secret Sauce": Among various ways to represent the state of the system (like stacking past frames or just providing the previous action), Vector-to-go (VTG) was the most robust. It provides the agent with a clear picture of its own "momentum" during the decision-making process.
- Performance Recovery: In concurrent versions of Cartpole and Pendulum, agents using VTG were able to recover the performance level of a "blocking" agent, whereas standard unconditioned agents failed as latency increased.
- Latency as a Feature, Not a Bug: Instead of trying to minimize latency through expensive hardware, the authors show that you can simply teach the agent to reason about that latency.
- Smoothness Emerges Naturally: Because the agent plans its next move while the current one is finishing, the resulting trajectories are significantly smoother and more "human-like" compared to the jerky "stop-and-go" motion of blocking agents.
- Real-World Speedup: In the robotic grasping task, the concurrent agent achieved a 49% faster execution speed (policy duration) compared to the blocking baseline while maintaining comparable grasp success rates. In simulated grasping, concurrent models reduced the total wall-clock time per episode by approximately 31.3%.
Limitations and Future Work
While highly effective, the authors note a few areas for future exploration:
- Off-Policy Data Efficiency: An interesting future direction is exploring how to better utilize off-policy data collected under different latency regimes.
- Beyond Value-Based RL: This work focused on value-based methods (DQN, QT-Opt). Extending the concurrent framework to policy gradient methods or actor-critic architectures remains an open area.
- Variable Latency: While the framework handles latency, extremely high or highly unpredictable jitter in computation time could still pose challenges for the current discretization method.
Summary updated