Thin X ray Lens Design And Simulation

Jiaming Shen, Jenny A Shen2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel "thin sandwich" mirror array lens for X-ray telescopes, aiming to overcome the bulk and weight limitations of current designs. By fabricating a solid disc of alternating mirror and substrate layers without air gaps, they demonstrate through ray tracing simulations that this design can achieve precise focusing and potentially offer new methods for image deconvolution and star localization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional X-ray telescopes often rely on Wolter-type optics, which use precisely shaped parabolic and hyperbolic mirrors. However, these designs typically involve multiple, separate mirror shells with air gaps, leading to bulky and heavy instruments. This weight and size constraint limits the aperture and thus the light-gathering capability of X-ray telescopes. The authors aim to address this by proposing a compact, "thin sandwich" mirror array lens that integrates these optical elements into a single, solid disc, potentially enabling larger aperture X-ray telescopes.

Methods

The core of the proposed method involves fabricating a thin X-ray lens by depositing alternating layers of mirror coatings and transparent substrates. This "sandwich" structure eliminates air gaps, creating a solid disc. The mirrors are designed as arrays of parabolic and hyperbolic rings, precisely shaped through polishing. The X-rays are intended to graze along the surface of the mirror coatings, which are embedded within the substrate.

The authors employed geometrical optics ray tracing for simulation. They modeled two artificial stars as light sources and a virtual lens array with a disc at the focal plane representing a CCD receiver. This simulation allowed them to analyze the focal quality and the patterns formed by X-rays. They also developed a method for calculating the gap between mirror rings to avoid blocking incident rays.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The simulations used artificial star sources with parameters similar to the real star SN185.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Integrated "Sandwich" Optics: The concept of a solid, layered mirror-substrate structure eliminates air gaps, offering a more compact and potentially lighter alternative to traditional X-ray optics.
  • Grazing Incidence within Substrate: X-rays are designed to graze along the internal mirror coatings embedded within a transparent substrate, a novel approach to mirror design.
  • Corn-Shaped Aberration as a Feature: Rays from off-axis stars form a distinct "corn shape" pattern on the CCD. Instead of being purely an aberration, this pattern is proposed as a valuable diagnostic tool for image deconvolution and potentially for determining star location and distance.
  • Gap Calculation for Optical Performance: A method is presented to calculate the necessary gap between mirror rings to ensure incident rays are not blocked, crucial for maintaining optical efficiency.
  • Fabrication Feasibility: The paper suggests that current thin-film coating technologies are suitable for fabricating such mirror arrays.

Key Results

  • Ray tracing simulations demonstrated that the proposed thin sandwich lens can focus X-rays.
  • Off-axis stars produce a characteristic "corn shape" pattern on the focal plane, which the authors believe can be used for image reconstruction and potentially for determining star location.
  • The simulation results indicate that the gap size between mirror rings is primarily determined by the parabolic mirror's ray path (da), and this gap is critical for preventing ray blockage.
  • The paper presents relationships between lens radius, the number of mirror rings, and lens thickness, showing that thicker mirrors require fewer rings but reduce the overall effective lens area.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation: The paper focuses on simulation and design. Experimental studies are needed to validate the proposed fabrication process and the optical performance of the thin sandwich lens.
  • Scattering and Absorption: While the substrate material is chosen for its transparency, some scattering and absorption of X-rays by the substrate material are acknowledged. The authors suggest this can be compensated for by a larger lens aperture.
  • Wave Physics: The ray tracing simulation assumes the particle nature of X-rays dominates, which is valid for structures larger than 100 nm. However, for smaller structures, wave effects like interference and diffraction might become significant.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further study into using "corn shape" mirrors to replace hyperbolic curves and the potential for using the observed corn pattern to extract star location information. They also mention ongoing simulations for thin-film coating technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

A proposal of thin sandwich mirror array lens for X-ray telescope Wolter type lens is discussed. We discussed a process of design, fabrication of this thin X-ray lens and conducted a simulation and provided a measurement method for lens focal quality. The lens consists of two connected layers of arrays of rings of mirrors, one is of parabolic mirror and another is of hyperbolic mirrors. In each layer, the mirror coating is deposited on a substrate and next substrate in turn is deposited on this mirror film, leaving no air gap. Repeat this process to form an array of mirrors. Hence form a solid thin disc sandwich mirror lens and each ring of mirror can be curved precisely by polishing process. X ray travels into the transparent substrate and grazes on the surface of the mirror coating facing the substrate. Using geometrical optics ray tracing, we conducted simulation with two artificial distance stars as the source objects, a virtual lens of mirror array and a disc placed at the focal plane as the receiver CCD. Simulation shows that the star located off optical axis forms corn shape patterns by its ray crossing pointa on CCD disc. Those patterns may provide the baseline pattern for further image deconvolution or aberration reducing algorithm. The corn pattern is related to the dimensional structure of the lens and the space location of the star; hence, it contains some information about space location of the star. A simulation of ray tracing video is made as well. The thin sandwich lens we discussed in this paper may provide a way to build a large aperture telescope X ray lens
BibTeX
@misc{shen2019thin,
  author = {Jiaming Shen and Jenny A Shen},
  title = {{Thin X ray Lens Design And Simulation}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.31224/osf.io/qwcav},
}
Figure