Thermal Performance Optimization Simulation Study of a Passive Solar House with a Light Steel Structure and Phase Change Walls

Lei Cheng, Chunlong Zhuang, Shengbo Eben Li, Guangqin Huang, Hongyu Zhang, Fei Gan, Ningge Xu, Shanshan HouEnergies 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the use of phase change materials (PCMs) in light steel-framed passive solar houses to improve thermal performance, particularly in challenging climates like the Tibetan Plateau. By developing a novel evaluation index and using EnergyPlus simulations, the study identifies optimal PCM phase change temperatures and layer thicknesses, along with insulation levels, to enhance indoor temperature stability and energy efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Light steel structures, while offering advantages in modularity and transport, often suffer from poor thermal performance, leading to high energy consumption for heating, especially in extreme climates. Passive solar houses aim to utilize solar energy for heating, but its intermittent nature poses a challenge. Phase change materials (PCMs) can store and release thermal energy, helping to buffer temperature fluctuations and improve the utilization of solar heat. However, optimizing the integration of PCMs into light steel structures, considering factors like phase change temperature, material thickness, and insulation, requires detailed analysis to overcome these limitations and ensure comfortable indoor environments.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Theoretical Analysis: They derived a theoretical formula for the phase change temperature of PCMs based on heat balance within the heat-collecting partition wall, suggesting it should be 1-3 °C higher than the target indoor air temperature.
  • Novel Evaluation Index: A new metric, the "accumulated daily indoor temperature offset value" ($I_{EX}$), was proposed to quantify the effectiveness of PCMs in stabilizing indoor temperatures and reducing fluctuations.
  • Numerical Simulation: The EnergyPlus software was utilized to build a detailed simulation model of a Trombe-style passive solar house with PCM walls. This allowed for the investigation of various parameters.
  • Two-Factor Coupling Analysis: The study systematically analyzed the combined influence of PCM phase change temperature and PCM layer thickness on the $I_{EX}$ value.
  • Parameter Optimization: Simulations were conducted to determine the optimal thickness of the insulation layer.
  • Model Validation: The simulation model's accuracy was verified against experimental data from actual passive solar rooms built for testing.

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • Experimental Data: Data from actual passive solar rooms (one experimental, one PCM-equipped) built in Xining city, Qinghai Province, China, were used for model validation.
  • Meteorological Data: Measured meteorological data from Xining city for January were used as input for the simulations.
  • Material Properties: Physical and thermal properties of various prepared PCM materials (capric acid, lauric acid, myristic acid based) and insulation materials (EPS) were used as simulation parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PCM as a Thermal Buffer: PCMs are crucial for smoothing out the inherent intermittency of solar energy, storing heat during the day and releasing it at night to maintain a more stable indoor temperature.
  • The $I_{EX}$ Index: The proposed "accumulated daily indoor temperature offset value" ($I_{EX}$) provides a quantitative way to assess the overall thermal performance and temperature regulation effectiveness of PCM integration. A lower $I_{EX}$ signifies better performance.
  • Coupling Effects: The performance of the PCM wall is not solely dependent on individual parameters but rather on the interplay between PCM phase change temperature and its layer thickness.
  • Optimal PCM Temperature: The optimal phase change temperature for the PCM is closely linked to the desired indoor design temperature, with a recommendation of 1-3 °C above it.
  • Optimal PCM Thickness: There's a critical optimal thickness for the PCM layer. Exceeding this thickness doesn't necessarily improve performance and can even lead to harsher indoor thermal environments due to reduced heat penetration and release efficiency.
  • Insulation's Independent Role: The insulation layer thickness has a significant, independent impact on indoor temperature stability, offering an economic optimization point.

Key Results

  • Optimal Combination: Under typical Tibetan Plateau conditions, the optimal combination for the phase change temperature and layer thickness was found to be 17 °C and 15 mm, respectively, resulting in a low $I_{EX}$ value.
  • PCM Thickness Limit: For a given phase change temperature, increasing the PCM layer thickness beyond a certain point (around 15 mm in this study) did not improve the indoor thermal environment and could even worsen it.
  • Optimal Insulation Thickness: The optimal insulation layer thickness for the Trombe solar house was determined to be 50 mm, balancing thermal performance with construction cost and convenience.
  • Model Validation: The EnergyPlus simulation model demonstrated good agreement with experimental data, accurately predicting the trend of indoor temperature fluctuations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Generalizability: The study's findings are based on specific meteorological conditions of the Tibetan Plateau. While the methodology is presented as a feasible design method, the specific optimal parameters might differ for other climates. The authors suggest that when building parameters differ significantly from the model, the proposed method should be used to determine reasonable phase change temperature and layer thickness.
  • Simplified Model Assumptions: The simulation made several simplifying assumptions, such as considering heat transfer only in the wall's thickness direction, ignoring natural convection during melting and supercooling effects, and neglecting the heat capacity of glass and the influence of indoor equipment.
  • Future Work: The paper provides a framework for optimizing PCM integration. Future work could explore a wider range of PCM materials, different building geometries, and more complex climate scenarios to further refine the design guidelines. Investigating the long-term durability and cost-effectiveness of these solutions would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Phase change materials are used in passive solar house construction with light steel structure walls, which can overcome the problems of weak heat storage capacity and poor utilization of solar heat and effectively solve the thermal defects of light steel structure walls. Based on this, on the basis of preliminary experimental research, this study further carried out theoretical analysis and simulation research on the thermal performance of a light steel structure passive solar house (Trombe form) with PCM walls. Through the heat balance analysis of heat transfer in the heat collecting partition wall, the theoretical calculation formula of the phase change temperature of the PCM was obtained, and it verified theoretically that the phase change temperature value should be 1–3 °C higher than the target indoor air temperature. The evaluation index “accumulated daily indoor temperature offset value” was proposed for evaluating the effect of phase change materials on the indoor temperature of the passive solar house, and “EnergyPlus” software was used to study the influence of the phase change temperature, the amount of material, and the thickness of the insulation layer on the indoor air temperature in a natural day. The results showed that there was a coupling relationship among the performance and between of the thickness of the PCM layer and the phase change temperature. Under typical diurnal climate conditions in the northern Tibetan Plateau of China, the optimal combination of the phase change temperature and the layer thickness was 17 °C and 15 mm, respectively. Especially at a certain temperature, excessive increases in the thickness of the phase transition layer could not improve the indoor thermal environment. For this transition temperature, there exists an optimal transition layer thickness. For a Trombe solar house, the thickness of the insulation layer has an independent impact on indoor temperature compared to other factors, which has an economic value, such as 50 mm in this case. In general, this paper studied the relationship between several important parameters of the phase change wall of a solar house by using numerical simulation methods and quantitatively calculated the optimal parameters under typical meteorological conditions, thus providing a feasible simulation design method for similar engineering applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2023thermal,
  author = {Lei Cheng and Chunlong Zhuang and Shengbo Eben Li and Guangqin Huang and Hongyu Zhang and Fei Gan and Ningge Xu and Shanshan Hou},
  title = {{Thermal Performance Optimization Simulation Study of a Passive Solar House with a Light Steel Structure and Phase Change Walls}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/en16093725},
}
Figure