Theory of Aces: Fame by chance or merit?

M. V. Simkin, Vwani RoychowdhuryJournal of Mathematical Sociology 2003 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates the relationship between achievement and fame using WWI fighter pilots as a case study. They found that fame, measured by Google hits, grows exponentially with achievement (aircraft destroyed), but the distribution of fame itself follows a power law, suggesting an inherent unfairness in how recognition is distributed. A stochastic model is proposed to explain these observations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the age-old question of whether fame is a result of merit or simply chance. While it's difficult to objectively measure "merit" in many fields, WWI fighter pilots offer a unique opportunity: their "achievement" can be quantified by the number of enemy aircraft they shot down. The authors aim to empirically determine if this quantifiable achievement directly translates into fame, and if so, how this relationship shapes the overall distribution of fame among these pilots. They also explore the underlying mechanisms that might lead to such a distribution.

Methods

The researchers collected data on WWI German fighter pilots, using the number of opponent aircraft destroyed as a measure of achievement. Fame was quantified by the number of Google web pages mentioning each pilot, with search results filtered to ensure relevance (e.g., including terms like "pilot" or "ace"). They then performed statistical analysis, including calculating correlation coefficients between achievement and the logarithm of fame, and analyzing the distribution of both achievement and fame. A stochastic model was developed to explain the observed exponential growth of fame with achievement and the resulting power-law distribution of fame.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of information on 392 German WWI fighter pilots, including their number of confirmed aerial victories (achievement) and the number of Google web pages mentioning them (fame). A smaller subset of 33 aces who had books written about them was also used to compare "book-fame" with "Google-fame."

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fame grows exponentially with achievement: While not a perfect linear relationship, the more aircraft a pilot shot down, the exponentially greater their fame tended to be.
  • Achievement distribution is exponential: The number of pilots achieving a certain level of merit decreases exponentially as that merit increases. In simpler terms, very few pilots achieved a high number of victories.
  • Fame distribution is a power law: Despite the exponential relationship between fame and achievement, the overall distribution of fame among all pilots follows a power law. This means a few pilots are incredibly famous, while a vast majority are relatively unknown.
  • "Unfair" distribution of fame: The power-law distribution implies that fame is not distributed proportionally to achievement. A small number of highly accomplished individuals capture a disproportionately large share of the overall fame.
  • Stochastic model explains the phenomenon: The authors propose a model where fame replicates like a meme, with its spread influenced by an individual's "achievement" acting as a form of Darwinian fitness. This model successfully explains both the exponential growth of fame with achievement and the resulting power-law distribution.

Key Results

  • A strong correlation (r ≈ 0.72) was found between achievement and the logarithm of fame for German WWI aces. This indicates that approximately 52% of the variation in fame can be explained by achievement.
  • The correlation between achievement and fame (without the logarithm) was weaker (r ≈ 0.48).
  • Fame measured by the number of Google hits was highly correlated (r ≈ 0.985) with fame measured by the number of books written about the aces, suggesting consistency in fame metrics.
  • The distribution of achievement (number of victories) was found to be exponential.
  • The distribution of fame (Google hits) followed a power law, with the fitted exponent (γ ≈ 1.9) being close to the theoretical prediction from the model (γ ≈ 2.1).
  • Manfred von Richthofen, with 80 victories, accounted for 27% of the total fame despite only being responsible for 1.6% of the total aircraft destroyed by German aces.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data limitations: The study was limited to German aces due to the difficulty in filtering namesakes and the time-consuming nature of manual verification. The data was collected around May 2003, and the authors acknowledge that current Google hit counts would differ.
  • "Fame" for non-meritorious reasons: The paper notes that some aces acquired fame for reasons other than aerial combat (e.g., aerobatics, writing books), which might slightly inflate the true correlation between combat achievement and fame.
  • Generalizability: While the model is proposed to explain the observed phenomena, its direct applicability to other fields where "achievement" is less quantifiable would require further investigation.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that their findings are relevant to problems studied in the context of evolving networks and the theory of citing, indicating potential avenues for future research. They also highlight that the derived probability of achieving fame significantly higher or lower than expected provides a sense of "relief to the unknown."

Summary updated

Abstract

We study empirically how fame of WWI fighter-pilot aces, measured in numbers of web pages mentioning them, is related to their achievement or merit, measured in numbers of opponent aircraft destroyed. We find that on the average fame grows exponentially with achievement; to be precise, there is a strong correlation (~0.7) between achievement and the logarithm of fame. At the same time, the number of individuals achieving a particular level of merit decreases exponentially with the magnitude of the level, leading to a power-law distribution of fame. A stochastic model that can explain the exponential growth of fame with merit is also proposed.
BibTeX
@article{simkin2003theory,
  author = {M. V. Simkin and Vwani Roychowdhury},
  title = {{Theory of Aces: Fame by chance or merit?}},
  journal = {Journal of Mathematical Sociology},
  year = {2003},
}
Figure