Estimating achievement from fame

M. V. Simkin, Vwani RoychowdhuryarXiv 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We report a method for estimating people's achievement based on their fame. Earlier we discovered (cond-mat/0310049) that fame of fighter pilot aces (measured as number of Google hits) grows exponentially with their achievement (number of victories). We hypothesize that the same functional relationship between achievement and fame holds for other professions. This allows us to estimate achievement for professions where an unquestionable and universally accepted measure of achievement does not exist. We apply the method to Nobel Prize winners in Physics. For example, we obtain that Paul Dirac, who is a hundred times less famous than Einstein, contributed to physics only two times less. We compare our results with Landau's ranking.

Introduction

Quantifying human achievement is a persistent challenge in sociology and scientometrics. Traditional metrics, such as publication counts or citation indices, are often compromised by "buzzword" inflation or the "copying effect," where researchers cite papers primarily because they are already widely cited. This paper proposes an alternative: using public visibility, or "fame," as a proxy for merit. By inverting the observed exponential relationship between fame and achievement in objective fields (like aerial combat), we can estimate achievement in subjective fields like theoretical physics.

Methods

The core hypothesis is that fame ($F$) grows exponentially with achievement ($A$): $$F(A) = C \cdot e^{\beta A}$$ where $C$ and $\beta$ are constants. To estimate achievement from fame, we invert this relationship: $$A(F) = \frac{\ln(F/C)}{\beta}$$ Because the sensitivity parameter $\beta$ is unknown for physicists, we normalize achievement relative to Albert Einstein ($A_E = 1$). To handle the unknown constant $C$, we establish a "floor" by assigning zero achievement to the least famous individual in our sample (Nils Dalén). This provides a lower bound for achievement measured in "Einsteins."

Validation and Results

To validate this model, we first analyzed data from 392 German WWI fighter aces, where achievement (aerial victories) is precisely recorded. We found that the ratio of predicted to actual achievement follows a lognormal distribution. With 85% probability, the real achievement was within a factor of two of the estimate.

Cumulative distribution of estimation errors for WWI fighter pilots, demonstrating that the observed distribution closely tracks a normal distribution in log-space.

Applying this model to 45 pre-WWII Nobel Laureates in Physics reveals a striking compression of merit compared to fame. While Google hits (measured in 2008) span several orders of magnitude, the estimated achievement scores are much more tightly clustered.

Table of physicists ranked by Google hits and estimated achievement in 'Einsteins'.

Key findings include:

  • Albert Einstein: 1.00 Einsteins (Benchmark)
  • Max Planck: 0.911 Einsteins
  • Niels Bohr: 0.709 Einsteins
  • Werner Heisenberg: 0.632 Einsteins
  • Paul Dirac: 0.474 Einsteins

Notably, Dirac is roughly 100 times less famous than Einstein, yet his estimated contribution is nearly half as significant. This aligns with the subjective rankings of Lev Landau, who used a similar logarithmic scale to categorize physicists.

Discussion

The logarithmic nature of the achievement-fame relationship acts as a natural noise filter. While external factors—such as institutional names (Max Planck) or political infamy (Hermann Göring)—can inflate Google hits by orders of magnitude, the resulting impact on the achievement estimate is relatively small. For instance, a 37% reduction in Planck's hits would only shift his achievement score by 12%.

While the method is inherently approximate, it offers a data-driven way to automate expert intuition using the "wisdom of the crowds" reflected in web data. Future work could extend this model to other domains where achievement is difficult to quantify, such as the arts or humanities.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report a method for estimating people's achievement based on their fame. Earlier we discovered (cond-mat/0310049) that fame of fighter pilot aces (measured as number of Google hits) grows exponentially with their achievement (number of victories). We hypothesize that the same functional relation between achievement and fame holds for other professions. This allows us to estimate achievement for professions where an unquestionable and universally accepted measure of achievement does not exist. We apply the method to Nobel Prize winners in Physics. For example, we obtain that Paul Dirac, who is hundred times less famous than Einstein contributed to physics only two times less. We compare our results with Landau's ranking.
BibTeX
@misc{simkin2009estimating,
  author = {M. V. Simkin and Vwani Roychowdhury},
  title = {{Estimating achievement from fame}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0906.3558},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0906.3558},
}
Figure