Theoretical study of cellulose II nanocrystals with different exposed facets

Can Leng, Kenli Li, Zean Tian, Yubing Si, Huang Huang, Junfeng Li, Jie Liu, Keqin Li

TL;DR

This study theoretically investigates how different exposed facets of cellulose II nanocrystals influence their properties. By designing various nanocrystal models and analyzing their hydroxymethyl group conformations, hydrogen bonding networks, and structural stability, the researchers found that flat facets lead to more stable nanocrystals. This work provides a strategy for designing novel cellulose nanocrystals with tailored properties by controlling their exposed crystal facets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) are a promising class of nanomaterials derived from the abundant natural polymer, cellulose. Their unique chemical and mechanical properties make them attractive for various applications, including in medicine, environmental technologies, and separation processes. However, a key question remains: how do the different exposed surfaces (facets) of these nanocrystals affect their overall physicochemical properties? Understanding this relationship is crucial for rationally designing CNCs with specific functionalities. While experimental studies have touched upon the stability of different cellulose allomorphs and the influence of shape, a detailed theoretical investigation into how specific exposed facets of cellulose II nanocrystals impact their internal structure, hydrogen bonding, and stability was lacking.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations and Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to investigate their designed cellulose II nanocrystal models.

  • Nanocrystal Design: Six cellulose II nanocrystal models were theoretically designed, exposing different crystal facets: (001), (112), and (221). These were categorized as Type-A, Type-B, and Type-O crystals, with variations in chain length (Degree of Polymerization, DP) and the number of chains.
  • Hydroxymethyl Conformation Analysis: MD simulations were used to analyze the distribution of hydroxymethyl group conformations (specifically, the dihedral angle O5-C5-C6-O6) in the terminal anhydroglucose units. This helped understand how the exposed facet influences the orientation of these crucial functional groups.
  • Hydrogen Bond (HB) Analysis: The study investigated the hydrogen bond networks within the nanocrystals. This involved identifying different types of HBs, calculating their fractions, distances, and angles. The strength of these HBs was further assessed using a method that correlates bonding critical point properties with HB strength.
  • Structural Stability: DFT calculations were performed on isolated chain sheet models to quantify the relative structural stability of the nanocrystals. This involved calculating binding energies (ΔEbind) and sheet energies (ΔEsheet) in both vacuum and water environments.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical models and simulations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Facet-Dependent Hydroxymethyl Conformations: The orientation of hydroxymethyl groups on the terminal anhydroglucose units is significantly influenced by the exposed facet. Inclined facets tend to favor the gauche-gauche (gg) conformation, while flatter facets allow for more gauche-trans (gt) conformations. This suggests that surface chemistry can be tuned by facet engineering.
  • HB Network Sensitivity to Facets: The hydrogen bond network, particularly at the chain ends, is directly affected by the exposed facet. Different facets lead to varying contact sites between adjacent chains, influencing the formation and types of HBs. This highlights the interconnectedness of surface structure and internal bonding.
  • Flat Facets are More Stable: The study strongly indicates that cellulose II nanocrystals with flat exposed facets (specifically the (001) facet, designated as Type-O) are the most structurally stable. Stability decreases as the facets become more inclined. This is a crucial finding for material design, suggesting that controlling the surface orientation is key to achieving robust materials.
  • Chain Length Dominates Stability in Type-A Models: For Type-A nanocrystals, the length of the cellulose chains (DP) has a more significant impact on structural stability than the number of chains. This provides a clear parameter for optimizing stability within a given facet type.
  • HB Strength as a Design Tool: The weak to medium strength of the identified HBs offers a potential avenue for chemical modification. Understanding these interactions can guide strategies for functionalizing CNC surfaces for specific applications.

Key Results

  • The gt distribution of hydroxymethyl groups was found to be higher for the flat (001) facet (6012, 21.60%) compared to inclined facets (e.g., 6A12, 15.89%). Conversely, the gg distribution was lower for the flat facet.
  • The study identified eight types of hydrogen bonds, with O₂H…O₆ and O₂H…O₂ being the most favorable.
  • 6012 (Type-O, flat facet) was found to be the most stable nanocrystal model, exhibiting the lowest binding and sheet energies, both in vacuum and water.
  • For Type-A models, increasing the DP from 6 to 19 led to a significant increase in HB numbers, while the number of chains had a negligible effect on stability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Limitations: The paper acknowledges that conventional DFT calculations are limited to a few hundred atoms, necessitating the use of semi-empirical methods for larger systems. While these methods have advanced, they still represent approximations.
  • Experimental Validation: The study is theoretical. Future work should focus on experimentally validating these findings, particularly regarding the relationship between exposed facets, HB networks, and structural stability.
  • Water Environment Complexity: While water simulations were performed, the complexity of real-world aqueous environments might introduce further nuances not fully captured.
  • Broader Range of Facets: The study focused on specific facets. Exploring a wider range of crystal facets and their combinations could reveal more intricate structure-property relationships.
  • Synthesis Strategy: The paper suggests that tuning exposed facets will guide the design of novel CNCs. Future research could explore practical synthesis strategies to achieve precise control over these facets.

Summary updated

Abstract

Derived from the most abundant natural polymer, cellulose nanocrystal materials have attracted attention in recent decades due to their chemical and mechanical properties. However, still unclear is the influence of different exposed facets of the cellulose nanocrystals on the physicochemical properties. Herein, we first designed cellulose II nanocrystals with different exposed facets, the hydroxymethyl conformations distribution, hydrogen bond (HB) analysis, as well as the relative structural stability of these models (including crystal facets {A, B, O} and Type-A models vary in size) are theoretically investigated. The results reveal that the HB network of terminal anhydroglucose depends on the adjacent chain's contact sites in nanocrystals exposed with different facets. Compared to nanocrystals exposed with inclined facet, these exposed with flat facet tend to be the most stable. Therefore, the strategy of tuning exposed crystal facets will guide the design of novel cellulose nanocrystals with various physicochemical properties.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{leng2021theoretical,
  author = {Can Leng and Kenli Li and Zean Tian and Yubing Si and Huang Huang and Junfeng Li and Jie Liu and Wei‐Qing Huang and Keqin Li},
  title = {{Theoretical study of cellulose II nanocrystals with different exposed facets}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-01438-5},
}
Figure