Theoretical Puncture Mechanics of Soft Compressible Solids

Stefano Fregonese, Zhiyuan Tong, Sibo Wang, Mattia BaccaJournal of Applied Mechanics 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new theoretical model for predicting the force required to puncture soft, compressible materials. By accounting for volumetric compressibility, the model reveals that contrary to intuition, compressibility can increase puncture resistance in tough materials, offering new insights for designing better needles and protective materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately predicting the force needed to puncture soft materials is crucial for applications ranging from medical procedures like biopsies and injections to food processing and manufacturing. Existing theoretical models often simplify material behavior by assuming incompressibility, meaning they ignore how materials change volume under pressure. However, most real-world soft materials do change volume. This simplification limits the accuracy of these models, especially when dealing with complex failure mechanisms and deep indentation. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a more realistic model that incorporates the effects of volumetric compressibility on puncture mechanics.

Methods

The researchers propose a theoretical model based on a quasi-static, linearly elastic, and compressible material assumption. They model the puncturing needle as a rigid cylinder with a spherical tip. The core of their approach involves:

  • Constitutive Model: They employ a 1-term Ogden hyperelastic model, which is a standard approach for describing the large deformations of soft materials. Crucially, they extend this by incorporating a linear elastic compressibility component, distinguishing it from previous models that assumed incompressibility.
  • Finite Element Analysis (FEA): While the paper presents a theoretical framework, it relies on FEA to compute key parameters like the J-integral (related to energy release rate) and strain energy. These FEA results are then used to derive empirical fitting laws.
  • Force-Displacement Relationships: They develop equations to describe the force required for both needle indentation (before rupture) and penetration (after rupture). These equations relate the puncture force to material properties (toughness, stiffness, strain-stiffening, bulk modulus) and needle geometry.

The novelty lies in the explicit inclusion of volumetric compressibility and its interplay with other material properties, moving beyond the common incompressibility assumption.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study is primarily theoretical, deriving relationships based on established material models and FEA simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Compressibility as a Strength Enhancer: Surprisingly, volumetric compressibility can increase puncture resistance in tough and soft materials. This is attributed to an "additional (strain) energy barrier to puncture" arising from the energy required to open the crack (spacing energy).
  • Incompressibility is Not Always Optimal: For tough materials, the model suggests that incompressible materials exhibit lower puncture resistance compared to their compressible counterparts.
  • Brittle/Stiff Materials Benefit from Incompressibility: Conversely, for brittle and stiff materials, incompressibility leads to higher puncture resistance. Volumetric compressibility in these materials appears to detract from their strength.
  • Interplay of Properties: The study highlights a complex interplay between strain-stiffening, toughness, stiffness, and volumetric compressibility, showing how these factors collectively influence puncture behavior. Strain-stiffening generally increases resistance, but its effect is modulated by compressibility.
  • Design Implications: The findings offer a valuable tool for designing sharper needles and more effective puncture-resistant materials by allowing engineers to tune material properties based on desired outcomes.

Key Results

  • The model successfully predicts puncture force and indentation depth based on material properties and needle geometry.
  • Materials with high toughness and low modulus exhibit the highest puncture resistance, a finding consistent with previous work.
  • The model quantifies how volumetric compressibility can either enhance or detract from puncture resistance depending on the material's intrinsic properties (toughness vs. stiffness). For tough materials, compressibility increases resistance; for brittle materials, it decreases it.
  • The study provides dimensionless parameters and fitting equations (e.g., Eq. 8, 9, 10, 11) that correlate various material properties (strain-stiffening coefficient $\alpha$, bulk modulus $\kappa/\mu$) and geometric ratios (relative toughness $\mu R/G_c$) with critical puncture forces and depths.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Linear Elastic Compressibility: The model assumes linear elastic compressibility. The authors acknowledge that for highly compressible materials (low $\kappa/\mu$), volumetric strain can become significant, and a linear approximation might introduce errors. They suggest that a nonlinear elastic response for volumetric strain could improve accuracy but would significantly complicate the model.
  • Frictionless Assumption: The study assumes frictionless contact between the needle and the specimen, which is stated to be a reasonable approximation only at shallow penetration depths after insertion. The authors note that friction becomes important at greater depths and can induce a linear increment in penetration force.
  • Experimental Validation: The authors explicitly state that their theoretical findings require experimental validation, which is currently unavailable in the literature. This is identified as a crucial next step for future development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Accurate prediction of the force required to puncture a soft material is critical in many fields like medical technology, food processing, and manufacturing. However, such a prediction strongly depends on our understanding of the complex nonlinear behavior of the material subject to deep indentation and complex failure mechanisms. Only recently, we developed theories capable of correlating puncture force with material properties and needle geometry. However, such models are based on simplifications that seldom limit their applicability to real cases. One common assumption is the incompressibility of the cut material, albeit no material is truly incompressible. In this article, we propose a simple model that accounts for linearly elastic compressibility, and its interplay with toughness, stiffness, and elastic strain stiffening. Confirming previous theories and experiments, materials having high toughness and low modulus exhibit the highest dimensionless puncture resistance at a given needle radius. Surprisingly, in these conditions, we observe that incompressible materials exhibit the lowest puncture resistance, where volumetric compressibility can create an additional (strain) energy barrier to puncture. Our model provides a valuable tool to assess the puncture resistance of soft compressible materials and suggests new design strategies for sharp needles and puncture-resistant materials.
BibTeX
@article{fregonese2023theoretical,
  author = {Stefano Fregonese and Zhiyuan Tong and Sibo Wang and Mattia Bacca},
  title = {{Theoretical Puncture Mechanics of Soft Compressible Solids}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Mechanics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1115/1.4062844},
}
Figure