Thematically Analysing Social Network Content During Disasters Through the Lens of the Disaster Management Lifecycle

Sophie Parsons, Peter M. Atkinson, Elena Simperl, Mark J. Weal

Introduction

During natural disasters, social media platforms like Twitter transform into a "digital firehose" of real-time information. While emergency responders increasingly utilize this data for immediate situational awareness, a significant challenge remains: integrating this chaotic, high-volume data into formal disaster management processes. This research addresses the gap in understanding how communication evolves throughout the entire disaster lifecycle, moving beyond the immediate response phase to include long-term recovery.

Methodology

The study employed a hybrid approach combining qualitative social science techniques with computational data processing. Researchers analyzed a dataset of approximately 8.8 million tweets from the 2013/14 UK storms and floods. Using Python-based filtering, they extracted a representative sample of 638 tweets for manual thematic coding.

Central to the methodology was mapping these communications to Faulkner’s Disaster Management Lifecycle (DML), which categorizes events into six phases: Pre-Event, Prodromal (imminent), Emergency, Intermediate, Long Term, and Resolution. This allowed the authors to observe how public discourse shifts as a disaster progresses from an imminent threat to an emergency and eventually into recovery.

Thematic Framework

The researchers identified 25 "Basic Themes" which were aggregated into three "Organised Themes" to capture the nature of the discourse:

  1. Subjective and Critical: Emotional or urgent statements including warnings, sympathy, and complaints.
  2. Informative and Supportive: Practical information shared with a helpful tone, such as preparation tips.
  3. Objective and Instructive: Factual, logistical data like school closures or transport updates.
Thematic categorization of social media content during the UK storms and floods.

Results and Discussion

The analysis revealed a distinct shift in the type of content shared as the crisis evolved. In December 2013, "Subjective and Critical" tweets were the most prevalent. However, as the flooding persisted into January and February 2014, "Informative and Supportive" and "Objective and Instructive" categories grew in proportion, reflecting a shift toward community resilience and logistical management.

Percentage of tweet types across the three months of the disaster period.

A key finding was the cyclical nature of the disaster. The 2013/14 floods did not follow a linear path through the DML; instead, the crisis frequently "reset" from recovery phases back to imminent threat phases as successive storms hit. Twitter activity mirrored these cycles, with volume peaking in February 2014, which accounted for 65% of the analyzed data.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that social media provides a nuanced record of public sentiment and needs that extends beyond tactical alerts. While objective data is crucial for immediate response, "Subjective" tweets offer invaluable insights for the recovery phase by highlighting public dissatisfaction and specific pain points. Future work aims to use these manually identified themes to train machine learning classifiers, enabling disaster managers to monitor public sentiment in real-time and improve long-term resilience policies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social Networks such as Twitter are often used for disseminating and collecting information during natural disasters. The potential for its use in Disaster Management has been acknowledged. However, more nuanced understanding of the communications that take place on social networks are required to more effectively integrate this information into the processes within disaster management. The type and value of information shared should be assessed, determining the benefits and issues, with credibility and reliability as known concerns. Mapping the tweets in relation to the modelled stages of a disaster can be a useful evaluation for determining the benefits/drawbacks of using data from social networks, such as Twitter, in disaster management. A thematic analysis of tweets' content, language and tone during the UK Storms and Floods 2013/14 was conducted. Manual scripting was used to determine the official sequence of events, and classify the stages of the disaster into the phases of the Disaster Management Lifecycle, to produce a timeline. Twenty-five topics discussed on Twitter emerged, and three key types of tweets, based on the language and tone, were identified. The timeline represents the events of the disaster, according to the Met Office reports, classed into B. Faulkner's Disaster Management Lifecycle framework. Context is provided when observing the analysed tweets against the timeline. This illustrates a potential basis and benefit for mapping tweets into the Disaster Management Lifecycle phases. Comparing the number of tweets submitted in each month with the timeline, suggests users tweet more as an event heightens and persists. Furthermore, users generally express greater emotion and urgency in their tweets. This paper concludes that the thematic analysis of content on social networks, such as Twitter, can be useful in gaining additional perspectives for disaster management. It demonstrates that mapping tweets into the phases of a Disaster Management Lifecycle model can have benefits in the recovery phase, not just in the response phase, to potentially improve future policies and activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{parsons2015thematically,
  author = {Sophie Parsons and Peter M. Atkinson and Elena Simperl and Mark J. Weal},
  title = {{Thematically Analysing Social Network Content During Disasters Through the Lens of the Disaster Management Lifecycle}},
  booktitle = {The Web Conference},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1145/2740908.2741721},
}
Figure